1 Henry Wellcome Ancient Biomolecules Centre, Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PS, UK
2 Centre for Infection, Institute of Cell and Molecular Science, Barts and The London, Queen Mary's School of Medicine and Dentistry, 64 Turner St, London E1 2AD, UK
3 Museum of London, 46 Eagle Wharf Road, London N1 7ED, UK
4 Laboratory of Biological Anthropology, Institute of Forensic Pathology, University of Copenhagen, 1017, Copenhagen, Denmark
5 Defence Science and Technology Laboratory, Porton Down, Salisbury, Wiltshire, SP4 0JQ, UK
Correspondence
Michael B. Prentice
m.b.prentice{at}qmul.ac.uk
![]() |
ABSTRACT |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Details of all cloned bacterial DNA sequences and database matches and specific details of PCR cycles are available in Microbiology Online.
Present address: Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Arizona, 1041 E Lowell St, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA.
![]() |
INTRODUCTION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
The aetiology of the Black Death is of major historical interest, but there are other significant consequences of resolving the issue of attribution. Knowledge of aetiology is important to understand any possible evolutionary impact of the associated mortality (Stephens et al., 1998) and to assess our ability to control any similar contemporary disease. Many scientific resources are now available to fight a future re-emerging human pandemic of Y. pestis infection. Well-established protocols exist to diagnose, treat and prevent transmission (WHO, 1999
), the genome has been sequenced (Parkhill et al., 2001
; Deng et al., 2002
) and a subunit vaccine is in clinical trials (Titball & Williamson, 2001
). These resources would be ineffective if a re-emerged Black Death had a different aetiology. Therefore, for historical and public health reasons alone, independent replication of the observations of Y. pestis DNA in ancient remains from a small geographical area seems desirable. The nature of ancient DNA (aDNA) evidence makes independent confirmation a necessity.
The study of aDNA involves extraction and analysis of DNA from the remains of organisms preserved as fossils, skeletons or mummified tissues. Pathogen DNA has been reported in a range of ancient animal and human remains. Many of the reports are from skeletons exhibiting paleopathological evidence of the disease. This includes reports of Mycobacterium leprae DNA from skeletal remains (Rafi et al., 1994) and DNA from various members of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex from human skeletal (Salo et al., 1994
; Taylor et al., 1996
), bison skeletal (Rothschild et al., 2001
) and human mummified tissue (Nerlich et al., 1997
; Fletcher et al., 2003a
, b
). In most of these cases structurally un-modified bone also yielded mycobacterial DNA. In the case of Y. pestis, fatal infection would not be expected to leave any specific bony changes, so no osteological confirmation is available and any retrospective diagnosis is completely DNA-based.
aDNA studies are hampered by extremely low levels of DNA preservation, often coupled with the presence of much greater levels of modern contaminants. Characteristically, only short aDNA fragments (less than 300 bp) can be amplified (Richards et al., 1995; Höss et al., 1996
; Hofreiter et al., 2001
) and easy amplification of longer fragments is an indication that contamination has occurred. Contaminants normally arise from three sources; (i) modern equivalents of the source species, (ii) previously PCR-amplified DNA (amplicons) from the source species, or (iii) similar species in the environment (of especial importance in the study of micro-organisms) (Gutierrez & Marin, 1998
). Unrecognized contamination as a source for positive results is so insidious and difficult to prevent that in many cases it only comes to light when results from one laboratory cannot be confirmed by other groups and a laboratory-specific contaminant is revealed (Austin et al., 1997
; Gutierrez & Marin, 1998
). A series of strict criteria have been proposed for research standards in this field (Cooper & Poinar, 2000
). Possibly the most important of these criteria is the independent replication of results by other groups.
Two studies from the same research group have been published reporting the successful extraction, amplification and direct sequencing from PCR products of Y. pestis-specific DNA retrieved from the dental pulp cavities of plague victims (Drancourt et al., 1998; Raoult et al., 2000
). Findings that pathogen-specific DNA can be recovered from this source in systemically infected animals (Aboudharam et al., 2000
) have led Drancourt et al. (1998)
to hypothesize that teeth provide a lasting, contamination-free refuge where pathogen aDNA may survive.
This study presents the results of attempts by two independent research groups to amplify and sequence ancient Y. pestis DNA from human teeth. Samples were obtained from five archaeological sites in Northern Europe and were analysed using a range of PCR primers that were designed to be Y. pestis-specific. Three methods of aDNA extraction are also both directly and indirectly compared in order to assess the suitability of each method in preventing contamination of the DNA source.
![]() |
METHODS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
|
Royal Mint site.
Purchase and consecration of land for a burial ground at East Smithfield (to the east of the walled city of London) is recorded during the first Black Death epidemic of 1349 (Hawkins, 1990). The East Smithfield cemetery on the site of the old Royal Mint was excavated between June 1986 and June 1988 revealing a mass burial pit, two mass burial trenches and 14 rows of stratigraphically contemporary individual graves. A total of 600 individuals were excavated and these were the source for our specimens. Previous studies on these remains have provided much useful archaeological and anthropological data on Black Death plague victims (Hawkins, 1990
; Waldron, 2001
). Royal Mint samples are referred to as RM in this study.
Verdun site.
Excavations in Verdun, north-eastern France, of the Hospice Sainte Catherine on a monastery site revealed several multiple graves and two burial pits containing 21 and 26 individuals, respectively. Burial pits of this kind on ancient hospital sites are associated with fatal disease epidemics. The teeth processed were from the larger burial pit, dated from clothing remnants and other artefacts to be from the late 17th/early 18th century. Monastery archives document 16 outbreaks of plague on the site from the 16th to the 18th century, making this a probable plague pit. Verdun samples are referred to as VE in this study.
