1Department of Neurobiology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15261; and 2Departments of Pathology, Anatomy, and Neurobiology, University of Kentucky College of Medicine, Lexington, Kentucky 40536
![]() |
ABSTRACT |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Ritter, Amy M., C. Jeffery Woodbury, Kathryn Albers, Brian M. Davis, and H. Richard Koerber. Maturation of Cutaneous Sensory Neurons From Normal and NGF-Overexpressing Mice. J. Neurophysiol. 83: 1722-1732, 2000. In the rodent, cutaneous sensory neurons mature over the first two postnatal weeks, both in terms of their electrical properties and their responses to mechanical stimulation of the skin. To examine the coincidence of these events, intracellular recordings were made from neurons in the dorsal root ganglion (DRG) in an in vitro spinal cord, DRG, and skin preparation from mice between the ages of postnatal day 0 and 5 (P0-P5). We also examined mice in which nerve growth factor (NGF) is overexpressed in the skin. NGF has been shown to be involved in a number of aspects of sensory neuron development and function. Therefore we ask here whether excess target-derived NGF will alter the normal course of development, either of somal membrane properties, physiological response properties, or neuropeptide content. In wild-type mice, somal action potentials (APs) were heterogeneous, with some having simple, uninflected falling phases and some displaying an inflection or break on the falling limb. The proportion of neurons lacking an inflection increased with increasing age, as did mean conduction velocity. A variety of rapidly and slowly adapting responses could be obtained by gently probing the skin; however, due to relatively low thresholds and firing frequencies, as well as lack of mature peripheral receptors such as hairs, it was not possible to place afferents into the same categories as in the adult. No correlation was seen between the presence or absence of an inflection on the somal AP (a marker for high-threshold mechanoreceptors in adult animals) and either peripheral threshold or calcitonin-gene related peptide (CGRP) content. Small differences in the duration and amplitude of the somal AP were seen in the NGF-overexpressing mice that disappeared by P3-P5. Excess target-derived NGF did not alter physiological response properties or the types of neurons containing CGRP. The changes that did occur, including a loss of the normal relationship between AP duration and conduction velocity, and a decrease in mean conduction velocity in the inflected population, might best be explained by an increase in the relative proportions of myelinated nociceptors. Of greatest interest was the finding that in both NGF overexpressers and wild-type mice, the correlation between mechanical threshold and presence or absence of an inflection on the somal spike is not apparent by P5.
![]() |
INTRODUCTION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
The maturation of sensory neurons of the dorsal
root ganglion (DRG) takes place over a protracted period that, in the
rodent, extends into the first two postnatal weeks (Fitzgerald
and Fulton 1992). During this time, the axons of sensory
neurons become myelinated, and receptor structures in the skin mature.
Responses can be elicited from the skin as early as embryonic day
17 (E17) (Fitzgerald 1987a
); however,
the firing rates and adaptation properties of the receptors do not
fully resemble those of the adult until after postnatal day
14 (P14) (Koltzenburg et al. 1997
). The
biophysical properties of the neurons also mature over this time. Somal
action potential duration becomes shorter over the first two postnatal
weeks as conduction velocity increases. As animals mature, more neurons are encountered lacking an inflection or "hump" on the falling limb
of the somal spike (Fulton 1987
), although uninflected
neurons can be recognized as early as E19 (Mirnics
and Koerber 1997
).
In adult animals, the presence or absence of such a hump is of some
significance, because it is a reliable indicator of physiological function for myelinated afferents. Afferents responding to
high-intensity, potentially noxious stimulation of the skin
[high-threshold mechanoreceptors (HTMRs)] are always found to have an
inflected spike, whereas low-threshold mechanoreceptors that respond to
hair movement, gentle pressure, or vibration do not (Koerber et
al. 1988; Ritter and Mendell 1992
; Rose
et al. 1986
). Among unmyelinated afferents (C-fibers), there is
some species variability. In the cat (Traub and Mendell
1988
) both high-threshold and low-threshold mechanoreceptive C-fibers have inflected spikes, whereas in the mouse, a class of
physiologically unidentified C-fiber has been reported that lacks an
obvious inflection, but that possesses a very long
afterhyperpolarization (Yoshida and Matsuda 1979
;
Yoshida et al. 1978
).
