From the Department of Medicine, Royal Victoria Hospital, and Department of Biochemistry, McGill University, Montréal, Québec, Canada H3A 1A1
![]() |
ABSTRACT |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Members of the family of fungal zinc cluster DNA-binding proteins possess 6 highly conserved cysteines that bind to two zinc atoms forming a structure (Zn2Cys6) that is required for recognition of specific DNA sequences. Many zinc cluster proteins have been shown to bind as homodimers to a pair of CGG triplets oriented either as direct (CGG NX CGG), inverted (CGG NX CCG), or everted repeats (CCG NX CGG), where N indicates nucleotides. Variation in the spacing between the CGG triplets also contributes to the diversity of sites recognized. For example, Leu3p binds to the everted sequence CCG N4 CGG with a strict requirement for a 4-base pair spacing. Here, we show that another member of the family, Uga3p, recognizes the same DNA motif as Leu3p. However, these transcription factors have distinct DNA targets. We demonstrate that additional specificity of binding is provided by nucleotides located between the two everted CGG triplets. Altering the 4 nucleotides between to the two everted CGG triplets switches the specificity from a Uga3p site to a Leu3p site in both in vitro and in vivo assays. Thus, our results identify a new mechanism that expands the repertoire of DNA targets of the family of zinc cluster proteins. These experiments provide a model for discrimination between targets of zinc cluster proteins.
![]() |
INTRODUCTION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
In fungi, many transcriptional regulators are characterized by the presence of a zinc finger containing a cluster of 6 cysteines (consensus sequence: CX2CX6CX5-9CX2CX6-8C) that are bound by two zinc atoms and are referred to as zinc cluster proteins or Zn2Cys6 binuclear cluster proteins. Over 50 have been characterized in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae (1, 2). The Zn2Cys6 domain is usually followed by a short linker region that bridges the zinc finger to the dimerization domain consisting of a coiled-coil consisting of heptad repeats (1). Zinc cluster proteins usually bind as homodimers to target DNA sequences.
Gal4p, which is required for activation of genes related to galactose metabolism, recognizes an inverted repeat consisting of CGG triplets spaced by 11 base pairs (bp)1 (CGG N11 CCG), where N indicates nucleotides, with each zinc finger recognizing a CGG triplet (3). Some other members of this family bind to similar sites with an alternate spacing. For instance, Put3p, which activates genes related to proline metabolism, recognizes a DNA sequence related to that of Gal4p but with a spacing of 10 bp (CGG N10 CCG), whereas the activator of genes of the pyrimidine pathway, Ppr1p, binds to the sequence CGG N6 CCG (4-7). Determination of the solution or crystal structure of the DNA-binding domains of Gal4p, Ppr1p, and Put3p has revealed that their zinc fingers have a very similar structure which contacts the highly conserved CGG triplets (7-12) (reviewed in Ref. 13). Furthermore, zinc fingers of Gal4p, Ppr1p, and Put3p can be interchanged without altering the specificity of binding (14).
Other zinc cluster proteins also recognize CGG triplets but with a different orientation. For example, Hap1p, which activates genes required for cellular respiration, binds as a homodimer to a direct repeat consisting of two CGG triplets spaced by 6 bp (CGG N6 CGG) (15, 16). In addition, two other zinc cluster proteins, Leu3p and Pdr3p, bind to CGG triplets oriented in opposite directions, an everted repeat (CCG NX CGG) (17). Leu3p activates genes for the metabolism of branched amino acids and GDH1 which encodes NADP-dependent glutamate dehydrogenase, an enzyme involved in ammonium assimilation (18, 19).
Leu3p, which forms a homodimer in solution (20), is constitutively
bound to target sites (21), and its activity is positively regulated by
-isopropyl malate, an intermediate of leucine metabolism (22). Even
though direct and inverted repeats consisting of CGG triplets are found
in UASLEU3 (upstream activating sequence), we have shown,
by mutational analysis, that Leu3p actually binds to an everted repeat
containing two CGG triplets spaced by 4 bp (CCG N4 CGG). Alternatively,
DNA targets of Leu3p could be considered to be an inverted repeat
with the sequence CCG. However, a chimeric protein in which the
zinc finger of Gal4p was replaced by the corresponding region of Leu3p
was shown to recognize a Gal4p site (CGG N11 CCG) but not an inverted
repeat with the sequence CCG N11 CGG (17). These results show that
Leu3p does recognize the sequence CGG and strongly suggest that
the two zinc fingers of Leu3p are oriented in opposite orientations to
those of Gal4p (8).
Alteration of the spacing between the CGG triplets completely abolishes binding of Leu3p to a target site in vitro. Similarly, another member of this family, Pdr3p, a positive transcriptional regulator of multi-drug resistance genes (23, 24), binds to an everted repeat with no intervening nucleotides (CCGCGG) (17, 25, 26). Thus, diversity of binding sites is generated, in part, by three different DNA motifs (direct, inverted, and everted repeats) as well as differences between the number of nucleotides between the CGG triplets.