Angers site.
Minor earthworks in the Place de la Paix, Angers, France, in 2001 revealed a mass grave of up to 1000 individuals that was not recorded in the city archives. Although archaeological analysis has not yet been undertaken, the large scale and unrecorded nature of the burial site represents a catastrophic event in a city noted for multiple severe plague outbreaks (Scott & Duncan, 2001), making this a possible plague pit. Angers samples are referred to as AN in this study.
Spitalfields site.
The Spitalfields site is located just outside the walls of Roman and medieval London. The main medieval findings relate to the priory and hospital of St Mary Spital founded in 1197 and dissolved by Henry VIII in 1538. Excavation by the Museum of London 19992001 revealed a large burial ground adjacent to the hospital that appears to have been in use throughout this period. One region of the burial ground is a mass grave with multiple skeletons buried together in a disorderly fashion suggesting mortality in a major epidemic. Carbon-14 dating of remains from this part of the excavation assigns them to the late 13th century (i.e. slightly earlier than 1349 when the Black Death was first recognized in London). Spitalfields samples are referred to as SP in this study.
DNA extraction and analysis.
Samples were analysed independently by two groups to control for laboratory-specific failures, Oxford University's Ancient Biomolecules Centre (ABC) and St Bartholomew's Hospital (SBH), London. The ABC is a dedicated aDNA facility where no work on modern DNA is ever undertaken. At SBH, most aDNA extraction and PCR set-up was undertaken in a specialized virology laboratory where no bacterial work is undertaken. Strict aDNA protocols were followed by both groups (Cooper & Poinar, 2000). This included the independent analysis of pairs of teeth from eight individuals excavated at three archaeological sites by both groups.
Assessment of dentine extraction techniques to minimize DNA extract contamination.
Teeth samples must be powdered prior to DNA extraction. To remove surface contamination teeth were treated with bleach those used at the ABC through immersion for 10 min in 50 % bleach solution, those at SBH were wiped but not immersed in 50 % bleach. Post-cleansing all teeth were exposed to UV light at 325 nm for 20 min. Three methods of tooth dentine extraction were then performed at the ABC to compare efficiency at (a) preventing contamination entering the DNA extract and (b) retrieving DNA.
(i) Eighteen teeth (14VE/2YO/2CP) were directly ground into powder (ground) using a microdismembrator (Braun).
(ii) Nine teeth (5VE/2YO/2CP) were powdered using the method pioneered by Drancourt et al. (1998). This consists of pulp cavity removal by scraping with a dental tool following longitudinal fracturing of teeth (scraped).
(iii) Fifty-three teeth (5AN/2RM/2SP/44CP) were encased in silicone rubber (silicone) prior to the removal of dentine with a dental drill as reported in Gilbert et al. (2003b) (Fig. 1
). This method of powder extraction was developed due to concerns about the efficiency of contaminant removal from the porous outer surface teeth and that surviving contaminant DNA may be transferred to extractions as the teeth are handled.
|
To directly compare extracts from scraped and ground teeth, seven teeth from seven individuals were first scraped, following which the remains were ground. To compare all three methods, two teeth were taken from each of two individuals. The first tooth from each individual was scraped to remove some dentine, after which the remainder of the tooth was ground (as above). Dentine was removed from the second tooth using the silicone method. As a further control, two of the samples that were scraped then ground were from the burial site at York that is not believed to have contained victims of the plague.
DNA extractions at the ABC.
DNA extractions on the powdered samples followed a standard phenol/chloroform method modified for aDNA samples, as described by Cooper et al. (2001).
Dentine removal at SBH.
In total 39 medieval teeth were examined at SBH. Teeth were wiped with bleach and then exposed to UV light as at the ABC. The scrape method used in the initial Y. pestis aDNA study (Drancourt et al., 1998) was used to obtain dentine for DNA extraction from 17 medieval specimens and two 19th century Farringdon control teeth (DNA extractions BT1BT24). Subsequently the ABC silicone encasement technique was adopted for 22 further teeth (DNA extractions BT25BT46).
DNA extractions at SBH.
DNA extractions BT1BT10 employed the technique described in the study by Drancourt et al. (1998). DNA extractions BT12BT24 employed a different method, whereby dentine was placed into 1·5 ml DNA extraction buffer (5 M guanidinium isocyanate, 1·3 % Triton X-100, 0·1 M Tris/HCl pH 6·4, 0·02 M EDTA pH 8·2) and agitated at 48 °C overnight. Subsequently DNA recovery followed a silica-based extraction protocol (Boom et al., 1990
) modified for aDNA (Höss et al., 1996
). An intermediate pre-amplification step after DNA extraction and before PCR using random 15-mers following the method of Zhang et al. (1992)
was also applied to these specimens only (BT12BT24) and not to any other specimens processed. The remaining DNA extractions (BT25BT46) were undertaken using a commercial kit (GENECLEAN Kit for Ancient DNA; Qbiogene).
PCR amplification
Primers.
The presence of Y. pestis DNA in DNA extracts was monitored using PCR amplification, followed by cloning and sequencing where relevant. Primers, taken from both published aDNA studies, and of new design, were employed against three bacterial targets. One of these was not specific for Y. pestis targeting part of the 16S rRNA gene. The other two were Y. pestis-specific: the plasmid-encoded plasminogen activator gene (pla) and the chromosomal RNA polymerase -subunit-encoding gene (rpoB). All primer sets were optimized on a small sample of extractions. Samples were also assayed for endogenous human DNA using a selection of human mitochondrial Hyper Variable Region 1 (HVR-1) and nuclear
-globin DNA primers. For full primer details refer to Table 2
. Specific details of PCR cycles are available in Microbiology Online (http://mic.sgmjournals.org).
|
PCR amplification, cloning and sequence analysis ABC.