The development of electrical properties and the maturation of
peripheral physiology occur in tandem and may be interrelated. How this
process is regulated is not known. However, neurotrophins have been
shown to be critically involved in a number of other aspects of sensory
neuron development and function, including the regulation of peripheral
response properties. This family of related molecules includes nerve
growth factor (NGF), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), brain-derived neurotrophic
factor (BDNF), and neurotrophin 4/5 (NT-4/5). They are produced by the
targets of sensory neurons and act embryonically to regulate
differentiation of sensory neuron precursors and mediate
target-dependent survival (reviewed in Davies 1994).
NGF, in particular, has been shown to regulate the survival,
development, and physiological response properties of nociceptors
(Mendell et al. 1999
), whereas other neurotrophins appear to regulate the survival and mechanical sensitivity of restricted subclasses of low-threshold mechanoreceptors
(Airaksinen et al. 1996
; Carroll et al.
1998
).
In the adult animal, high affinity receptors for NGF, NT3
(McMahon et al. 1994), and possibly BDNF (Wright
and Snider 1995
) are confined to largely nonoverlapping
subpopulations of sensory neurons, indicating that there may be some
specificity with regards to the subclasses of sensory neurons that
individual neurotrophins affect. However, in the neonate, the
distribution of high-affinity receptors is much more widespread, and
individual sensory neurons may respond to more than one neurotrophic
factor. For instance, TrkA, the high affinity receptor for NGF, is
found on 70-80% of neurons at birth in the rat and declines to its
adult distribution on ~40% of neurons over the first three weeks
after birth (Bennett et al. 1996
;
Molliver and Snider 1997
).
Given that TrkA is widely distributed in DRG neurons in the neonate,
and declines over the period of time that sensory neurons and their
targets are maturing, it is possible that NGF is involved in the
maturation of sensory neurons. To test this, we examined sensory
neurons from mice in which NGF is overexpressed in the skin
(Albers et al. 1994). Normally, NGF begins to be
expressed at around E11 (in whisker pads) (Davies
et al. 1987
), which is around the time that sensory axons begin
innervating the skin. NGF levels fall precipitously around
E15, which corresponds to the onset of cell death in
lumbar regions (Coggeshall et al. 1994
). In this line of
NGF overexpressers, the NGF transgene is linked to the K-14 keratin
promoter. Transgene expression begins around E11, as
endogenous NGF expression is falling, and NGF levels remain high in the
skin and other keratinized structures throughout adult life. These mice
have hypertrophied sympathetic and sensory ganglia and increased
innervation of the skin (Albers et al. 1994
;
Mendelson et al. 1996
) and, behaviorally, are
hyperalgesic (Davis et al. 1993
). In this study, we have
examined early postnatal changes that occur in the physiology of
sensory neurons. We have addressed whether the maturation of somal
membrane properties is correlated with the maturation of peripheral
physiology, and whether these changes occur normally in the presence of
excess target-derived NGF.
![]() |
METHODS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
NGF-overexpressing male mice and wild-type female mice were
obtained from the colony maintained at the University of Kentucky (Albers et al. 1994) and bred in-house at the University
of Pittsburgh animal facilities.
Mouse pups aged P0-P5 were cooled on ice, then perfused through the heart with ice-cold Ringer solution (composition in mM: 127 NaCl, 1.9 KCl, 1.2 KH2PO4, 1.3 MgSO4, 2.4 CaCl2, 26 NaHCO3, and 10 D-glucose). The animal was decapitated, eviscerated, and submerged in a recirculating, oxygenated (95% O2-5% CO2) bath of cold Ringer (17-19°C). A dorsal laminectomy was performed to expose the spinal cord, which was dissected out along with several (3-8) thoracic DRGs, attached dorsal cutaneous nerves (DCNs), and a large block of trunk skin innervated by those nerves. Spinal cord, DRGs, and skin were pinned out in a silicone elastomer (Sylgard)-coated recording chamber, superfused with oxygenated Ringer (95% O2-5% CO2), and the bath temperature was raised to 30-31°C. The skin was raised slightly to allow the circulation of fluid beneath it. Electrophysiological mapping of whole-nerve tactile fields showed the skin to be still viable up to 24 h after the initial surgery. A small-bore suction electrode was attached en passant to a DCN for stimulation.
