 |
INTRODUCTION |
Volatile anesthetics are commonly used in surgery to induce the state of general anesthesia. These compounds depress neuronal activity in various parts of the mammalian CNS (Fujiwara et al. 1988
; Nicoll 1972
; Nicoll and Madison 1982
; Richards 1973
; Richards and White 1975
; Richards et al. 1975
). The underlying cellular mechanisms are still a matter of discussion. Volatile anesthetics have been shown to hyperpolarize central neurons. This hyperpolarization is probably related to an increase in K+ conductance, as suggested from studies on hippocampal, neocortical, spinal, and thalamic neurons (El-Beheiry and Puil 1989
; Miu and Puil 1989
; Sugiyama et al. 1992
; Takenoshita and Takahashi 1987
). An additional mechanism that may contribute to neuronal depression concerns the effects reported on
-aminobutyric acid-A (GABAA)-mediated synaptic inhibition. There is growing evidence that volatile anesthetics affect GABAA receptor channels and potentiate GABA-induced Cl
currents (Hall et al. 1994a
; Longoni et al. 1993
; Moody et al. 1993
; Nakahiro et al. 1989
; Scholfield 1980
; Tanelian et al. 1993
; Wakamori et al. 1991
). These effects occur at clinical concentrations and follow the Meyer-Overton rule (Jones et al. 1992
), which correlates the potency of general anesthetics with their fat solubility (Overton 1901
). On the basis of these criteria, the GABAA receptor-ion channel complex is believed to play an important role in causing the state of general anesthesia.
The volatile anesthetic enflurane exhibits depressing but also excitatory actions (Black 1979
; Collins et al. 1995
; Stevens et al. 1984
). Seizurelike biphasic electroencephalogram patterns during enflurane anesthesia were observed in cats (Stevens et al. 1984
). Similar to epileptogenic drugs, enflurane caused bursts of population spikes in the hippocampal slice preparation (MacIver and Kending 1989
). The cellular mechanisms that underlie enflurane-induced central excitation are not known. It has been proposed that a depression of GABA-mediated synaptic events may be involved (Pearce 1993
). In line with this hypothesis, a recent study on cultured hippocampal neurons showed that enflurane caused dramatic reductions in the amplitudes of evoked inhibitory postsynaptic currents (IPSCs) (Jones and Harrison 1993
). However, in another publication on the effects of enflurane in the hippocampus, the excitatory effects of the anesthetic were attributed to enhanced synaptic excitation rather than to a depression of GABAA-mediated inhibition (MacIver and Kending 1989
).
In the present work we tested the hypothesis that enflurane-induced alterations in the firing patterns can be largely explained by the effects on synaptic inhibition. Cerebellar Purkinje cells were chosen as a model system because they exhibit spontaneous activity even in acutely isolated brain slices (Jaeger and Bauer 1994
; Llinas and Sugimori 1980a
,b
), thus offering the possibility of analyzing the effects of enflurane on the spike patterns and GABAA-mediated inhibition in the same preparation.
 |
METHODS |
Slice preparation
Slices were prepared according to procedures similar to those described by Edwards et al. (1989)
. In brief, 13- to 16-day-old Sprague-Dawley rats of either sex were deeply anesthetized with enflurane, isoflurane, or halothane and decapitated, and the brains were quickly removed. Systematic effects on the quality of the slices or on the characteristic discharge patterns of Purkinje neurons were not observed with regard to the anesthetic chosen. Brains were stored for 5-10 min in ice-cold artificial cerebrospinal fluid (ACSF) consisting of (in mM) 125 NaCl, 2.5 KCl, 1.25 NaH2PO4, 1 MgCl2, 26 NaHCO3, 2 CaCl2, and 25 glucose. The cerebellum was then glued onto a Teflon block and 250- to 300-µm-thick sagittal slices were prepared with a vibratome (Campden, Loughborough, UK). Slices were stored in a bath of ACSF at 21-23°C bubbled with 95% O2-5% CO2. They were then transferred to the recording chamber 1-6 h later and continuously perfused with ACSF at a flow rate of ~1 ml/min.

View larger version (57K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 1.
Extracellularly recorded firing patterns of Purkinje cells observed before (control), during 1.3 MAC (1 MAC induces general anesthesia in 50% of patients and rats), and after (wash) enflurane application. Recordings during and after enflurane treatment were carried out 12 min after switching between the solutions. At that time, discharge patterns arrived at the new steady state. A: enflurane reduced the action potential discharge rate by introducing periods of quiescence. Mean spike rates were 11.3 Hz before, 6.7 Hz during, and 9.8 Hz after enflurane treatment. B: in this cell, enflurane evoked bursts of spikes with decreasing amplitudes. The small unit exhibited a discharge pattern very similar to the large one (not shown). Note the different time scales. C: spike rates and interspike intervals before, during, and after enflurane treatment. Top row: number of spikes recorded within 5-s time intervals. Bottom row: distributions of interspike intervals peaking at 65, 46, and 57 ms before, during and after enflurane treatment. Interspike intervals lasting >150 ms were ignored. Enflurane reduced spontaneous firing of Purkinje cells by introducing long periods into the discharge patterns when the cell stayed silent, but not by increasing the interspike intervals observed within bursts of spikes. Mean firing rates were 12.4 Hz before, 6.3 Hz during, and 11.2 Hz after enflurane treatment.
|
|
Control of experimental temperature
Experiments were carried out at either 21-23 or 34-36°C. The recording chamber consisted of a metal frame with a glass bottom. A heating wire was glued onto the metal frame. In cases in which experiments were carried out at 34-36°C, the frame was heated to 36°C by passing an appropriate direct current through the heating wire. Furthermore, the bathing solutions were heated to 36°C before entering the recording chamber.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 1.