The amplification, re-amplification, cloning and PCR methodology used at the ABC are as reported elsewhere (Cooper et al., 2001). Where PCR products yielded multiple DNA bands, those of the expected size were excised from the gel for purification and re-amplification. All PCR products of the expected size were sequenced. Twenty-three PCR products from the ABC were also cloned prior to sequencing. Attempts were made to identify all sequences using the NCBI BLAST tool.
PCR amplification, cloning and sequence analysis SBH.
At SBH initial PCR (DNA extracts BT1BT10) was performed with AmpliTaq (Applied Biosystems), later switching to AmpliTaq Gold (Applied Biosystems) (DNA extracts BT12BT24) and latterly Platinum Taq Hifidelity (Invitrogen) (DNA extracts BT25BT46) as at the ABC. In all cases, PCR was performed in 25 µl volumes with 1 µl DNA extract. For DNA extracts BT1BT24, the PCR mix comprised 2·5 units of Taq in Perkin Elmer PCR buffer with 1·5 mM MgCl2, 200 µM of each dNTP and 2 µM of each oligonucleotide primer.
![]() |
RESULTS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
|
|
|
|
Human PCR results
Human amplification products of the expected size were obtained in 53 out of 89 mitochondrial amplifications performed at the ABC, and in three out of 39 nuclear amplifications performed at SBH. No extraction blanks at the ABC yielded human DNA. Nevertheless, no attempt was made to sequence human products from samples extracted without silicone encasement at the ABC, due to the obvious bacterial, and therefore likely human sample, contamination. All human sequences are commonly found among Europeans and do not match any member of the ABC laboratory (data not shown). As this study has only a marginal interest in human DNA, the authenticity of the mitochondrial DNA amplified and cloned at the ABC has not been as exhaustively tested as would be appropriate in a study of human evolution. At SBH, nine out of 22 mitochondrial DNA amplifications yielded bands of the expected size. However, extraction blanks and the PCR control also yielded bands with this PCR. Cloning and sequencing of a contaminating band from one of the extraction controls and bands obtained from two teeth from different test subjects showed the contaminating band to be human mitochondrial DNA distinct both from that found in the two test subjects and also the individual who performed the DNA extraction and PCR.
At SBH no positive amplification results were obtained in the -globin control PCR following adoption of the silicone-encasement technique and the use of a commercial kit for DNA extraction (specimens BT25BT46). One microlitre of DNA extract was added to a control PCR for a TEM
-lactamase gene (Essack et al., 2001
) containing 4·3 pg of target DNA (PCR carried out in 25 µl volumes with Platinum Taq DNA polymerase as for the ABC standard method) to ensure that negative results in this assay and assays for Y. pestis-specific DNA were not due to PCR inhibitors in the DNA extracts. PCR inhibition was detected in two out of 22 tested extracts.
![]() |
DISCUSSION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Absence of authentic Y. pestis DNA in the samples
No evidence for surviving Y. pestis DNA was found in this study, despite the examination of a large number of samples from five mass graves, including two well-documented plague pits and several other probable plague-victim burial sites. This result strongly contrasts with previous studies (Drancourt et al., 1998; Raoult et al., 2000
). PCR amplification using Y. pestis-specific primers did produce amplicons, though not of Y. pestis DNA. Similarly, cloned amplicons from the non-specific bacterial 16S rDNA revealed sequences that matched a variety of bacteria. While two cloned 16S rDNA sequence fragments obtained with one set of primers resembled Y. pestis, and although this short amplicon incorporates a variable loop that can be used to distinguish species of bacteria, the sequence was shared by at least seven different prokaryotes belonging to three genera found on the Ribosomal Database Project II web site (http://rdp.cme.msu.edu/html/) and numerous other bacterial sequences in the NCBI BLAST database (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/blast/). The database matches of most 16S rDNA sequences obtained suggest the contaminating DNA probably originates in contemporary soil bacteria, rather than authentic aDNA sources (see supplementary data). Evidence to support this hypothesis includes the lack of post-mortem damage-driven sequence variation observed among multiple clones of the same species (Pääbo, 1989
), the large size of fragments obtained (Pääbo, 1989
) and, most importantly, the presence of micro-organism DNA where human DNA cannot be amplified.
The human DNA bears characteristics that suggest authenticity, including the observed consistency of amplified sequences and the observed spectrum of damage within the human cloned sequences (Pääbo, 1989; Gilbert et al., 2003a
), the pattern of nuclear to mitochondrial DNA survival (Hofreiter et al., 2001
) and the appropriate behaviour of negative controls and extraction blanks (Cooper & Poinar, 2000
). However, it is very difficult to guarantee the authenticity of aDNA from human samples (cf. Handt et al., 1996
; Cooper, 1997
; Kolman & Tuross, 2000
; Hofreiter et al., 2001
), thus it is possible that the human results are derived from contaminant DNA. Such a case would add support to the conclusion that the amplified bacterial DNA is from modern environmental contaminants.