Intracellular recordings were made from DRG neurons using thin-walled
glass electrodes filled with 1 M potassium acetate and 5% neurobiotin
with impedances of 80-100 M. When a neuron was impaled that could
be driven by stimulation of the DCN, and that had an action potential
amplitude of at least 50 mV, the skin was searched with a blunt glass
probe for the cell's receptive field. Receptive field properties were
characterized using glass probes and mechanical thresholds determined
using calibrated Von Frey hairs. Data were digitized (Neuro Data
Neuro-Corder model DR-484) and recorded on VHS tape for off-line
analysis. For each neuron, latencies to DCN stimulation, resting
membrane potential, and input resistance were measured. In addition,
single sweeps were used to measure the other action potential
parameters illustrated in Fig.
1A.
|
A single cell per ganglion was labeled with neurobiotin (75% duty cycle, 2-4 nA for 2-10 min). At the end of the experiment, DRGs were removed and fixed in 4% paraformaldehyde for 20 min, then transferred to 30% sucrose in 0.1 M phosphate buffer. Single, serial 20- to 25-µm sections were collected in small wells. Neurobiotin (Vector) was visualized using FITC-conjugated avidin (Vector, incubation of 1-2 h), and calcitonin-gene related peptide (CGRP) staining in the same sections was performed using rabbit anti-CGRP antiserum (Chemicon, overnight at 4°C). CGRP was then visualized using Cy3-conjugated goat anti-rabbit secondary. After final washes, sections were mounted and fluorescence was viewed using a Leica confocal microscope under ×100 oil. Eight optical sections were obtained through a depth of 5 µm for each fluorophore. Tissue was included in the analysis only if the following two criteria were met: only a single, brightly labeled neurobiotin-positive cell was found in the ganglion, and the quality of the CGRP staining was optimal.
![]() |
RESULTS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Intracellular recordings were made from 72 neurons in 26 wild-type mice, and 108 neurons from 10 NGF-overexpressing mouse pups. Of the 26 wild-type mice, 21 were control littermates of the transgenics, but 5 were control mice of a different strain (Swiss Webster, Hilltop). No differences were found between the cellular properties of DRG neurons in the two wild-type groups, so the results from the two strains were pooled. Within the control and NGF-overexpressing groups, data were subdivided according to age: neurons from mice aged P0-P2, and neurons from mice aged P3-P5. Within the two age groups, data were further subdivided into neurons lacking an inflection on the falling limb of the action potential (Fig. 1B), and those with an inflection (Fig. 1D). This was determined by examining the derivative of the spike (dV/dt, Fig. 1A). A truly "broad" inflected spike, such as the one in Fig. 1D, would typically have a bend of nearly 90° in the negative-going portion of the derivative, which corresponds to the change in velocity giving rise to the "hump" in the falling limb of the spike. An uninflected spike with fast kinetics such as that in Fig. 1B would have no angle at all (no change in velocity) in the negative-going part of the derivative. In some spikes, the inflection was not obvious to the naked eye, but could be detected by examining the derivative, in which a change in velocity was apparent (Fig. 1C).
A graph of conduction velocity versus baseline duration for the entire
sample from wild-type and NGF-overexpressing animals is presented in
Fig. 2. For the wild-type animals (Fig.
2A), the distribution of data points is much the same as has
been reported for DRG neurons of adult cat and rat (Harper and
Lawson 1985; Koerber et al. 1988
; Ritter
and Mendell 1992
; Villière and McLachlan 1996
). An inverse relationship between conduction velocity and baseline duration exists, such that neurons with slower conduction velocities have, on average, longer duration action potentials than
those with faster conduction velocities. As might be expected given the
incomplete state of myelination at these ages, the range of conduction
velocities sampled was much compressed compared with adults. Only a few
neurons were sampled conducting over 1 m/s, and most of these were
found in the P3-P5 age group. The graph illustrates another
feature apparent in adults: the baseline duration of uninflected
neurons is generally shorter than inflected neurons for any given
conduction velocity. Figure 2A also illustrates several
differences between the two age groups. As has been reported, baseline
duration decreased as age increased, and conduction velocity increased
(Fulton 1987
). Overall, spikes became narrower and
faster with increasing age.
