Correspondence to: Leslie R. Schover, PhD, Department of Behavioral Science, The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, 1515 Holcombe Blvd.243, Houston, TX 77030-4009 (e-mail: lschover{at}mdanderson.org)
The conventional wisdom is that breast cancer devastates womens lives, even when the disease is controlled by modern, multimodality treatments. We, the general public, take our stereotypes not so much from real life but from novels, movies of the week, and soap operas. Our poor heroine loses her breast (or at least gains an ugly scar that would turn off any but the most desperate man). Needless to say, her sex life falls apart. If she is single, her boyfriend leaves her. If she is married, she ends up divorced while her husband finds a younger partner who flaunts a perfect bosom in skimpy halter tops when our heroine picks up the kids for weekend visits. Of course we learn that our heroine the survivor only got breast cancer because of stress. In the last 3 years, she lost both her parents in a tragic plane crash, her teenaged son was arrested for marijuana possession, she supported her husband emotionally and financially when he was fired from his job for insider trading, and after fending off sexual advances from her boss, she was passed over for the job promotion she clearly deserved.
I admit, this is a highly dramatized picture of our stereotypes about the consequences of breast cancer, but many health professionals as well as the general public firmly believe that breast loss is the worst trauma of breast cancer, that men commonly desert women treated for breast cancer, that it is impossible to have a satisfying sex life after breast cancer treatment, that stress plays a major role in causing breast cancer, and that breast cancer survivors typically face job discrimination.
Over the last decade, Dr. Elizabeth Maunsell and her colleagues in Quebec have systematically debunked each component of this breast cancer myth. In an 8-year follow-up of women who had mastectomy versus breast conservation (1), Maunsell et al. found no major differences in quality of life between the two groups of women, confirming the results of large surveys in the United States (24). Although having a mastectomy is upsetting, the greatest physical and emotional morbidity from breast cancer comes simply from being diagnosed with a lifethreatening illness (2,3). In fact, the cancer treatment that contributes to most longterm physical and emotional morbidity is adjuvant chemotherapy (24). The Canadian (5) and United States (2,3) surveys agree that middleclass, Caucasian women who are long-term survivors of breast cancer have a quality of life that is as good as or better than agematched control women!
Although approximately 50% of survivors of breast cancer report some sexual dysfunction, similar rates are seen among postmenopausal women who have not had cancer (2). Dr. Maunsells group did find that breast cancer survivors who lived with a partner had more sexual problems than a group of healthy women matched in age and place of residence (5). This group of women may be those treated with chemotherapy and made prematurely menopausal, and who thus have an increased likelihood of sexual dysfunction, as seen in other cohorts (24). Yet the most sexually satisfied women in the U.S. survey were those who had found a new sexual partner after their cancer diagnosis (2). Romance can still trump biology.
Maunsell et al. also demonstrated that marital breakdown is no more common among women after breast cancer than among control women matched on demographics (6,7). However, as common sense would predict, women who were dissatisfied with their relationships 3 months after their cancer diagnosis were more likely to have experienced a break-up or divorce by 8-year follow-up than women who were satisfied with their relationships at 3 months (6).
Not only have Maunsell and colleagues investigated quality of life after breast cancer but they have also examined the link between stress and breast cancer etiology. They conducted interviews with 673 women several months after breast cancer diagnosis, in which the women were asked, using a standardized checklist, to identify stressful life events they had experienced within the last 5 years. Ten years later, the number of stressful events women experienced was not predictive of survival, even after the analysis was weighted according to standards of severity, or according to the womans own perceived severity (8). A metaanalysis of the literature on stress and breast cancer also failed to find a connection between the two events (9). Other recent investigations have not found increased rates of breast cancer after losing a child to death (10) or caring for an ill family member (11).
In this issue of the Journal, Maunsell and colleagues (12) have focused on employment experiences among breast cancer survivors after their treatment. In their own pilot work, the researchers had interviewed 13 breast cancer survivors who mentioned jobrelated problems during a clinic visit (13). These women told about losing jobs, feeling stigmatized in the workplace, and experiencing an inability to meet the physical demands of work. However, populationbased studies have not confirmed this picture. In the United States, data from the Health and Retirement Study of 1992 showed that breast cancer survivors were only 10% less likely to be employed than women who were similar demographically but who had not had cancer (14). In a follow-up of a large cohort of breast cancer survivors, Ganz and colleagues (3) reported that 80% of women initially employed and free of disease at an average follow-up of 6-years were still working. Those women who changed work status most typically had retired or had reduced their work to parttime. Two other recent surveys found that the great majority of women diagnosed with breast cancer before age 50 years (15) or treated with adjuvant chemotherapy (16) returned to their preillness work status.