In contrast to our findings, previous studies reported successful direct sequencing of Y. pestis-specific PCR products (Drancourt et al., 1998; Raoult et al., 2000
) from ancient teeth. This implies a low level of contaminating non-Y. pestis bacterial DNA, despite using a dentine extraction method that this study has demonstrated to be contamination-prone. Two questions therefore need to be answered. Firstly, why such levels of contaminating DNA from bacteria other than Y. pestis are found in our study, even when Y. pestis specific primers, high-fidelity enzymes, dedicated aDNA facilities, rigorous cleaning and established extraction techniques are used. Secondly, why it was not possible to amplify Y. pestis-specific DNA from samples of plague victims that yield what appears to be authentic human DNA.
A tempting explanation for the discrepancy between the results is heterogeneity between archaeological sites. Samples studied in this work were obtained from north-western European locations, which differ environmentally from the relatively warmer and drier southern French locations of the previous studies. It is possible, therefore, that the diagenetic conditions at the southern locations were conducive to ancient Y. pestis survival and that local environmental bacteria do not share amplifiable DNA similarities with Y. pestis. Several possible flaws can be identified with this hypothesis. aDNA studies have repeatedly demonstrated that an inverse correlation exists between average temperature of archaeological site, humidity and aDNA retrieval (Höss et al., 1996). It is surprising that samples used in the two successful studies were from warmer locations than those used here. An alternative environmental variable to consider is that the samples analysed in this study can be expected to have experienced more groundwater. Although this has not been directly implicated in aDNA survival, Nielsen-Marsh & Hedges (2000)
note an inverse correlation of sample exposure to water and aDNA survival. However, the ability to amplify what appears to be endogenous human aDNA from extracts suggests host DNA survival is not an issue. The reduced rate of amplification of DNA associated with environmental bacteria from the pulp of silicone-encased and drilled teeth compared with glove-handled split teeth suggests that the pulp is indeed relatively protected from environmental contamination, whether arising due to water penetration while in the soil or as a result of handling during processing. The wetter northern environments may harbour a specific range of micro-organisms that share amplifiable similarities with Y. pestis. However, with increasing numbers of scientists suggesting global dispersion of micro-organisms (Finlay & Clarke, 1999
; Finlay et al., 1999
), it appears strange the two (globally close) environments should differ so much in micro-organism content.
A further explanation is that the individuals from whom the samples derive were either infected by a Y. pestis strain lacking the plasmid-located sites for amplification or not infected with Y. pestis (because they were not victims of the Black Death, or because the infection did not seed the pulp cavity, or because the Black Death and subsequent plagues were not caused by Y. pestis). The first hypothesis is unlikely, as although some Y. pestis plasmids may vary between strains, the plasmid containing the pla gene is a consistent feature of contemporary Y. pestis isolates (Filippov et al., 1990). In addition, a Y. pestis chromosomal target (rpoB) was employed for the ABC-processed teeth. If the 66 selected individuals were not infected by Y. pestis but were surrounded by infected individuals, then this would be a most unusual sampling error. The second hypothesis is plausible. There is no guarantee that bacteria causing a systemic infection entered the teeth of infected individuals, even if individuals were infected with Y. pestis. Contemporary microbiological studies with dental pulp (primarily but not exclusively in the context of dental caries) are able to both directly culture and obtain DNA by PCR from various anaerobes and streptococci (Hoshino et al., 1992
; Conrads et al., 1997
; Bate et al., 2000
), i.e. typical oral bacteria. It has been demonstrated that DNA specific to Coxiella burnetii could be detected in dental pulp of five out of 10 guinea pigs 1520 days after intraperitoneal injection with the bacteria (Aboudharam et al., 2000
). However, in no animal were blood cultures and dental pulp PCR positive at the same time. Consequently, the relationship between bacteraemia and pulp colonization is not straightforward and it is possible that Y. pestis may not have been present in the teeth specimens but Y. pestis infection still caused death.
The third hypothesis that the Black Death was not caused by Y. pestis is controversial (Scott & Duncan, 2001; Cohn, 2002
), but cannot be immediately discounted. Recent re-examinations of the epidemiology of the Black Death from contemporary descriptions and mortality records have suggested that it does not correspond to the illness referred to as bubonic plague and that the organism responsible was therefore not Y. pestis (Scott & Duncan, 2001
; Cohn, 2002
). These authors argue that instead of the cumbersome ratflea vector system of Y. pestis infections, a more direct person-to-person spread of the disease is required to cause the predominantly city-based outbreaks with subsequent rapid spread over long distances. They also postulate that the illness itself, presenting multiple haemorrhagic skin lesions (tokens) and killing 4050 % of the population, does not convincingly resemble microbiologically confirmed bubonic plague in the pre-antibiotic era. The proponents of these hypotheses regard the molecular evidence of the Marseille group as either relevant only to distinct local outbreaks of bubonic plague in Marseille and other parts of Provence (Scott & Duncan, 2001
) or in need of independent corroboration (Cohn, 2002
). Scott & Duncan (2001)
instead suggest that the Black Death was a form of viral haemorrhagic fever, a group of emerging infections caused predominantly by RNA Filoviruses (Khan et al., 1998
). If so, they would be impossible to identify by current techniques on available remains from Black Death victims [viral RNA extraction and successful RT-PCR from historical specimens has only been recorded from frozen or formalin-preserved organs (Taubenberger et al., 1997
; Reid et al., 1999
; Basler et al., 2001
)].