|
In contrast, the plot of baseline duration versus conduction velocity for somal spikes from NGF overexpressers (Fig. 2B) did not display the clear relationship between these two parameters as in controls. All of the values for baseline duration clustered within a narrow range of conduction velocities. In Fig. 2, C and D, only the data from animals aged P3-P5 is plotted against conduction velocity, and regression lines were calculated separately for inflected and uninflected neurons. In the wild-type animals, a significant correlation was seen between conduction velocity and baseline duration for both types of cell (P < 0.01, for both). In the NGF overexpressers, a significant correlation existed for the inflected neurons (P < 0.01), but not for uninflected neurons (P > 0.5). Uninflected neurons in the NGF overexpressers displayed a wide range of baseline durations that did not correlate well with conduction velocity.
The compression in conduction velocity range is illustrated again in Fig. 3, where the means ± SE of nine different parameters are broken down by age and presence or absence of inflection for the two groups. A comparison of mean conduction velocity for the different groups (Fig. 3A) indicates that the inflected neurons sampled in the NGF overexpressers had, overall, slower conduction velocities than those in wild-type animals, which contributes to the clustered appearance of the graph in Fig. 2B. This trend was also apparent in the uninflected population but did not reach statistical significance. Also of interest is the skewing in the sampling at P3-P5 between the wild-type animals and NGF overexpressers (Fig. 3B). At P0-P2, in both groups, the overwhelming majority of neurons sampled were inflected, with uninflected neurons making up <10% of the sample. By P3-P5, uninflected neurons had increased to ~40% of the sample in wild-type animals. However, uninflected neurons were still scarce in NGF overexpressers, remaining at 12%.
|
Surprisingly, very few consistent differences were noted between the
electrical properties of neurons from wild-type and NGF overexpressing
mice. The spikes of inflected neurons from P0-P2 NGF-overexpressing animals were significantly shorter in duration than
their wild-type counterparts (Fig. 3C), and this difference arose from a faster rising portion of the spike (Fig. 3D).
The longer duration in the wild-type group might be attributed to more
neurons exhibiting an inflection in the rising limb of the spike often
seen at this age (Fulton 1987) (see also Fig.
6); however, this was not the case. Similar numbers of neurons in control and NGF overexpressers displayed such an inflection (50% of
the wild-type P0-P2 neurons, as compared with 44% in
the NGF overexpressers at P0-P2). Concomitant with the
faster rise time, spikes from P0-P2 NGF-overexpressing
animals also had slightly larger amplitude (Fig. 3E),
and more of an overshoot (Fig. 3F). Resting membrane
potential was elevated in inflected neurons sampled at
P3-P5 in the NGF overexpressers (Fig.
3I), as was spike overshoot (Fig. 3F).
One might have expected spike amplitude to be larger in this group as
well, but this did not reach statistical significance (P = 0.06). No differences were seen in the length
of the afterhyperpolarization (AHP; Fig. 3G) or in input
resistance (Fig. 3H) between wild-types and
NGF-overexpressers. The large standard error in the value for AHP
duration in the P3-P5, NGF-overexpressing uninflected population was due to a single neuron with an extraordinarily long AHP,
that may have been a type A neuron described by Yoshida et al.
(1978)
.
Immunostaining
In NGF-overexpressing mice, it has been reported that,
whereas the total number of trigeminal ganglion neurons increases
twofold, there is a disproportionate (5-fold) increase in the number of neurons expressing TrkA (Goodness et al. 1997).
Normally, TrkA is highly (>90%) co-localized with CGRP
(Averill et al. 1995
). As might be expected, the numbers
of CGRP-immunoreactive DRG neurons are increased in NGF-overexpressers
(Davis, unpublished observations), and the density of
CGRP-immunoreactive fibers increases dramatically in the skin
(Albers et al. 1994
) and spinal cord (Mendelson
et al. 1996
). The increase in the numbers of TrkA and CGRP
positive neurons and the increase in the density of CGRP immunoreactive fibers may result from the rescue during development of neurons that
normally express CGRP/Trk A. Alternatively, NGF overexpression may
induce de novo expression of CGRP in populations of neurons that
normally do not express it. To distinguish between the two possibilities, neurons were labeled with neurobiotin, and their CGRP
content was correlated with their somal spike shape. A total of 13 neurobiotin-stained neurons were recovered from wild-type animals, and
17 from NGF overexpressers. Sections from DRGs double labeled for both
neurobiotin and CGRP are shown in Fig. 4.