Concentration-dependent effects of enflurane on the interburst and burst durations of action potential firing
of Purkinje cells
|
|
Extracellular recordings
Cerebellar slices were viewed under a low-power dissection microscope. ACSF-filled glass electrodes with resistances of ~5 M
were positioned on the surface of the Purkinje cell layer. Electrodes were advanced into the slices until extracellular spikes >300 µV in amplitude were visible and a single unit could be clearly discriminated. The noise amplitude was between 20 and 100 µV.
Whole cell voltage-clamp and current-clamp recordings
Experiments were carried out with a setup similar to that described by Stuart et al. (1993)
. Patch pipettes were pulled from thin-walled borosilicate capillaries (1.5 mm OD) and coated with Sylgard (Dow Corning). After fire polishing, resistances were 1.5-3.5 M
. For voltage-clamp recordings, pipettes were filled with an intracellular solution containing (in mM) 145 CsCl, 1 MgCl2, 5 ethyleneglycol-bis-(
-aminoethyl ether)-N,N,N
,N
-tetraacetic acid, 2 ATP, and 10 N-2-hydroxyethyl-piperazine-N
-2-ethanesulphonic acid (HEPES), pH 7.3. Input resistance of Purkinje cells was 337 ± 112 (SD) M
(n = 41). The access resistance ranged within 5-12 M
and was compensated by ~80% with the series resistance compensation of the LM/EPC (List, Germany), as described in Llano et al. (1991b)
. Purkinje cells (n = 12), with the soma close to the surface of the slice, were stained with the fluorescent dye Lucifer yellow (Sigma, Deisenhofen, Germany). They showed intact dendritic arborizations within the molecular layer. Cells lying deeper (10-30 µm) in the slice were cleaned before establishment of the gigaseal, as described by Edwards et al. (1989)
. Current-clamp recordings were carried out with the use of an Axoclamp-2A amplifier. Patch pipettes were filled with 140 potassium gluconate, 5 HEPES, 3 NaCl, 1 MgCl2, 0.5 CaCl2. In some experiments, 0.3 mM guanosine 5
-triphosphate was added. Under these conditions, input resistances of Purkinje cells were 187 ± 35 (SD) M
(n = 33).
Stimulating presynaptic fibers
Glass electrodes with tip diameters between 2 and 10 µm were used for stimulating presynaptic fibers. In these recordings, 15 µM 6-cyano-nitroquinoxaline-2,3-dione (Sigma) and 20 µM D,L
2-amino-5-phosphonorenic acid (Sigma) were added to the bath solution. In some experiments, bipolar stimulus electrodes pulled from double-barreled theta glass capillaries (Hilgenberg, Malsfeld, Germany) were used (Vincent et al. 1992
). Currents of 15-35 µA and 0.1 ms in duration were sufficient to elicit synaptic currents with peak amplitudes of ~0.2-2 nA. The stimulation frequency was 0.5 Hz.
Preparation and application of volatile anesthetics
Defined concentrations of volatile anesthetics dissolved in ACSF were prepared according to the method described by Tas et al. (1989)
. In brief, 500 ml ACSF were bubbled at a flow rate of 200 l/h with a vapor containing the volatile anesthetic. The desired vapor concentration was delivered by calibrated vaporizers (Draeger, Luebeck, Germany). Temperature was 22-23°C. After ~30 min, an equilibrium between the gas and liquid phase was reached (Tas et al. 1989
). About 60 min later, samples were taken with the use of gas-tight syringes. Continuous bubbling ensured that enflurane did not evaporate during this procedure. Samples were later applied during electrophysiological recordings.
Because the solubility of enflurane is twice as high at 21-23°C as at 34-36°C, ACSF was bubbled with 1 vol% enflurane to obtain a concentration in the ACSF corresponding to 1 MAC (1 MAC induces general anesthesia in 50% of patients and rats). Vapor pressure concentrations delivered by the calibrated vaporizers were regarded as correct, because the MAC value determined by the suppression of the righting reflex with eight rats was close to 2.0 vol%. This is in accordance with the value given in the literature (Franks and Lieb 1993
). Test solutions of 1 MAC enflurane were additionally prepared by dissolving enflurane in the ACSF to a final concentration of 0.63 mM (Franks and Lieb 1994
), according to the method described by Wakamori et al. (1991)
.
Anesthetics were applied via bath perfusion with the use of syringe pumps (ZAK, Marktheidenfeld, Germany), which were connected via Teflon tubing to the experimental chamber. The flow rate was 1 ml/min. Slices were positioned close to the outlet of the Teflon tube in the recording chamber to minimize the loss of enflurane. In some experiments, we additionally blew a vapor containing 1 vol% enflurane across the surface of the ACSF while applying a test solution of 1 MAC enflurane and recording of IPSCs from Purkinje cells. Switching the stream of vapor on and off had no effect on the time constant of IPSCs. From this finding we conclude that the loss of enflurane before reaching the slice was negligible.
Control recordings before enflurane application were taken ~15 min after the whole cell configuration was established. After that time, the reversal potential for IPSCs was close to 0 mV, indicating complete perfusion of the cell with the pipette solution. When switching from ACSF to drug-containing solutions, the medium in the experimental chamber was replaced within 2 min by
95%. Effects on the spike patterns and IPSCs were stable ~5 min later. This delay may be attributed to the diffusion of the test solution into the tissue. Recordings in the presence of enflurane were taken 8-15 min after switching between the solutions. The time required to observe recovery increased with the concentration tested. With 0.5-2 MAC, full recovery was reached after 12-15 min, andwith 4.0 MAC it was reached after 30-60 min. Stable recording of
1 h was necessary to test a single enflurane concentration.