In contrast to our findings, all but one individual tested from three different locations in southern France in the previous studies yielded positive PCR amplifications of fragments of the Y. pestis pla or rpoB genes (Drancourt et al., 1998; Raoult et al., 2000
). The authors also report in their second publication a higher percentage of the older erupted teeth to be positive for Y. pestis-specific DNA (20 out of 23 teeth positive) than the more recent unerupted teeth used in the first publication (8 out of 13 teeth positive). This pattern of results seems surprising for several reasons. Firstly, during an epidemic, not all deaths can be expected to arise due to the specific pathogen (Kiple, 1993
). Thus, as increasing numbers of specimens are examined, the chance of analysing authentic uninfected remains increases. Therefore, it seems unlikely that, among the eight individuals sampled in these two studies, only one negative for Y. pestis DNA was observed. Secondly, preservation of Y. pestis DNA in nearly all teeth from infected individuals is unlikely due to the nature of DNA degradation. Pfeiffer et al. (1999)
observed that storage of teeth in soil for only 6 weeks leads to a decrease in extractable endogenous DNA by 90 %. Therefore, aDNA tests for bacterial infection can be expected to demonstrate a proportion of false-negative results. For example, independently replicated M. tuberculosis aDNA assays on comparably old specimens that display characteristic diagnostic bony lesions did not yield 100 % positive results (Haas et al., 2000
) despite the robust successfulness of assays for mycobacterial aDNA in various laboratories (Zink et al., 2001
; Haas et al., 2000
; Rothschild et al., 2001
; Spigelman et al., 2002
; Fletcher et al., 2003a
, b
). We have found no published data on long-term preservation of aDNA from Enterobacteriaceae in human specimens, other than the Marseille group's publications on Y. pestis. Evidence of rapid Y. pestis DNA degradation over short periods of time is provided in the article from which the original pla PCR assay was developed [an assay for Y. pestis in infected fleas (Hinnebusch & Schwan, 1993
)]. After 5 months storage, sensitivity of the original assay dropped from 100 to 90 % in fleas stored at -20 °C, and to 55 % in fleas stored at room temperature in ethanol (Hinnebusch & Schwan, 1993
). Although the target in this original assay was larger (478 bp) than the 300 and 150 bp targets used by ourselves and the Marseille group, pla target aDNA preservation over five centuries in soil at Mediterranean ambient temperatures would have to be remarkably better than this to yield the positivity rate of 20 out of 23 14th century teeth that they describe (Raoult et al., 2000
). Another factor suggesting excellent DNA preservation in southern France is the detection of rpoB in the first publication (Drancourt et al., 1998
), albeit by two rounds of PCR. One of the reasons pla is used as a target for current Y. pestis detection assays is the high copy number of the pPst (pesticin) plasmid on which it is located over 100 per bacterium (Parkhill et al., 2001
). In contrast, rpoB is a single copy chromosomal gene (Parkhill et al., 2001
), a relatively poorly represented target which is not used as the basis for any current assays for Y. pestis pre-culture diagnosis.
Poor laboratory technique may explain our results, as could differences in the methodologies used here and previously. However, similar results are found by two independent laboratories, one of which is a facility dedicated to aDNA research and has published numerous replicated aDNA studies (e.g. Cooper et al., 2001; Shapiro et al., 2002
; Barnes et al., 2002
; Endicott et al., 2003
; Gilbert et al., 2003a
, b
). Secondly, the lack of contaminant DNA sequence variation observed between samples from one archaeological site and the much larger sequence variation between different sites points to the presence of contaminants in samples prior to extraction. Lastly, the techniques used here include the use of the modified PCR enzyme Platinum Taq Hifidelity (as opposed to standard Taq polymerases). The increased yields and successes of aDNA amplifications performed using this enzyme have been noted previously (Willerslev et al., 1999
; Hansen et al., 2001
; Gilbert et al., 2003a
) especially in amplifying low-copy-number DNA.
It is possible that the DNA sequences presented previously (Drancourt et al., 1998; Raoult et al., 2000
) derive from the contamination of DNA extracts with formerly amplified or extracted Y. pestis DNA. Other examples exist of pioneering bacterial aDNA studies that could not be replicated and may have resulted from unsuspected contamination. Christner et al. (2000)
reported unsuccessful attempts at replicating aDNA detection from bacteria within Greenland ice cores (Catranis & Starmer, 1991
; Ma et al., 1999
). Graur & Pupko (2001)
and Nickle et al. (2002)
have been unable to replicate detection of the 250 million-year-old halotolerant bacterium of Vreeland et al. (2000)
.
The previous Y. pestis aDNA studies were undertaken in a busy facility not dedicated to aDNA work, where numerous other bacteriological studies are undertaken, and initially using a positive control of modern Y. pestis DNA, all of which are risk factors for contamination. However, occurrence of contamination in aDNA work even under the most stringent conditions is well documented (Handt et al., 1996; Kolman, 1999
; Kolman & Tuross, 2000
; Hofreiter et al., 2001
). In our own study, the use of a modified positive control in the SBH laboratory (a non-dedicated aDNA set-up comparable to that used by the Marseille group) has resulted in contamination problems with bacterial DNA. This clear occurrence of selective contamination where, importantly, negative controls remained blank is especially revealing. This phenomenon, termed the carrier effect, and the dangers of relying on negative controls are discussed elsewhere (Cooper, 1994
; Handt et al., 1994
; Kolman, 1999
). Raoult et al. (2000)
developed suicide PCR to avoid the possibility of amplicon contamination, but this technique is not resilient to contamination by fragments of extracted modern DNA, from any organism sharing the DNA sequence of interest.
Conclusion
This study has failed to replicate previous reports of specific Y. pestis DNA amplification from dental pulp residues extracted from historical plague victims. Analyses of 16S rDNA PCR products reveal a wide variety of bacterial DNA in the extracts from teeth prepared using the previous method. An improved method has been developed for pulp-cavity sampling, which resulted in a reduced number of amplicons from apparent environmental contaminants, and it is recommended that future studies consider adopting the approach, which is cheap, simple and effective.