As might be expected (Lawson et al. 1996
), many
neurons with inflections in both types of animals were immunopositive:
71% (5/8) in wild-type animals and 58% (8/13) in NGF overexpressers
(Fig. 4, M-P). In addition, in both types of animals, a
proportion of uninflected neurons were CGRP-positive. In wild-type
animals, 60% (3/5) of uninflected neurons were positive (Fig. 4,
A-D), a surprisingly large percentage given that
uninflected neurons are associated with low-threshold mechanoreceptors
in adults. Only 1/5 (20%) of uninflected neurons in NGF-overexpressers
was CGRP positive. The finding that NGF overexpression does not
significantly alter the proportions of inflected or uninflected neurons
that express CGRP does not support the hypothesis that large numbers of
neurons are changing their peptidergic phenotype.
|
Peripheral physiology
We were able to determine adequate stimulus and thresholds for a total of 42 neurons in NGF overexpressers (22 at P0-P2 and 20 at P3-P5), and 21 neurons in wild-type mice (6 at P0-P2 and 15 at P3-P5). Few units were characterized at P0-P2 in the wild-type mice because these neurons were extremely fragile, and we were unable to hold the penetrations long enough to adequately type most of them. Unlike adult neurons, which generally depolarize as the penetration deteriorates, these neurons would hyperpolarize. As membrane potential became more negative, the somal spike would fail to invade, leaving only the initial segment (IS) spike. As it became more negative still, the IS spike would gradually disappear, and no spike could be evoked even by intracellular injection of current.
By stimulating the skin, both rapidly and slowly adapting units could
be identified. Rapidly adapting units had small, discrete receptive
fields, but many slowly adapting units would respond with a few spikes
when probing gently over a large area of skin (approximately half the
size of the nerve territory). These units had one or two small spots
where slowly adapting responses could be elicited at lower thresholds,
and we presume that responses generated at other areas of the skin were
in response to stretch. A few "slowly-rapidly adapting" units were
identified, that sustained their discharge for a few seconds, but
eventually adapted. Such units have been described in immature animals
(Koltzenburg et al. 1997).
Although we were able to separate units into the broad categories of
slowly and rapidly adapting, it was difficult to further separate
neurons into the classes normally seen in adult animals. Although a few
tylotrich hairs have erupted by birth, the majority of the pelage does
not fill in by P5 (Payne et al. 1991), and we
were never able to associate any of our rapidly adapting units with
hair movement. Receptive field typing was especially problematic for
slowly adapting units. A few units were encountered with
short-duration, uninflected action potentials, that gave a brisk,
slowly adapting discharge from the skin and that may have been slowly
adapting type I or II units. However, the majority of slowly adapting
neurons fired at relatively low frequencies, had inflected spikes, and discharged at higher frequencies to increasing intensity of
stimulation. Their mechanical thresholds were too low to call them
nociceptors (see Peripheral thresholds) and
their frequency of discharge too low to call them SAIs. Thus the rather
stereotyped responses seen in adults were not evident at these ages.
Peripheral thresholds
The range of mechanical thresholds found in both wild-type and
NGF-overexpressers at these ages was much lower than values published
for adult animals. The highest threshold value at
P0-P2, 2 mN, was within the range seen for
low-threshold mechanoreceptors from an in vitro preparation of adult
mouse skin (Kolztenburg et al. 1997), and even at
P3-P5 thresholds were well below the range at which
HTMRs from adult rats in vivo respond (5-25 mN: Lynn and
Carpenter 1982
; 14-100 mN: Leem et al. 1993
).