One caveat to this positive picture of employment is that women with physically demanding, bluecollar jobs may have more difficulty returning to work after breast cancer (17). Most research on breast cancer survivorship is based on predominantly Caucasian, middleclass sample populations (2). By contrast, both rural and urban women were included in the populationbased study in Quebec by Maunsell et al. (12), but their study population is without the ethnic variation that might be seen in a large, U.S. cohort. Approximately threefourths of the women in the study were employed in whitecollar jobs (12). Maunsell and colleagues dispel the myth of widespread job discrimination after breast cancer. Women employed at the time of diagnosis did not experience involuntary occupational loss or job discrimination compared with other women of similar age and demographic background. Maunsell et al. (12) found that most postcancer reduction in employment was voluntary. Experiencing cancer tended to alter womens priorities so that they valued career goals less and saw increased worth in time for family and enjoyment of life. A subgroup of women also reduced working hours because of ill health, usually when the cancer recurred.
It is reassuring to see comparable findings between Canada, where womens access to health care is independent of occupational status, and the United States, where affordable private health insurance is usually tied to a particular job. We should, however, not grow complacent about, nor should we trivialize, the emotional and physical pain of acute cancer treatment. However, future research on breast cancer survivorship should focus on those women who may be at increased risk for poor psychosocial outcomes: those who belong to underserved minority groups, are less well educated, are younger at diagnosis, have conflicted relationships, are coping with advanced disease, and are made prematurely menopausal by adjuvant chemotherapy (18).
REFERENCES
1 Dorval M, Maunsell E, Deschenes L, Brisson J. Type of mastectomy and quality of life for long term breast carcinoma survivors. Cancer 1998;83:21308.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
2 Ganz PA, Rowland JH, Desmond K, Meyerowitz BE, Wyatt GE. Life after breast cancer: understanding womens healthrelated quality of life and sexual functioning. J Clin Oncol 1998;16:50114.[Abstract]
3 Ganz PA, Desmond KA, Leedham B, Rowland JH, Meyerowitz BE, Belin TR. Quality of life in longterm diseasefree survivors of breast cancer: a follow-up study. J Natl Cancer Inst 2002;94:3949.
4 Schover LR, Yetman RJ, Tuason LJ, Meisler E, Esselstyn CB, Hermann RE, et al. Partial mastectomy and breast reconstruction. A comparison of their effects on psychosocial adjustment, body image, and sexuality. Cancer 1995;75:5464.[ISI][Medline]
5 Dorval M, Maunsell E, Deschenes L, Brisson J, Masse B. Longterm quality of life after breast cancer: Comparison of 8-year survivors with population controls. J Clin Oncol 1998;16:48794.[Abstract]
6 Dorval M, Maunsell E, Taylor-Brown J, Kilpatrick M. Marital stability after breast cancer. J Natl Cancer Inst 1999;91:549.
7 Taylor-Brown J, Kilpatrick M, Maunsell E, Dorval M. Partner abandonment of women with breast cancer: myth or reality? Cancer Pract 2000;8:1604.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
8 Maunsell E, Brisson J, Mondor M, Verreault R, Deschenes L. Stressful life events and survival after breast cancer. Psychosom Med 2001;63:30615.
9 Duijts SF, Zeegers MP, Borne BV. The association between stressful life events and breast cancer risk: a metaanalysis. Int J Cancer 2003; 107:10239.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
10 Lambe M, Cerrato R, Askling J, Hsieh CC. Maternal breast cancer risk after the death of a child. Int J Cancer 2004;110:7636.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
11 Kroenke CH, Hankinson SE, Schernhammer ES, Colditz GA, Kawachi I, Holmes MD. Caregiving stress, endogenous sex steroid hormone levels, and breast cancer incidence. Am J Epidemiol 2004;159:101927.
12 Maunsell E. A populationbased study. J Natl Cancer Inst 2004;96:181322.
13 Maunsell E, Brisson C, Dubois L, Lauzier S, Fraser A. Work problems after breast cancer: an exploratory qualitative study. Psychooncology 1999;8:46773.[ISI][Medline]
14 Bradley CJ, Bednarek HL, Neumark D. Breast cancer and womens labor supply. Health Serv Res 2002;37:130928.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
15 Bloom JR, Stewart SL, Chang S, Banks PJ. Then and now: quality of life of young breast cancer survivors. Psychooncology 2004;13:14760.[ISI][Medline]
16 Bushunow PW, Sun Y, Raubertas RF, Rosenthal S. Adjuvant chemotherapy does not affect employment in patients with earlystage breast cancer. J Gen Intern Med 1995;10:736.[ISI][Medline]
17 Satariano WA, DeLorenze GN. The likelihood of returning to work after breast cancer. Public Health Rep 1996;111:23641.[ISI][Medline]
18 Ganz PA, Hirji K, Sim MS, Schag CA, Fred C, Polinsky ML. Predicting psychosocial risk in patients with breast cancer. Med Care 1993;31:41931.[ISI][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles in HighWire Press-hosted journals:
![]() |
||||
|
Oxford University Press Privacy Policy and Legal Statement |