It is difficult to interpret the previous reports of almost uniform positive results, when similar techniques reveal the non-specificity of supposedly Y. pestis-specific primers in this application, the ease of positive control cross-contamination and the apparent lack of Y. pestis DNA in samples that yield human DNA, from well-documented archaeological plague sites. Only a minority of published ancient pathogen DNA studies clearly indicate that they have involved independent replication by separate laboratories. Most of the replicated reports concern successful amplification of M. tuberculosis from skeletal remains or mummified tissue (Zink et al., 2001; Haas et al., 2000
; Rothschild et al., 2001
; Spigelman et al., 2002
; Fletcher et al., 2003a
, b
). The special properties of M. tuberculosis that enable lengthy persistence in the body as a latent infection have been suggested to preserve its DNA after the death of its host (Fletcher et al., 2003a
). There is no evidence that Y. pestis can cause persistent latent disease in humans. Independent replication seems particularly necessary when attempting novel retrospective diagnosis of diseases that cause rapid death and leave no specific bony changes. Authoritative aDNA evidence offers the only conclusive method to match current pathogens with ancient epidemics of disease, but misleading DNA data are very easily generated from contemporary bacteria. For these reasons we believe that until an independently replicated, successful study on Y. pestis aDNA is undertaken in a suitable, controlled environment, meeting best practice guidelines in aDNA research (Cooper & Poinar, 2000
), it is premature to claim (Drancourt & Raoult, 2002
; Raoult & Drancourt, 2002
) that aDNA studies have unequivocally proved Y. pestis to be the cause of the Black Death and subsequent historical plagues. The aetiology of one of the major pandemics of the last millennium remains unproven by molecular techniques.
![]() |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
---|
![]() |
REFERENCES |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Austin, J. J., Ross, A. J., Smith, A. B., Fortey, R. A. & Thomas, R. H. (1997). Problems of reproducibility does geologically ancient DNA survive in amber-preserved insects? Proc R Soc Lond B Biol Sci 264, 467474.[CrossRef][Medline]
Barnes, I., Matheus, P., Shapiro, B., Jensen, D. & Cooper, A. (2002). Dynamics of mammal population extinctions in Eastern Beringia during the last glaciation. Science 295, 22672270.
Basler, C. F., Reid, A. H., Dybing, J. K. & 9 other authors (2001). Sequence of the 1918 pandemic influenza virus nonstructural gene (NS) segment and characterization of recombinant viruses bearing the 1918 NS genes. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 98, 27462751.
Bate, A. L., Ma, J. K. & Pitt Ford, T. R. (2000). Detection of bacterial virulence genes associated with infective endocarditis in infected root canals. Int Endod J 33, 194203.[CrossRef][Medline]
Boom, R., Sol, C. J., Salimans, M. M., Jansen, C. L., Wertheim-van Dillen, P. M. & van der Noordaa, J. (1990). Rapid and simple method for purification of nucleic acids. J Clin Microbiol 28, 495503.[Medline]
Catranis, C. & Starmer, W. T. (1991). Microorganisms entrapped in glacial ice. Antarct J U S 26, 324326.
Christner, B. C., Mosley-Thompson, E., Thompson, L. G., Zagorodnov, V., Sandman, K. & Reeve, J. N. (2000). Recovery and identification of viable bacteria immured in glacial ice. Icarus 144, 479485.[CrossRef]
Cohn, S. (2002). The Black Death Transformed: Disease and Culture in Early Renaissance Europe. London: Arnold.
Conrads, G., Gharbia, S. E., Gulabivala, K., Lampert, F. & Shah, H. N. (1997). The use of a 16S rDNA directed PCR for the detection of endodontopathogenic bacteria. J Endod 23, 433438.[Medline]
Cooper, A. (1994). DNA from museum specimens. In Ancient DNA, pp. 149165. Edited by B. Hermann & S. Hummel. New York: Springer-Verlag.
Cooper, A. (1997). Reply to Stoneking: ancient DNA how do you really known when you have it? Am J Hum Genet 60, 10011002.[Medline]
Cooper, A. & Poinar, H. N. (2000). Ancient DNA: do it right or not at all. Science 289, 1139.[Medline]
Cooper, A., Lalueza-Fox, C., Anderson, S., Rambaut, A., Austin, J. & Ward, R. (2001). Complete mitochondrial genome of two extinct moas clarify ratite evolution. Nature 409, 704707.[CrossRef][Medline]
Deng, W., Burland, V., Plunkett, G., 3rd & 18 other authors (2002). Genome sequence of Yersinia pestis KIM. J Bacteriol 184, 46014611.
Drancourt, M. & Raoult, D. (2002). Molecular insights into the history of plague. Microbes Infect 4, 105109.[CrossRef][Medline]
Drancourt, M., Aboudharam, G., Signoli, M., Dutour, O. & Raoult, D. (1998). Detection of 400-year-old Yersinia pestis DNA in human dental pulp: an approach to the diagnosis of ancient septicemia. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 95, 1263712640.
Endicott, P., Gilbert, M. T., Stringer, C., Lalueza-Fox, C., Willerslev, E., Hansen, A. J. & Cooper, A. (2003). The genetic origins of the Andaman Islanders. Am J Hum Genet 72, 178184.[CrossRef][Medline]
Essack, S. Y., Hall, L. M., Pillay, D. G., McFayden, M. L. & Livermore, D. M. (2001). Complexity and diversity of Klebsiella pneumoniae strains with extended-spectrum beta-lactamases isolated in 1994 and 1996 at a teaching hospital in Durban, South Africa. Antimicrob Agents Chemother 45, 8895.