The cumulative sum distribution of mechanical thresholds is illustrated
in Fig. 5. Two points are illustrated by
this graph. The first is that at P3-P5, there was no
difference in thresholds between wild-type and NGF-overexpressing mice,
indicated by the fact that the cumulative sum distributions for the two
groups overlap completely. The second is that thresholds in the
NGF-overexpressing mice increased with age. We would expect the same to
be true in the wild-type mice; however, too few units were
characterized in wild-type animals <2 days old to make the same
comparison across age groups.
|
At these ages, spike shape was not a reliable indicator of mechanical threshold. Figure 6 shows somal spikes and physiological responses from two slowly adapting units recorded from wild-type animals, one from a P3 mouse, and one from a P4 mouse. Mechanical thresholds for both units are low: 0.3 mN for the P3 unit (Fig. 6A), and 1 mN for the P4 unit (Fig. 6B), but the cell with the lower mechanical threshold (Fig. 6A) is the one with the inflected spike. Graphs in which mechanical threshold is plotted against baseline duration at different ages in the two types of mice are shown in Fig. 7. These graphs illustrate that the presence or absence of an inflection per se was not a good predictor of threshold. For any given threshold value, our sample contained neurons with inflected spikes and those without. The mean mechanical threshold for inflected spikes in wild-type animals was 1.28 ± 0.69 (SD) mN, and in NGF overexpressers, 1.93 ± 1.94 mN. For uninflected neurons, mean threshold in wild type animals was 2.76 ± 3.26 mN, and in NGF overexpressers 1.66 ± 0.61 mN. There were no significant differences between mean thresholds of inflected and uninflected neurons in either set of animals (P > 0.05, Mann-Whitney U test), nor were there significant differences between thresholds from wild-type animals and NGF-overexpressers.
|
|
![]() |
DISCUSSION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Normal development
Results obtained here confirm and extend earlier findings
on the postnatal maturation of somal membrane properties of DRG neurons
(Fulton 1987). As animals increased in age, the average duration of the somal spikes of DRG neurons became shorter, conduction velocities increased, and there was an increase in the number of
neurons sampled that lacked an inflection on the falling limb of the spike.
Peripheral response properties also matured over the first few
postnatal days. Thresholds for activation from the skin started off low
and increased between P0-P2 and P3-P5. However,
even at P3-P5, most thresholds were clearly within a range
that would be considered innocuous, and, moreover, the mechanical
thresholds for neurons with inflected spikes and those with uninflected
spikes were indistinguishable. This is in contrast to the case in the adult, where there are clear differences in peripheral threshold between myelinated afferents with inflected action potentials, and
those with uninflected ones (Koerber et al. 1988;
Ritter and Mendell 1992
; Rose et al.
1986
). Thus the functional classifications of "HTMR" and
"LTMR" are not distinguishable at very early ages, because nearly
all sensory neurons are low threshold, irrespective of somal spike shape.
Neonatal animals are hyperalgesic and hyperreflexic compared with
adults (Fitzgerald et al. 1988; Holmburg and
Schouenborg 1996
). It has been speculated that the hyperalgesia
results from transient inappropriate synapses made by low-threshold
mechanoreceptors within areas of the spinal cord normally innervated by
C-fiber nociceptors (Fitzgerald et al. 1994
). However,
given that putative HTMRs are not particularly high threshold at these
ages, no more so than putative LTMRs, it seems that the
hypersensitivity of the flexion reflex may be due in part to a low
threshold for activation at the periphery. A caveat of this hypothesis
is that we have no way of knowing how many of the inflected neurons in
our sample will remain unmyelinated and be classified in the adult as
C-fibers. However, it is known that myelinated nociceptors as well as
C-fibers contribute to the flexion reflex, and under conditions of
spinalization it is even possible to unmask weak inputs from LTMRs
(Weng and Schouenborg 1998
).
The stereotyped physiological response properties of cutaneous
mechanoreceptors in adult animals were not evident in the neonate. In
part, this may be due to the immature state of the somal spike: because
their spikes are, as a population, longer in duration than they will be
when fully mature, they may not be able to sustain the high firing
frequencies found in the adult. Another contributing factor is likely
to be the immature state of the peripheral end-organs within the skin.
For instance, although hair follicles are present in the skin at this
time, the hairs themselves do not erupt until after P3
(Payne et al. 1991). Although it is likely that some of
our rapidly adapting afferents were hair follicle afferents being
stimulated by pressure, without the adequate stimulus of hair movement,
it is impossible to definitively type them as such. Likewise, we
sampled many slowly adapting units: because most fired at relatively
low frequencies, we could not definitively type them as SAI or SAII,
and because they all had relatively low thresholds, we could not
definitively type them as mechanonociceptors. Despite our inability to
find many units that were convincingly "nociceptive" in the
neonates, we are able to find such units in an identical preparation
taken from animals aged P14 and older, indicating that
the low thresholds are probably not an artifact of being maintained in
vitro (Woodbury, unpublished observations). Instead, they are probably
related to the immature state of the integument at these ages.