Data analysis
Data were low-pass filtered between 2 and 5 kHz, acquired on a 486 PC with the digidata 1200 AD/DA interface and pClamp 6.1 software (Axon Instruments). Sampling rates ranged between 5 and 15 kHz. Alternatively, records were stored on a Sony data recorder for later analysis. Extra- and intracellularly recorded spikes and synaptic events were counted on- or off-line with the use of software event detectors. Amplitudes of synaptic events were determined from cursor measurements. IPSC current decays were fitted with monoexponential functions. Fitting routines were provided by the pClamp program package. Concentration-response relationships were fitted with Hill equations with the use of the simplex algorithm. Spike rates were measured as the mean of spikes occurring in a period of 180-300 s. For statistical analysis the paired Student's t-test was used. Where not otherwise stated, results are given as means ± SE.

View larger version (13K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 2.
Concentration-response relationships for enflurane-induced depression of mean spike rates. For each concentration, the mean value and SE were calculated from 5-17 different cells in different slices. A: averaged spike rates monitored at 22°C ( ) and 35°C (· · · ·). B: effect of enflurane was calculated by comparing action potential discharge rates before and during treatment. Horizontal line: half-maximal depression. One hundred percent depression is equivalent to complete depression of spontaneous action potentials.
|
|
 |
RESULTS |
Effects of enflurane on the discharge rates of Purkinje cells
Spike patterns of Purkinje cells were monitored extracellularly in sagittal cerebellar brain slices with electrodes positioned within the Purkinje cell layer. The effects of enflurane were tested with 127 cells at 22°C and 57 cells at 35°C. Before and after enflurane treatment, Purkinje cells continuously fired action potentials interrupted only by brief periods of silence, typically <2 s in duration. When enflurane concentrations corresponding to 1-2 MAC were applied, spike patterns such those as shown in Fig. 1A emerged. The anesthetic caused the cells to fire periodic bursts of action potentials, separated by gaps ~5-10 s in duration. In the majority of tested cells, the mean spike rates transiently increased before burst firing was established (data not shown). The concentration-dependent actions of enflurane on the interburst and burst durations are summarized in Table 1. The anesthetic prolonged the interburst intervals and shortened burst durations. In Fig. 1B, application of 1.3 MAC enflurane introduced a spike pattern similar to that in Fig. 1A and simultaneously caused the neuron to fire short trains of five to seven action potentials with decreasing amplitudes. Such patterns were observed in 5 of 14 cells tested with 1.3 MAC enflurane and in 6 of 12 cells with 2.0 MAC. In the remaining cells we obtained activity patterns like those in Fig. 1A. In Fig. 1C, the effect of enflurane on the discharge rate and on the interspike intervals is given. The data are derived from the large unit of Fig. 1B. They demonstrate that the anesthetic established a highly regular pattern of activity. During the active periods the spike rates were higher than observed under control conditions. This is indicated by the peak in the interspike intervals, which shifted from ~65 ms to 42 ms in the presence of enflurane.

View larger version (68K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 3.
Effects of enflurane on the discharge pattern of a Purkinje cell in the presence and absence of the -aminobutyric acid-A (GABAA) antagonist bicuculline. Spikes were binned at 5-s intervals. Control: spike rates before bicuculline application. 1.3 MAC: spike rates in the presence of 1.3 MAC enflurane. 1.3 MAC & bicu: spike rates in the presence of 25 µM bicuculline and enflurane. Wash: spike rates after removal of enflurane and bicuculline. Application of enflurane induced oscillatory spike activity. Addition of bicuculline increased the firing rate within the active period without abolishing the rhythmic firing pattern. Spike rates were 12.5 Hz (control), 7.5 Hz (1.3 MAC), 9.8 Hz (1.3 MAC and bicu), and 12.3 Hz (wash).
|
|

View larger version (21K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 4.
Effects of enflurane on the amplitudes of spontaneous inhibitory postsynaptic currents (IPSCs). A: effects of 1.3 and 2.0 MAC enflurane on synaptic events recorded from a voltage-clamped cell held at 77 mV. The cell was filled with 145 mM CsCl. An increase in GABAA-mediated conductance corresponds to inward currents (downward deflections). B: depression of IPSC amplitudes by enflurane is plotted against the mean IPSC amplitudes recorded before enflurane treatment. The data points are derived from cells tested with 1 MAC ( ) and 2 MAC ( ). They were fitted by regression lines. No significant correlation was observed (F test P < 0.05). C: concentration-response relationship for the depression of IPSC amplitudes. For each concentration, the number of tested cells was between 5 and 15. The solid line was fitted to the data by a Hill equation. Half-maximal inhibition was estimated to be close to 0.9 MAC enflurane.
