Body Mass Index in Childhood— Measuring a Moving Target

Mary Horlick

Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, Columbia University, New York, New York 10032

Address all correspondence and requests for reprints to: Mary Horlick, M.D., Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, Columbia University, New York, New York 10032. E-mail: mnh1{at}columbia.edu

The perplexing matter of the measurement of a moving target, relative fatness in children and adolescents, is addressed in this issue by Lindsay et al. (1) from the NIH population study of diabetes in the Gila River Indian Community in Arizona. They conclude from their analysis of over 900 Pima children, ages 5–20 yr, that body mass index (BMI) is a good measure of adiposity, and that BMI and dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry (DXA)-derived fat variables (percent body fat and fat mass) have broadly similar relationships to cardiovascular risk factors. The relationship of BMI to DXA variables in their report is in agreement with earlier studies in African American and Caucasian children (2, 3). The increased prevalence of childhood overweight and obesity, as well as the recognition that members of minority groups are at particular risk for morbidities associated with obesity, make investigation of measures and metabolic implications of adiposity in specific ethnic groups, such as in this study, especially important (4, 5).

BMI is readily obtained in clinical and field settings. It has established validity in the definition of adult obesity by health outcome, although its association with more precise measures of fat also varies with age in adults (6, 7). The normal changes in BMI with growth and maturation, generally reflecting increase in fat free mass more than fat mass, complicate the use of absolute values for BMI as a measure of fatness in children (2, 8). In 1982, Rolland-Cachera et al. (9) compared various measures of weight for height and, with qualifications, identified BMI as a reasonable index of pediatric adiposity and proposed reference values for BMI by age and sex for French children. Other national reference standards have also been published, most recently from the National Center for Health Statistics as BMI percentile charts (10). An expert committee recommended guidelines for screening overweight adolescents based on BMI percentiles for age and sex ("at risk for overweight" >85%, "overweight" >95%) (11). These guidelines had low false positive rates, but also low sensitivity for detecting a high percentage of body fat (12, 13). The International Obesity Task Force extrapolated the WHO standards for adult obesity (overweight, >=25 kg/m2; obese, >=30 kg/m2) to children and adolescents 6–18 yr of age to establish an international definition of pediatric obesity (14). Because these two definitions of pediatric overweight are not based on health outcome and remain controversial, investigations of the cardiovascular risk associations of BMI and other measures of fatness, such as that presented by Lindsay et al. (1), are important contributions.

But can the conclusions about the associations of BMI as a continuous variable to DXA measures and to cardiovascular risk factors from this study be applied to the general population? As noted by the authors, the Pima Indians of Arizona suffer unprecedented high levels of obesity in childhood and later life. The mean BMI values for this study population were "at risk for overweight" (5–9 yr), "overweight" (10–14 yr), and "obese" (15–19 yr) by both the BMI percentile and international definitions; thus, the associations with BMI are all based on comparisons within a predominantly overweight population. Unquestionably, this information is important for clinicians evaluating obese children; BMI has now been shown to correlate with cardiovascular risk factors in groups of overweight children from three backgrounds in the United States (African American, Caucasian, and Native American; Refs. 15 and 16). However, the observed associations of BMI and DXA variables with cardiovascular risk may only be applicable to subjects with high BMI for age, not to subjects across all BMI ranges.

What does BMI measure in children and adolescents? The components of BMI (body mass/stature2) are fat mass/stature2 and fat free mass/stature2. Pediatric studies, including that of Lindsay et al. (1), show a strong correlation between BMI and fat mass, but there is also correlation between BMI and fat free mass (8). Whether fat or fat free mass is the dominant determinant of BMI, or the driving force for increase in BMI, depends on age, sex, pubertal stage, and ethnicity (2, 3, 8, 17). The stronger relationship of BMI to fat mass than to percent body fat observed in the current study by Lindsay et al. (1) is consistent with other studies. All reports that include a measure of percent body fat demonstrate that, for a given BMI, percent body fat is lower in boys than girls, lower with increasing age and more specifically with more advanced puberty, and lower in African Americans than Caucasians. What a given BMI measures depends on the body composition of the subject, and for a given BMI there is a range of percent body fat (3). This is why use of BMI in childhood is an attempt to measure a moving target—weight/stature2—that increases and also changes in composition with normal growth. Nonetheless, it is highly correlated with specific measures of adiposity in children, possibly more so in overweight subjects, and, as now demonstrated by Lindsay et al. (1), in Pima Indians in addition to African Americans and Caucasians (2, 3, 8, 13).