Our findings are in contrast to a report by Fitzgerald
(1987b) in which it was stated that mechanical thresholds for
HTMRs and LTMRs were "normal" in the neonate. The two studies
differ in methodology: the Fitzgerald study was done in vivo and
examined hindlimb afferents, whereas the current study was done in
vitro, and we recorded from thoracic afferents. However, the author
describes a class of pressure receptors that are common in very young
neonates (comparable to the ages studied here), but scarce by
P14. Some of the pressure receptors described by
Fitzgerald probably correspond to the slowly adapting units described
in this report. It was suggested that the thresholds of pressure
receptors will fall as they mature into LTMRs, but based on our
findings that thresholds increase with age, we suggest that thresholds
of some afferents will rise as they mature into HTMRs. The two
hypotheses are not mutually exclusive: examination of the central
projections of some of our slowly adapting afferents that had been
stained with neurobiotin indicates that they are a mixed population,
some having collaterals confined to laminae I and II, with others
projecting into III and IV (Woodbury et al., in preparation;
Ritter et al. 1998
). Thus at very early postnatal ages
there appears to be a population of immature afferents that are
homogeneous in terms of spike shape, threshold, and peripheral response
properties, but heterogeneous in terms of eventual phenotype.
NGF overexpressers
Somal membrane properties of sensory neurons in neonatal mice
overexpressing NGF in the skin differed consistently from those of wild
type animals only at the earliest time points (P0-P2). At
these ages, neurons in NGF overexpressers had spikes with faster rise
times, shorter durations, and larger amplitudes. These differences may
be a result of slightly larger neurons as a result of the excess NGF,
and so less damage incurred as a result of the penetrations. There may
also be a real difference in the ionic basis for the rising portion of
the spike, primarily carried by sodium current, between wild-type mice
and NGF-overexpressers that disappears as animals mature. Multiple
isoforms of the sodium channel -subunit have been cloned and
identified (reviewed in Black and Waxman 1996
), and the
pattern of expression of these isoforms changes during development
(Felts et al. 1997
). The type III isoform is expressed
in DRG neurons at E17 but not in the adult and reappears after axotomy (Waxman et al. 1994
). Its expression in
cultured, adult DRG neurons can be suppressed by addition of NGF
(Black et al. 1997
). Perhaps the excess NGF causes a
change in the time course over which this channel subunit is replaced
by other forms, and speeds the maturation of the sodium current in
these neurons. After a few days, currents in neurons from wild-type
animals would "catch up," and so the differences in somal spike
shape would disappear.
NGF overexpressers were found to have an increased proportion of
neurons with inflected spikes at P3-P5 relative to
controls. One possibility is that excess NGF caused most neurons to
retain their inflection, and indeed there is evidence that NGF
regulates currents in the inflected population of DRG neurons. The
inflected action potentials in DRG neurons are resistant to
tetrodotoxin (TTX) (Morita and Kateyama 1989;
Ritter and Mendell 1992
; Villière and
McLachlan 1996
; Waddell and Lawson 1990
;
Yoshida et al. 1978
), which is due largely to a
TTX-resistant sodium current with slow kinetics (Kostyuk et al.
1981
; Roy and Narahashi 1992
) that has been
identified in this subpopulation of DRG neurons (Oyelese et al.
1997
; Rizzo et al. 1994
). Neurons with inflected
spikes also express the SNS sodium channel
-subunit
(Dib-Hajj et al. 1996
), thought to underly a
TTX-resistant current (Akopian et al. 1996
;
Sangameswaran et al. 1996
). Addition of exogenous NGF to
a cut nerve stump partially rescues
-SNS expression, TTX-resistant currents, and inflections in large cutaneous and small, presumably unmyelinated sensory neurons after axotomy (Dib-Hajj et al.
1998
; Oyelese et al. 1997
). If NGF is capable of
up-regulating this current in nonaxotomized DRG neurons, this may
explain the increased incidence of neurons with inflected somal spikes.