|
|
Development of oscillatory spike activity and the depression of the action potential discharge rates were not temperature dependent. In Fig. 2A, averaged spike rates monitored at various enflurane concentrations are shown. The spontaneous spike rate measured before enflurane treatment was10.7 ± 4.0 Hz (n = 127) at 22°C and 26.7 ± 3.7 Hz (n = 57) at 35°C. The depressant effect of enflurane was quantified by comparing the discharge rates of the same cell before and during enflurane treatment. The results are given in Fig. 2B. At either temperature, half-maximal depression was observed close to 2 MAC. Spontaneous activity of Purkinje cells was significantly reduced at
0.4 MAC enflurane(P < 0.01).
Assuming that the effects on the discharge patterns of Purkinje cells are exclusively caused by a possible action on GABAA channels, the anesthetic should not be effective in bicuculline-treated slices, because the GABAA antagonist depressed inhibitory synaptic currents regardless of whether volatile anesthetics were present or not (see Fig. 8). To test this hypothesis, spontaneous acitvity of Purkinje cells was monitored and slices were then treated as follows. First, enflurane was applied during recording from cells that exhibited a stable discharge pattern. About 10 min later, bicuculline was added to a final concentration corresponding to 25 µM. Finally, enflurane and bicuculline were removed. Data from a typical recording are presented in Fig. 3. In the presence of enflurane, the same regular spike patterns emerged as already shown in Fig. 1C. When bicuculline was added, oscillatory activity remained. Within the active periods the spike rate increased. In this experiment the peak in the interspike interval was between 50 and 60 ms under control conditions and between 20 and 30 ms after application of bicuculline (data not shown). In all cells (n = 11) tested this way, bicuculline did not reverse oscillatory firing patterns of Purkinje cells caused by enflurane treatment.

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 8.
Effects of 25 µm bicuculline on the baseline current in the absence and presence of 1 MAC enflurane. All traces were recorded from the same neuron. The Purkinje cell was held at 72 mV. A: before enflurane treatment, application of bicuculline (bicu) abolished synaptic events while leaving the baseline current unaltered. B: in the presence of 1.0 MAC enflurane, inhibitory postsynaptic potentials were abolished when bicuculline was added. Again, the baseline remained unchanged.
|
|
To determine whether bicuculline altered the effects of enflurane on the mean spike rates summarized in Fig. 2, a different experimental protocol was used as illustrated in Fig. 3. In these recordings, the GABAA antagonist was applied before enflurane was added. In ~20% of the tested neurons, bicuculline completely abolished action potential activity. These neurons were excluded from further analysis. In the remaining cells, spike rates increased from 9.4 ± 0.9 Hz to 11.9 ± 1.0 Hz (n = 14). On average, 2 MAC enflurane reduced the discharge rate of Purkinje cells by only 13 ±8% in the presence of bicuculline.
Effects of enflurane on spontaneous and evoked IPSCs
IPSC AMPLITUDES.
Spontaneous GABAA-mediated IPSCs were monitored from voltage-clamped cells held at membrane potentials between
72 and
80 mV. To improve the voltage-clamp conditions, to amplify GABAA-mediated synaptic events and block GABAB currents, the neurons were filled with 145 mM CsCl. Under these conditions, spontaneous synaptic events with amplitudes between a few picoamperes and several nanoamperes were observed. These events were identified as spontaneous GABAA-mediated IPSCs, because they were abolished by bicuculline (25 µM, n = 7).

View larger version (25K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 5.
Effects of enflurane on the reversal potential of IPSCs. A: current traces recorded from the same cell at different membrane potentials before and during enflurane treatment. Membrane potentials are indicated at left. B: current-voltage relationship of mean IPSC amplitudes observed in the absence and presence of enflurane. Top graph: corresponding SDs. The data are derived from the same cell as in A. IPSC amplitudes were fitted by regression lines. The estimated reversal potential for a Cl -selective conductance is 2.5 mV.
|
|
The effects of enflurane on the amplitudes of spontaneous IPSCs are shown in Fig. 4A. In this particular experiment, two different concentrations were applied to the same cell. The anesthetic depressed the amplitude of IPSCs in a concentration-dependent manner. Setting the amplitude for event detection at 20 pA, the mean amplitudes were 248 ± 232 pA before enflurane, 167 ± 111 pA in the presence of 1.3 MAC, 46 ± 42 pA in the presence of 2.0 MAC, and 205 ± 148 pA following washout.
Mean IPSC amplitudes varied considerably between cells. We calculated an average of 203 ± 245 (SD) pA (n = 41). Similar results were reported by Farrant and Cull-Candy (1991)
, Llano et al. (1991a)
, and Puia et al. (1994)
. Despite this variability, depression of IPSC amplitudes by enflurane did not depend on the mean IPSC amplitudes that were recorded before enflurane treatment. In Fig. 4B, the effects of enflurane were quantified by dividing the mean IPSC amplitude recorded in the presence of the anesthetic by the amplitude observed before enflurane treatment. These values were plotted against the IPSC amplitudes measured before enflurane application. With concentrations corresponding to 1 and 2 MAC, no statistically significant correlation was observed (P < 0.05, F test).
In Fig. 4C, the concentration-response relationship is given. The solid curve was fitted with a Hill equation to the data points. Half-maximal reduction was estimated at 0.9 MAC. Depression of the mean IPSC amplitude was significant at 1.0 MAC (P < 0.01).
The reduction of IPSC amplitudes shown in Fig. 4 can be explained by at least two different mechanisms. Either the membrane conductance during IPSCs is reduced or, alternatively, a shift in the reversal potential toward more negative values is involved. When Purkinje cells were voltage clamped at values between +80 and
80 mV, anesthetic concentrations corresponding to 1 and 2 MAC enflurane depressed IPSC amplitudes at all tested voltages, whereas the reversal potential of IPSCs remained unaffected. In Fig. 5B, the mean IPSC amplitudes monitored at different membrane potentials were fitted by a straight line. The conductances estimated from the slope of the regression line were reduced to 53% of the control value with 1 MAC enflurane and to 23% with 2 MAC. The results from five cells tested in this way are summarized in Table 2. They indicate that depression of IPSC amplitudes is caused by a change in conductance and not by a shift in the reversal potential.