Filippov, A. A., Solodovnikov, N. S., Kookleva, L. M. & Protsenko, O. A. (1990). Plasmid content in Yersinia pestis strains of different origin. FEMS Microbiol Lett 55, 4548.[Medline]
Finlay, B. J. & Clarke, K. J. (1999). Ubiquitous dispersal of microbial species. Nature 400, 828.[CrossRef]
Finlay, B. J., Esteban, G. F., Olmo, J. L. & Tyler, P. A. (1999). Global distribution of free-living microbial species. Ecography 22, 138144.
Fletcher, H. A., Donoghue, H. D., Holton, J., Pap, I. & Spigelman, M. (2003a). Widespread occurrence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA from 18th19th century Hungarians. Am J Phys Anthropol 120, 144152.[CrossRef][Medline]
Fletcher, H. A., Donoghue, H. D., Taylor, G. M., van der Zanden, A. G. & Spigelman, M. (2003b). Molecular analysis of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA from a family of 18th century Hungarians. Microbiology 149, 143151.
Gilbert, M. T. P., Hansen, A. J., Willerslev, E., Rudbeck, L., Barnes, I., Lynnerup, N. & Cooper, A. (2003a). Characterisation of genetic miscoding lesions caused by post mortem damage. Am J Hum Genet 72, 4861.[CrossRef][Medline]
Gilbert, M. T. P., Willerslev, E., Hansen, A. J., Rudbeck, L., Barnes, I., Lynnerup, N. & Cooper, A. (2003b). Distribution patterns of post mortem damage in human mitochondrial DNA. Am J Hum Genet 72, 3247.[CrossRef][Medline]
Graur, D. & Pupko, T. (2001). The Permian bacterium that isnt. Mol Biol Evol 18, 11431146.
Greer, C. E., Peterson, S. L., Kiviat, N. B. & Manos, M. M. (1991). PCR amplification from paraffin-embedded tissues. Effects of fixative and fixation time. Am J Clin Pathol 95, 117124.[Medline]
Gutierrez, G. & Marin, A. (1998). The most ancient DNA recovered from an amber-preserved specimen may not be as ancient as it seems. Mol Biol Evol 15, 926929.
Haas, C. J., Zink, A., Molnar, E. & 7 other authors (2000). Molecular evidence for different stages of tuberculosis in ancient bone samples from Hungary. Am J Phys Anthropol 113, 293304.[CrossRef][Medline]
Handt, O., Hoss, M., Krings, M. & Paabo, S. (1994). Ancient DNA: methodological challenges. Experientia 50, 524529.[Medline]
Handt, O., Krings, M., Ward, R. & Pääbo, S. (1996). The retrieval of ancient human DNA sequences. Am J Hum Genet 59, 368376.[Medline]
Hansen, A., Willerslev, E., Wiuf, C., Mourier, T. & Arctander, P. (2001). Statistical evidence for miscoding lesions in ancient DNA templates. Mol Biol Evol 18, 262265.
Hawkins, D. (1990). The Black Death and the new London cemeteries of 1348. Antiquity 60, 637642.
Hinnebusch, J. & Schwan, T. G. (1993). New method for plague surveillance using polymerase chain reaction to detect Yersinia pestis in fleas. J Clin Microbiol 31, 15111514.[Abstract]
Hofreiter, M., Serre, D., Poinar, H. N., Kuch, M. & Pääbo, S. (2001). Ancient DNA. Nat Rev Genet 2, 353359.[CrossRef][Medline]
Hoshino, E., Naomi, A., Michiko, S. & Kohichi, K. (1992). Bacterial invasion of non-exposed dental pulp. Int Endod J 25, 25.[Medline]
Höss, M., Jaruga, P., Zastawny, T. H., Dizdaroglu, M. & Pääbo, S. (1996). DNA damage and DNA sequence retrieval from ancient tissues. Nucleic Acids Res 24, 13041307.
Khan, A. S., Sanchez, A. & Pflieger, A. K. (1998). Filoviral haemorrhagic fevers. Br Med Bull 54, 675692.[Abstract]
Kiple, K. F. (1993). The Cambridge World History of Human Disease. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Kolman, C. J. (1999). Molecular anthropology progress and perspectives on ancient DNA technology. In Genomic Diversity: Applications in Human Population Genetics. Edited by S. S. Papiha & R. Deka. New York: Academic/Plenum Publishers.
Kolman, C. J. & Tuross, N. (2000). Ancient DNA analysis of human populations. Am J Phys Anthropol 111, 523.[Medline]
Lynnerup, N. (1992). Anthropological Report on Human Remains from Vodroffsgaard, Copenhagen, AS 3/92. On file at the Laboratory of Biological Anthropology, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Ma, L.-J., Rogers, S. O., Catranis, C. M. & Starmer, W. T. (1999). Detection and characterization of ancient fungi entrapped in glacial ice. Mycologia 92, 286295.