Another, more parsimonious, explanation is that the increase in the
proportion of inflected neurons can be accounted for by differential
effects on the proliferation and/or survival of different subpopulations of DRG neurons promoted by the elevated levels of NGF.
In this line of mice, the total number of trigeminal ganglion neurons
is increased twofold, but those that express TrkA are increased
fivefold (Goodness et al. 1997). Also, as adults, these mice have been shown to have an increase in the number of myelinated nociceptors (Stucky et al. 1999
). Therefore it is likely
that the increase in the percentage of inflected neurons observed in the overexpressers reflects an increase in the percentage of myelinated nociceptors rather than the maintenance of a "hump" by neurons that
ordinarily lack one.
Proliferation of myelinated nociceptors would also explain the lack of
correlation between baseline duration and conduction velocity that is
apparent in the sample as a whole. The inverse correlation between
these two parameters is extremely robust and has been reported in every
species examined: cat (Cameron et al. 1986;
Koerber et al. 1988
; Rose et al. 1986
),
rat (Harper and Lawson 1985
; Mirnics and Koerber
1997
; Ritter and Mendell 1992
; Villière and McLachlan 1996
; Waddell and
Lawson 1990
), and pigeon (Gorke and Pierau
1980
). Its absence here is striking. Yet, if we were sampling
many neurons from a very homogeneous population (myelinated
nociceptors) in which all the units had very similar conduction
velocities, this would create such a graph. In addition, overrepresentation of this group in our sample at the expense of the
faster-conducting units might explain the decrease in mean conduction
velocity in the P3-P5 inflected group.
No clear-cut differences were found between wild-type and
NGF-overexpressing mice in the types of neurons that contained CGRP immunoreactivity. In adult rats, CGRP expression is not confined to a
discreet physiological or morphological class of DRG cell. It is found
in a small percentage of fast, uninflected neurons, in a subset of
myelinated, inflected neurons with comparatively short
afterhyperpolarizations (Lawson et al. 1996), as well as in a subset of C-fibers (Lawson 1995
). In both wild-type
and NGF overexpressers, there were some inflected and some uninflected neurons that were CGRP positive. In the overexpressers, many more inflected than uninflected neurons were double labeled (58% inflected, 20% uninflected), which is in good agreement with percentages found in
myelinated afferents from adult rat (Lawson et al.
1996
). In wild-type animals, we found an unusually high
percentage (60%) of uninflected neurons that were immunopositive, but
this represents a very small sample (3/5). If excess NGF caused a
conversion of neurons that do not normally express CGRP, we might have
expected proportionally more uninflected neurons in the NGF
overexpressers to be CGRP immunoreactive, but this was not the case. Of
methodological concern is the possibility that the presence of
neurobiotin in the cell body may have obscured the presence of CGRP
immunoreactivity in some cases. This would result in false negatives
and an underestimation of the percentage of double labeled neurons. We
have no reason to believe that there were systematic differences in the
amount of neurobiotin injected into neurons in experiments done on
wild-type and those done on overexpressers that would lead to more
false negatives in one group than the other.
Conclusions
Over the first few postnatal days, as somal membrane properties of DRG neurons mature, the maturation of peripheral response properties lags behind. In adults, HTMRs and LTMRs are clearly distinguishable on the basis of spike shape and threshold. In contrast, in neonatal animals up to at least 5 days of age, inflected and uninflected neurons do not separate out into physiologically distinguishable groups. Overexpression of NGF does not substantially interfere with or accelerate the maturation of electrical properties, peptide expression, or peripheral response properties (i.e., elevation of peripheral thresholds); however, changes in the relative proportions of different types of DRG neurons caused by the excess of NGF obscures the relationship between peripheral fiber conduction velocity and the baseline duration of the somal spike normally exhibited by DRG cells.
![]() |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
---|
This work was supported by American Paralysis Association Grant RA2-9605 to A. M. Ritter, and National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke Grants NS-23725 to H. R. Koerber and NS-31826 to B. M. Davis.
![]() |
FOOTNOTES |
---|
Address for reprint requests: A. M. Ritter, Dept. of Neurobiology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, 3500 Terrace St., Pittsburgh, PA 15261.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Received 28 July 1999; accepted in final form 1 November 1999.
![]() |
REFERENCES |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|