View this table:
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
TABLE 2.
Effects of enflurane on the amplitude of GABAA-mediated conductances as obtained from current-voltage relationships
|
|
DECAY OF IPSCs.
IPSC decays recorded from Purkinje cells can be well fitted with monoexponential functions (Puia et al. 1994
; Vincent et al. 1992
). A time constant of 10.4 ± 0.5 ms (n = 79) was calculated from recordings carried out before enflurane treatment at 21-23°C. This is close to the value given elsewhere (Puia et al. 1994
; Vincent et al. 1992
). In hippocampal pyramidal cells, the volatile anesthetic halothane prolonged the current decays of evoked and spontaneous IPSCs (Gage and Robertson 1985
; Mody et al. 1991
). Figure 6A shows that similar effects were obtained with enflurane during recording from Purkinje cells. In the top traces, spontaneous IPSCs monitored before and during enflurane application are shown. In the presence of 0.5 MAC enflurane, current decays were clearly prolonged. The time constant fitted to the current decays was 10.7 ± 2.3 (SD) ms (n = 353) before enflurane treatment and 24.5 ± 2.5 ms (n = 383) in the presence of the anesthetic. From seven cells, averages of 10.4 ± 2.7 ms before and 21.7 ± 7.1 ms during enflurane treatment were calculated.

View larger version (24K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 6.
A: effects of enflurane on the time course of GABAA-mediated spontaneous and evoked IPSCs. Top traces: spontaneous IPSCs. Bottom traces: IPSCs evoked by electric stimulation of afferent fibers overlain by spontaneous IPSCs. Arrow: stimulus (18 µA, 0.1 ms). The Purkinje cell was held at 78 mV. At a concentration corresponding to 0.5 MAC, current decays were considerably prolonged in the presence of enflurane. B: time constants of current decays in the time course of enflurane application. Time constants were obtained frommonoexponential fits. Steady state was reached ~7 min after enflurane perfusion was begun. C: time constants of IPSC current decays recorded at different enflurane concentrations. The concentration-response curve was fitted with a Hill equation. Half-maximal potentiation was estimated at 1.7 MAC. With concentrations of 0.5 MAC, time constants differed significantly from the control value (P < 0.01). D: effects of enflurane on the frequency of synaptic events. Frequencies were estimated from randomly selected 3-min time segments. The threshold for event detection was set at 15 pA.
|
|
In the experiment shown in Fig. 6A, IPSCs were simultaneously evoked by electrical stimulation of afferent fibers (bottom traces). For stimulation, a second patch electrode was placed on the surface of the slice at the border between the Purkinje cell layer and granule cell layer. A current of 18 µA, 0.1 ms in duration, was used to evoke postsynaptic IPSCs. Average time constants of 9.7 ± 2.7 (SD) ms (n = 27) and 26.1 ± 5.3 ms (n = 26), respectively, were fitted to evoked IPSCs recorded before and during enflurane treatment (0.5 MAC).
In Fig. 6B, the time constants of current decays were averaged once a minute before, during, and after enflurane treatment to estimate the time required to obtain stable effects. At 1 MAC, enflurane increased the time constant from 9 to 47 ms. Steady state was reached 6-7 min after starting enflurane perfusion. Complete recovery was observed ~11 min after removal of the anesthetic.
In Fig. 6C, the concentration-response curve for the time constants of current decays estimated from spontaneous IPSCs is shown. At concentrations corresponding to 0.5 MAC, current decays were significantly prolonged (P < 0.01). With 2 and 4 MAC, time constants increased >10-fold. From the fit in Fig. 6C, half-maximal potentiation was observed at 1.7 MAC.
Problems and possible errors that are associated with preparing test solutions of volatile anesthetics and with estimating MAC values have been analyzed and discussed by Franks and Lieb (1993)
. To exclude such errors, we prepared the test solutions either by bubbling the ACSF with a vapor containing the anesthetic or by diluting the anesthetic to the desired concentration. The effects of the differently prepared solutions on the IPSC time constant are compared in Table 3. The data suggest that both methods yielded very similar anesthetic concentrations in the ACSF.
IPSC FREQUENCY.
Figure 6D summarizes the actions of enflurane on the frequency of synaptic events. Between 0.5 and 2 MAC, enflurane reduced the frequency of IPSCs in a concentration-dependent manner. With 4 MAC, IPSCs were nearly abolished. Because the IPSC amplitudes were largely depressed with this high concentration, it seems possible that synaptic events could not be resolved from the baseline current.
ESTIMATION OF THE OVERALL EFFECT OF ENFLURANE ONGABAA-MEDIATED INHIBITION.
Presynaptic GABA release causes the opening of postsynaptic GABAA channels, subsequently allowing Cl
ions to flow across the postsynaptic membrane. The GABAA-mediated inhibitory input received by a Purkinje cell thus depends on the number of ions transferred in the time course of synaptic events and on the frequency of these events. In Fig. 7A, idealized synaptic events observed under control conditions at 22°C and with different enflurane concentrations are shown. Idealized IPSCs were constructed from the amplitudes and time constants in Figs. 4C and 6C. Enflurane depressed the amplitudes of IPSCs and simultaneously prolonged current decays. Because of the monoexponential current decays, the transferred charge per IPSC can be approximated by multiplying the IPSC amplitudes and the corresponding time constants of current decays. The results are given in Fig. 7B. They show that, despite the amplitude depressing effect, the increase in the transferred charge per averaged IPSC is well approximated by a straight line.

View larger version (13K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 7.