Nerlich, A. G., Haas, C. J., Zink, A., Szeimies, U. & Hagedorn, H. G. (1997). Molecular evidence for tuberculosis in an ancient Egyptian mummy. Lancet 350, 1404.[Medline]
Nickle, D. C., Learn, G. H., Rain, M. W., Mullins, J. I. & Mittler, J. E. (2002). Curiously modern DNA from a "250 million-year-old" bacterium. J Mol Evol 54, 134137.[Medline]
Nielsen-Marsh, C. & Hedges, R. E. M. (2000). Patterns of diagenesis in bone I: effects of site environments. J Archaeol Sci 27, 11391150.[CrossRef]
Oota, H., Saitou, N., Matsushita, T. & Ueda, S. (1995). A genetic study of 2,000-year-old human remains from Japan using mitochondrial DNA sequences. Am J Phys Anthropol 98, 133145.[Medline]
Pääbo, S. (1989). Ancient DNA: extraction, characterization, molecular cloning, and enzymatic amplification. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 86, 19391943.[Abstract]
Parkhill, J., Wren, B. W., Thomson, N. R. & 32 other authors (2001). Genome sequence of Yersinia pestis, the causative agent of plague. Nature 413, 523527.[CrossRef][Medline]
Pfeiffer, H., Huhne, J., Seitz, B. & Brinkmann, B. (1999). Influence of soil storage and exposure period on DNA recovery from teeth. Int J Legal Med 112, 142144.[CrossRef][Medline]
Rafi, A., Spigelman, M., Stanford, J., Lemma, E., Donoghue, H. & Zias, J. (1994). Mycobacterium leprae DNA from ancient bone detected by PCR. Lancet 343, 13601361.[CrossRef]
Raoult, D. & Drancourt, M. (2002). Cause of Black Death. Lancet Infect Dis 2, 459.
Raoult, D., Aboudharam, G., Crubezy, E., Larrouy, G., Ludes, B. & Drancourt, M. (2000). Molecular identification by "suicide PCR" of Yersinia pestis as the agent of medieval black death. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 97, 1280012803.
Reid, A. H., Fanning, T. G., Hultin, J. V. & Taubenberger, J. K. (1999). Origin and evolution of the 1918 "Spanish" influenza virus hemagglutinin gene. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96, 16511656.
Richards, M., Sykes, B. & Hedges, R. (1995). Authenticating DNA extracted from ancient skeletal remains. J Archaeol Sci 22, 291299.[CrossRef]
Ringboel Bitsch, B. (1991). Archaeological Excavation Report "Vodroffsgaard", KBM 836. On file at Copenhagen City Museum, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Rothschild, B. M., Martin, L. D., Lev, G., Bercovier, H., Bar-Gal, G. K., Greenblatt, C., Donoghue, H., Spigelman, M. & Brittain, D. (2001). Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex DNA from an extinct bison dated 17,000 years before the present. Clin Infect Dis 33, 305311.[CrossRef][Medline]
Salo, W. L., Aufderheide, A. C., Buikstra, J. & Holcomb, T. A. (1994). Identification of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA in a pre-Columbian Peruvian mummy. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 91, 20912094.[Abstract]
Scott, S. & Duncan, C. (2001). Biology of Plagues: Evidence from Historical Populations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Shapiro, B., Sibthorpe, D., Rambaut, A., Austin, J., Wragg, G. M., Bininda-Emonds, O. R. P., Lee, P. L. M. & Cooper, A. (2002). Flight of the dodo. Science 295, 1683.
Spigelman, M., Matheson, C., Lev, G., Greenblatt, C. & Donoghue, H. (2002). Confirmation of the presence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex-specific DNA in three archaeological specimens. Int J Osteoarch 12, 393401.[CrossRef]
Stephens, J. C., Reich, D. E., Goldstein, D. B. & 36 other authors, (1998). Dating the origin of the CCR5-Delta32 AIDS-resistance allele by the coalescence of haplotypes. Am J Hum Genet 62, 15071515.[CrossRef][Medline]
Taubenberger, J. K., Reid, A. H., Krafft, A. E., Bijwaard, K. E. & Fanning, T. G. (1997). Initial genetic characterization of the 1918 "Spanish" influenza virus. Science 275, 17931796.
Taylor, G., Crossey, M., Saldanha, J. & Waldron, T. (1996). DNA from Mycobacterium tuberculosis identified in medieval human skeletal remains using PCR. J Archaeol Sci 23, 789799.[CrossRef]
Titball, R. W. & Williamson, E. D. (2001). Vaccination against bubonic and pneumonic plague. Vaccine 19, 41754184.[CrossRef][Medline]
Von Kohl, C. (1911). Historiske Meddelelser om København. Copenhagen, 191112. GEC Gad 3, 545614 (in Danish).
Vreeland, R. H., Rozenwieg, W. D. & Powers, D. W. (2000). Isolation of a 250 million-year-old halotolerant bacterium from a primary salt crystal. Nature 407, 897900.[CrossRef][Medline]
Waldron, H. (2001). Are plague pits of particular use to palaeoepidemiologists? Int J Epidemiol 30, 104108.
Willerslev, E., Hansen, A. J., Christensen, B., Steffensen, J. P. & Arctander, A. (1999). Diversity of Holocene life forms in fossil glacier ice. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 96, 80178021.
WHO. (1999). Plague Manual: Epidemiology, Distribution, Surveillance and Control (http://www.who.int/csr/resources/publications/plague/WHO_CDS_CSR_EDC_99_2_EN/en). Geneva: World Health Organization.
Yersin, A. (1894). La peste bubonique à Hong Kong. Ann Inst Pasteur (Paris) 8, 662667.
Zhang, L., Cui, A., Schmitt, K., Hubert, R., Navidi, W. & Amheim, N. (1992). Whole genome amplification from a single cell: implications for genetic analysis. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 89, 58475851.[Abstract]
Zink, A., Haas, C. J., Reischl, U., Szeimies, U. & Nerlich, A. G. (2001). Molecular analysis of skeletal tuberculosis in an ancient Egyptian population. J Med Microbiol 50, 355366.
Received 24 June 2003;
revised 29 September 2003;
accepted 10 October 2003.