Lindsay et al. (1) did not explore the strength of the relationship of BMI and DXA fat variables to cardiovascular risk factors in detail. The current high prevalence of pediatric obesity, its consequences during childhood, and its implications for adulthood make extension of this analysis the next task, with the goal of establishing health risk-based definitions of pediatric obesity (4, 5). This is imperative for clinical care and research and needs to be done in a population with a representative range of adiposity. An example is the recently proposed cutoffs for both percent body fat by DXA and waist circumference based on association with cardiovascular risk factors in prepubertal children (18). This kind of investigation, combined with analysis of the relationship of specific measures of adiposity to BMI percentiles or SD scores for age, will yield more sensitive definitions of childhood obesity (19). Previous reports of ethnic differences not only in body composition but also in the implications of given body composition characteristics, as well as observations that particular populations are a greater risk for the comorbidities of obesity, suggest that these definitions will likely be sex and ethnic specific, and will also be influenced by pubertal status (17, 20, 21). The definitions will provide tools for clinicians to recognize and monitor patients needing intervention, and for researchers to identify phenotypes for investigation of mechanisms and candidate genes, and hopefully to design effective specific treatments or means of prevention. The participation of 985 Pima Indian children in this study of body composition and metabolic parameters by Lindsay et al. (1) demonstrates that children will help investigators accomplish this important task.

Footnotes

Abbreviations: BMI, Body mass index; DXA, dual-energy x-ray absorptiometry.

Received July 18, 2001.

Accepted July 23, 2001.

References

  1. Lindsay RS, Hanson RL, Roumain J, Ravussin E, Knowler WC, Tataranni PA 2001 Body mass index as a measure of adiposity in children and young adults: relationship to adiposity by dual energy x-ray absorptiometry and to cardiovascular risk factors. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 86:4061–4067[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  2. Daniels SR, Khoury PR, Morrison JA 1997 The utility of body mass index as a measure of body fatness in children and adolescents: differences by race and gender. Pediatrics 99:507–526
  3. Pietrobelli A, Faith MS, Allison DB, Gallagher D, Chiumello G, Heymsfield SB 1998 Body mass index as a measure of adiposity among children and adolescents: a validation study. J Pediatr 132:204–210[Medline]
  4. Troiano RP, Flegal KM 1998 Overweight children and adolescents: description, epidemiology and demographics. Pediatrics 101:497–504[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  5. Glaser NS 1997 Non-insulin dependent diabetes mellitus in childhood and adolescence. Pediatr Clin North Am 44:307–337[Medline]
  6. U.S. Department of Health and Human Services 1998 Clinical guidelines on the identification, evaluation, and treatment of overweight and obesity in adults: the evidence report. Washington, DC: US DHHS (98-4083)
  7. Gallagher D, Visser M, Sepulveda D, Pierson RN, Harris T, Heymsfield SB 1996 How useful is body mass index for comparison of body fatness across age, sex, and ethnic groups? Am J Epidemiol 143:228–239[Abstract]
  8. Maynard LM, Wisemandle W, Roche AF, Chumlea WC, Guo SS, Siervogel RM 2001 Childhood body composition in relation to body mass index. Pediatrics 107:344–350[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  9. Rolland-Cachera MF, Sempe M, Guilloud-Bataille M, Patois E, Pequignot-Guggenbuhl F, Fautrad V 1982 Adiposity indices in children. Am J Clin Nutr 36:178–184[Abstract]
  10. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Health Statistics 2000 CDC growth charts: United States. http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/about/major/nhanes/growthcharts/charts.htm
  11. Himes JH, Dietz WH 1994 Guidelines for overweight and adolescent preventive services: recommendations from an expert committee. Am J Clin Nutr 59:307–316[Abstract]
  12. Lazarus R, Baur L, Webb K, Blyth F 1996 Body mass index in screening for adiposity in children and adolescents: systematic evaluation using receiver operating characteristic curves. Am J Clin Nutr 63:500–506[Abstract]
  13. Schaefer F, Georgi M, Wuhl E, Scharer K 1999 Body mass index and percentage fat mass in healthy German schoolchildren and adolescents. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 22:461–469[CrossRef]
  14. Cole TJ, Bellizzi MC, Flegal KM, Dietz WH 2000 Body mass index in children worldwide: cut-off points for overweight and obesity. Br Med J 320:1–6[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  15. Morrison JA, Sprecher DL, Barton BA, Waclawiw MA, Daniels SR 1999 Overweight, fat patterning, and cardiovascular disease risk factors in black and white girls: The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute Growth and Health Study. J Pediatr 135:458–464[Medline]
  16. Morrison JA, Barton BA, Biro FM, Daniels SR, Sprecher DL 1999 Overweight, fat patterning, and cardiovascular disease risk factors in black and white boys. J Pediatr 135:451–457[Medline]
  17. Travers SH, Jeffers BW, Bloch CA, Hill JO, Eckel RH 1995 Gender and Tanner stage differences in body composition and insulin sensitivity in early pubertal children. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 80:172–178[Abstract]
  18. Higgins PB, Gower BA, Hunter GR, Goran MI 2001 Defining health-related obesity in prepubertal children. Obes Res 9:233–240[Abstract/Free Full Text]
  19. Horlick M, Pietrobelli A, Mei Z, Heymsfield SB 2000 Body mass index-% fat relationship: relevance to pediatric percent fat ranges for overweight and obesity. Obes Res 8:17S
  20. Gower BA, Nagy TR, Goran MI 1999 Visceral fat, insulin sensitivity, and lipids in prepubertal children. Diabetes 48:1515–1521[Abstract]
  21. Yanovski JA, Yanovski SZ, Filmer KM, et al. 1997 Differences in body composition of black and white girls. Am J Clin Nutr 64:833–839[Abstract]