A: idealized time courses of IPSCs at different enflurane concentrations. Synaptic events were constructed from the mean amplitudes and time constants given in Figs. 4C and 6C. Increasing enflurane concentrations decreased the mean amplitudes and simultaneously prolonged the current decays. B: concentration-response relationships for the charge transferred during averaged IPSCs (   ) and the GABAA-mediated synaptic inhibition of Purkinje cells ( · · · ). For both fits a 2nd-order polynomial was used. See text for further details.
|
|
We estimated the mean inhibitory current received by Purkinje cells at different enflurane concentrations by multiplying the charge transfer per average synaptic event and the frequency of these events. The data show that, because of the concentration-dependent decrease of synaptic events, the increase in GABAA-mediated inhibition is less steep compared with the transferred charge per IPSC. Between 0.5 and 2 MAC, GABAA-mediated inhibition of Purkinje cells has doubled and remains more or less constant. Without enflurane, synaptically mediated inhibition of Purkinje cells corresponded to a conductance of 0.63 ± 0.17 nS.
EFFECTS OF BICUCULLINE ON BASELINE CURRENTS.
In a study on cultured hippocampal neurons, it was suggested that volatile anesthetics also gate GABAA channels in the absence of GABA (Yang et al. 1992
). We examined our data with regard to the question whether a persistent GABAA-mediated current was induced during enflurane treatment. The results of Fig. 8 were obtained before and during enflurane application. In both cases bicuculline was added to the bathing solution. To resolve the effects on the baseline currents, a cell with a low synaptic input was chosen. Enflurane application did not cause an inward current, as is to be expected when a persistent Cl
current is induced. Application of bicuculline abolished synaptic events, but did not affect the baseline current. Similar results were obtained with all cells investigated (n = 7). From these findings, it must be concluded that in our preparation enflurane did not gate GABAA channels in the absence of GABA.
EFFECTS OF TEMPERATURE.
In further experiments, the effects of enflurane were compared at different temperatures. The results are summarized in Fig. 9. Raising the temperature from 22 to 35°C shortened the IPSC time constant and increased the frequency of synaptic events. The mean IPSC amplitude was hardly affected. The effects of enflurane on the time constant of current decays and on the mean IPSC amplitudes were similar at 22 and 35°C.

View larger version (19K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 9.
Effects of enflurane on spontaneous IPSCs at different temperatures. Current decays were recorded at 22°C (A) and at 35°C (B). For each bar, the number of cells tested ranged between 9 and 15. C: mean IPSC amplitudes as observed at 22 and 35°C.
|
|
EFFECTS OF ENFLURANE IN THE PRESENCE OF TETRODOTOXIN.
Llano et al. (1991a)
demonstrated that the mean amplitude of IPSCs recorded from voltage-clamped Purkinje cells is strongly reduced if presynaptic action potentials are abolished by tetrodotoxin (TTX). This finding raises the question of whether the amplitude-depressing effect of enflurane summarized in Fig. 4 results from a depression of presynaptic action potentials. TTX treatment alone reduced the mean amplitude of IPSCs to 66.1 ± 4.4 pA (n = 12) and decreased the frequency of synaptic events to 4.1 ± 0.3 Hz. Figure 10 shows that the effects of 1 and 2 MAC enflurane on the IPSC amplitude were similar, regardless of whether TTX was present or not. Enflurane did not cause a decrease in the frequency of synaptic events in TTX-treated slices.

View larger version (31K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 10.
A: effects of 1 and 2 MAC enflurane on the frequency (top trace), the time constant (middle trace), and the mean amplitude (bottom trace) of IPSCs in the presence of 1 µM tetrodotoxin (TTX). The data were taken from the same cell and are given as mean values ± SD. The frequency was calculated from the number of synaptic events counted within a period of 100 s. B-D: effects of enflurane on the frequency (B), the time constant (C), and the mean amplitude of synaptic events (D) in the absence and presence of TTX.
|
|
EFFECTS OF ENFLURANE DURING CURRENT-CLAMP RECORDINGS.
When treated with enflurane, Purkinje cells began to fire bursts of action potentials (Fig. 1). Studies on thalamic neurons demonstrated that a transition in the discharge patterns from singular spiking toward burst firing occurred as the membrane potential was hyperpolarized (for a review, see Steriade et al. 1993
). A transient Ca2+ current and a hyperpolarization-activated cationic current (Ih) were identified as the most important components in causing these changes. Because the question arose of whether the effects of enflurane on Purkinje cells involved a similar mechanism, current-clamp experiments were carried out with the use of patch pipettes filled with potassium gluconate. Five to ten minutes after the whole cell configuration was obtained, 21 of 33 neurons fired action potentials spontaneously. Membrane resting potentials ranged between
55 and
69 mV. When injecting hyperpolarizing currents through the recording electrode, the discharge rates decreased, but, unlike in thalamic neurons, burst firing was not induced (Fig. 11A1). Exposure to the anesthetic (2 MAC) transiently increased the mean spike rate and caused burst firing(Fig. 11A2). During current-clamp recordings, 2 MAC enflurane reduced firing rates by 61 ± 14%, which is close to the value calculated from extracellular recordings.

View larger version (61K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 11.
