Letter

Kenny S. Crump and Harvey J. Clewell

Environ Corporation Ruston, LA 71270

To the Editor:

Waddell (2003)Go claimed evidence of "a clear and consistent threshold" for bladder and liver cancer in the large ED01 carcinogenicity study. Waddell’s method involved graphing the excess percentage of tumors versus the dose expressed as the number of molecules per kg body weight per day, and noting that these graphs showed no increase until the dose increased from 1 molecule up to something on the order of 1020 molecules, and then rose almost vertically from that point.

This method is highly flawed. Clearly, there could be no increased responses in the 19-log dose range below 1019 molecules because there were no doses in that range. The "very steep slopes" indicated by Waddell are a visual artifact resulting from his scale in which only about a 1/4 inch of abscissa represents a tenfold increase in dose. Even a linear dose response will produce graphs like those of Waddell when plotted in the same manner. To illustrate, Figure AGo shows a straight line that passes through the origin plotted between doses of 1018 and 1019 molecules/kg/day. Figure BGo shows the same line plotted using Waddell’s method. Although Waddell’s method would conclude that a threshold exists at about 1018 molecules/kg/day, this conclusion is clearly not justified. Waddell’s method will produce similar graphs whether or not there is a threshold.



View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
 
 

REFERENCE

Waddell, W. J. (2003). Thresholds of carcinogenicity in the ED01 study. Toxicol. Sci. 72, 158–163.[Abstract/Free Full Text]





This Article
Extract
FREE Full Text (PDF)
All Versions of this Article:
74/2/485    most recent
kfg117v1
Alert me when this article is cited
Alert me if a correction is posted
Services
Email this article to a friend
Similar articles in this journal
Similar articles in ISI Web of Science
Similar articles in PubMed
Alert me to new issues of the journal
Add to My Personal Archive
Download to citation manager
Search for citing articles in:
ISI Web of Science (5)
Disclaimer
Request Permissions
Google Scholar
Articles by Crump, K. S.
Articles by Clewell, H. J.
PubMed
PubMed Citation
Articles by Crump, K. S.
Articles by Clewell, H. J.