Effects of hyperpolarizing and depolarizing current injections on the spike patterns of Purkinje cells. The injected current is indicated at the top of the records. A1: in a spontaneously active cell, hyperpolarizing currents reduced spike rates without inducing burst firing. A2: enflurane (2 MAC) was applied, the spike rate transiently increased (enflurane 3 min) before the cell started bursting (enflurane 9 min). Spontaneous firing rates were 6.0 Hz before, 3.7 Hz during, and 6.7 Hz after treatment. B1: in a different cell with a bottom spontaneous activity (1.4 Hz), depolarizing currents increased the discharge rate in the absence (B1) and presence (B2) of the anesthetic. Enflurane reduced action potential firing by ~50% (B3). Without enflurane, membrane depolarization shifted the peak values of interspike interval histograms toward bottom values (B4). When enflurane was present (2 MAC), interspike intervals were hardly affected by the currents applied. B5: in the presence of enflurane, burst and interburst durations depended on the injected currents.
|
|
The effects of depolarizing currents, injected before and during enflurane treatment, are illustrated in Fig. 11B. Under control conditions without enflurane, current injections shortened interspike intervals and increased the spike rate. Enflurane application evoked burst firing and, as the cell was depolarized, burst durations lengthened and interburst intervals shortened (Fig. 11, B2 and B5). The discharge rate within the bursts was little affected by the amount of injected current (Fig. 11B4).
A representative example for the effects of the anesthetic on action potentials, the membrane resting potential and the input resistance is presented in Fig. 12. At 2 MAC, enflurane reduced the spike amplitude by 5 mV (7% of spike amplitude) and depressed spike afterhyperpolarizations by 3 mV (4%). The threshold for spike generation, as well as the width of action potentials, remained unaffected. On average, enflurane treatment hyperpolarized Purkinje cells by 5.2 ± 1.1 mV (n = 13), but only by 1.6 ± 1.2 mV (n = 7), when GABAA-mediated synaptic transmission was blocked. Bicuculline treatment alone (25 µM) increased the input resistance of Purkinje cells by ~10% and depolarized the membrane potential between 0 and 3 mV. Enflurane-induced membrane hyperpolarizations reversed at membrane potentials between
77 and
86 mV. This was close to the Nernst potential for Cl
ions (
80 mV).

View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 12.
Effects of enflurane (2 MAC) on fast sodium action potentials, the membrane resting potential, and the input resistance of a Purkinje cell. A: voltage traces in response to depolarizing and hyperpolarizing current injections. Note the reversible depression of spike afterhyperpolarizations, and the oscillatory component in the current traces recorded during hyperpolarizing stimuli. B: effects of the anesthetic on the threshold, afterhyperpolarizations (AHP), peak values (peak), and the width of fast sodium spikes. Spike widths were determined at half-maximal amplitude. The threshold was taken as the membrane potential measured when the change in voltage reached 10 V/s. C: time courses of the membrane resting potential and input resistance before, during, and after exposure to enflurane. Input resistances were calculated from the negative peak values (filled arrow in Fig. 13A) of the voltage responses that occurred during injecting a current of 100 pA for 500 ms.
|
|
During enflurane application, the input resistance, determined from the peaks of voltage deflections in response to hyperpolarizing current pulses, transiently increased, reaching a maximum ~3-4 min after the onset of enflurane perfusion, but then approached a steady state close to that recorded before enflurane administration (Fig. 12C). Under steady-state conditions, input resistances did not differ significantly, regardless of whether the anesthetic was present or not.
Similar to observations made in a previous study (Chang et al. 1993
), hyperpolarizing currents activated Ih, thus causing the sag in the voltage traces of Figs. 12A and 13A. Activation of Ih was considerably accelerated by enflurane (Fig. 13B).

View larger version (33K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
| FIG. 13.
A: effects of enflurane (2 MAC) on membrane properties in the presence of TTX (1 µM) and bicuculline (25 µM). The corresponding current-voltage relationships are given in B. 1/2: time of half-maximal voltage decay measured between the peak values (filled arrow) and the steady state (open arrow).
|
|
The voltage records shown in Fig. 13A were obtained when regenerative action potential activity and synaptic inhibition were blocked by TTX and bicuculline, respectively. The corresponding current-voltage relationships recorded before, during, and after enflurane application show that, under these conditions, the anesthetic slightly increased the input resistance on average of 8 ± 3% (n = 4).
 |
DISCUSSION |
In the present study we investigated the relation between the effects of enflurane on GABAA-mediated synaptic inhibition and on the discharge patterns of Purkinje cells. The result that bicuculline increased spontaneous firing without causing synaptic excitation (Fig. 8) indicated that GABAA-mediated inhibition in fact participated in controlling the discharge rates. There are two lines of evidence supporting the hypothesis that enflurane diminished spontaneous action potential activity by increasing synaptic inhibition. First,enflurane was more efficient in depressing spike rates in preparations with GABAA-mediated inhibition intact than in disinhibited slices. Second, 1-2 MAC enflurane increased synaptically mediated inhibition by a factor of 2 and simultaneously hyperpolarized the membrane potential by ~5.2 mV in the absence, but only by 1.6 mV in the presence, of bicuculline. Assuming an input resistance of 150 M
, a change in the membrane potential of 5 mV is caused by a current of ~30 pA. The results summarized in Fig. 11B3 demonstrate that such currents were indeed sufficient to alter the spontaneous activity of Purkinje cells considerably.
In thalamic neurons, periodic burst discharges were evoked by hyperpolarizing current injections (Steriade et al. 1993
). Bursts of action potentials were generated by the interplay of Ih and a transient Ca2+ current. Ih acted as a pacemaker current and depolarized the membrane potential until Ca2+ spikes appeared. As Ca2+ spikes occurred, the intracellular Ca2+ concentration rose. Consequently, Ca2+-dependent K+ conductances were activated, leading to membrane hyperpolarization. As a result, inactivation of Ca2+ channels was removed, Ih was activated, and the next cycle commenced. Burst discharges disappeared as the membrane potential was depolarized because, in this case, Ca2+ channels remained inactivated.
The following observations make it improbable that the same mechanism underlies enflurane-induced burst firing of Purkinje cells. First, bursts of action potentials were neither induced when hyperpolarizing currents were injected in the absence of enflurane nor abolished when depolarizing currents were applied in the presence of the anesthetic. Second,enflurane-induced membrane hyperpolarizations werelargely blocked in the presence of bicuculline, whereas burst discharges were not.
In Purkinje cells, the mechanisms underlying burst firing remain to be elucidated. It has been demonstrated that, when burst firing was induced by TTX treatment, blockage of Ih altered burst and interburst durations (Chang et al. 1993
). Because the anesthetic accelerated activation of this current, it seems possible that Ih was indeed involved in causing burst firing in the present study. We speculate that the effects observed on Ih facilitated a shift of the membrane potential toward the plateau potentials seen during bursts (Fig. 11). Thus, similarly as in thalamic neurons, Ih may have acted as the pacemaker current. However, completely different mechanisms, e.g., those involving autonomous oscillations in the intracellular Ca2+ concentration and periodic activation of Ca2+-dependent K+ channels, as reported in several preparations, cannot be ruled out at present (for reviews see Meyer and Stryer 1991
; Tsien 1990
).
Besides the mechanisms discussed above, the depression of spike afterhyperpolarizations shown in Figs. 11 and 12A could be also involved in altering the discharge patterns. This was already suggested in studies on the effects of volatile anesthetics on neocortical and hippocampal pyramidal cells (El-Beheiry and Puil 1989
; Fujiwara et al. 1988
). Depression of spike afterhyperpolarizations may contribute to neuronal excitation frequently observed during enflurane anesthesia. An excitatory action of enflurane was further indicated by the persistent increase in the input resistance observed in bicuculline-treated slices. Without bicuculline, the input resistance did not differ before and during enflurane administration. This indicates that the effect, which was unmasked in disinhibited preparations, was counterbalanced by an increase in synaptic inhibition.
The overall effects of enflurane on the discharge patterns of Purkinje cells appear to be rather complex. A typical example is given in Fig. 11B. During injection of a current of ~60 pA, the maxima of interspike intervals determined under control conditions and during enflurane-induced bursting lie close together (Fig. 11B4). In addition, the spike rates during bursts were rather insensitive to the amount of injected current. Thus, during injection of a brief 60-pA current pulse, the number of evoked action potentials would be similar regardless of whether the anesthetic was present or not (see Fig. 12). From the latter type of experiment it would not be obvious that, during persistent current injections, 2 MAC enflurane decreased the discharge rate by ~50% (Fig. 11B3). Furthermore, the same experiment showed that, in the presence of enflurane, the discharge rate is modulated by the injected current (Fig. 11B5). Because depolarizing currents shortened interburst intervals and lengthened burst durations when enflurane was present, an increase in synaptic inhibition should have the opposite effects.
With 2 MAC enflurane, spontaneous activity of Purkinje cells was reduced by ~50% during extracellular and by ~60% during intracellular recordings. Compared with other reports, this is a rather low value. In hippocampal slices, 1-2 MAC halothane completely blocked population spikes evoked by stimulation of the mossy fiber pathway (Mody et al. 1991
). Pyramidal cells in organotypic slice cultures of the rat neocortex are similarly sensitive. Bath application of enflurane caused half-maximal inhibition of spontaneous activity close to 0.3 MAC (Antkowiak et al. 1995
). These results indicate considerable variations with respect to the particular preparation chosen for the study.
Several authors have proposed that volatile anesthetics disturb synaptic transmission in the mammalian CNS by altering presynaptic Ca2+ influx (for a review see Kress and Tas 1993
). The amount of transmitter released on presynaptic action potentials depends on the increase in intracellular Ca2+ in the presynaptic bouton. The depression of IPSC amplitudes summarized in Fig. 4B may be explained by a blockage of presynaptic Ca2+ channels. Assuming such a mechanism in the case of enflurane, depression of IPSC amplitudes should not occur in the presence of TTX when presynaptic action potentials are suppressed. However, this was not observed, as indicated in Fig. 10. The suggestion that enflurane diminished presynaptic Ca2+ influx is also at variance with the finding that clinical concentrations of isoflurane did not block Ca2+ currents of acutely dissociated Purkinje cells (Hall et al. 1994b
).
Takenoshita and Takahashi (1987)
investigated the effects of halothane on spontaneous inhibitory postsynaptic potentials recorded from spinal neurons. In this study, depression of inhibitory postsynaptic potential amplitudes by halothane was attributed to a decrease in presynaptic Ca2+ influx. There are several possible explanations for the differences with regard to the effects observed in the cerebellum and spinal cord. The composition of Ca2+ channels may differ between the two preparations and the Ca2+ currents are possibly affected in a different manner. A high sensitivity of Ca2+ channels has indeed been reported in hippocampal and neocortical preparations (Puil et al. 1994
; Study 1994
). Furthermore, the mechanisms underlying the amplitude depressant effect may depend on the concentration applied.
All in all, we have identified various actions of a volatile anesthetic occurring simultaneously in a range of clinically relevant concentrations, making it difficult to precisely determine the ionic mechanisms producing the changes in the spike patterns. Our results demonstrate that increasedGABAA-mediated inhibition reduced spontaneous spike rates of Purkinje cells, whereas burst discharges were probably caused by a parallel action of the anesthetic on Ih and spike afterhyperpolarizations.