Other members of the family of zinc cluster proteins include Uga3p
(also called Dur3p) and Dal81p (also called Uga35p or Durlp). Dal81p is
a general positive regulator of genes involved in nitrogen utilization
through catabolism of -aminobutyrate (GABA), urea, arginine, and
allatoin (27, 28). The role of another member of the family of zinc
cluster proteins, Uga3p, is restricted to genes related to GABA
metabolism (29). Activity of Uga3p is dependent on the presence of GABA
resulting in activation of the genes for GABA utilization as a nitrogen
source such as the UGA1 and the UGA4 genes that
encode GABA transaminase and GABA permease, respectively (28-31).
Deletion of either UGA3 or DAL81 impairs activation of UGA1 and UGA4 (27-31).
Unexpectedly, deletion of DNA sequences encoding the zinc finger
of Dal81p does not affect its function suggesting that Dal81p may not
act by binding to specific DNA sequences. Target sites have been
identified in the UGA1 and UGA4 genes (31). These
UASs contain three (or four) CGG triplets that could be recognized by
Uga3p (see Fig. 1).
We have performed detailed mutagenesis of the UAS of UGA1. Our results show that Uga3p recognizes an everted CGG repeat spaced by 4 bp, a sequence similar to the target site of Leu3p. However, Leu3p does not recognize targets of Uga3p and vice versa. We show that additional specificity is provided by nucleotides located between the two CGG triplets.
![]() |
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURES |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Strains
Yeast (S. cerevisiae) strain YPH499 (32) (ura3-52
lys2-801 ade2-101 trp1-63 his3-
2000 leu2-
1) was used as wild
type. Disruption of the UGA3 was done by transforming YPH499
with linearized plasmid pUGA-HIS (see below) and selecting for
histidine auxotrophy. Deletion of DNA sequences encoding the zinc
finger of LEU3 was performed by the method of Baudin
et al. (33). The HIS3 gene was amplified by PCR
using pHIS3 (see below) as template and the oligonucleotides
primers
5'-GGAATAGAACTGGGATGAATGCTAGGAAAAGGAAATTCGCCTGCAGGGTTTTCCCAGTCA-3' and
5'-AAATTGATGATATTTTGTCGCAAATTCTTGAAACAGCTCAGCAGCGGATAACAATTTCAC-3'. Homologous recombination was verified by PCR or Southern blot analysis.
Plasmids
Disruption Plasmid and Expression Vector-- A portion of the UGA3 gene that encodes its DNA-binding domain (a.a 1-124) was PCR-amplified with Vent polymerase (New England Biolabs) using the primers 5'-CGGGATCCATGAATTATGGCGTGGAGAA-3' (initiator codon in bold) and 5'-GGAATTCAGTAGTTGTACAGCT-3' and yeast genomic DNA isolated from the strain YPH499 (32) as a template. The PCR product was cut by BamHI and EcoRI, purified on a column (PCR purification kit, Promega), and subcloned into pRSET-A (Invitrogen) or pGEX-f (17) cut with the same enzymes to give pUGA3-(1-124) and pGST-UGA3-(1-124), respectively. The HIS3 gene was amplified with the primers 5'-TTACTCTTGGCCTCCTCTAG-3' and 5'-GCCTCGTTCAGAATGACACG-3', and the PCR product was subcloned into the EcoRV site of pZERO-2 (Invitrogen) to give pMHIS3. The UGA3 disruption plasmid, pUGA-HIS, was constructed by subcloning the EagI fragment of pMHIS3 containing the HIS3 gene into the EagI site of pUGA3-(1-124). The resulting construct disrupts the UGA3 gene at nucleotide 244 relative to the ATG.
Reporters--
Reporter plasmids were constructed by inserting
double-stranded oligonucleotides in front of a derivative of SLF178
containing a minimal CYC1 promoter driving lacZ
transcription (34). Oligonucleotide 5'-TCGAAAAGCCGCGGGCGGGATTGTAC-3'
and its complementary sequence 5'-AATCCCGCCCGCGGCTTT-3' were used to
generate pUGA1-WT containing one copy of the UAS of UGA1
(31) in front of a minimal CYC1 promoter. Similarly, oligonucleotide
5'-TCGATCGGCCGGAACCGGCTTTGTAC-3' and its complementary sequence
5'-AAAGCCGGTTCCGGCCGA-3' were used to give pLEU2-WT containing one copy
of the UAS of LEU2 (18). Reporter ULU, containing sequences
corresponding to the UAS of LEU2 flanked by sequences of the
UAS of UGA1, was constructed using the oligonucleotide
5'-TCGAAAAGCCGGAACCGGGATTGTAC-3' and its complementary sequence
5'-AATCCCGGTTCCGGCTTT-3'. Sequences of the mutants of the UASs of
UGA1 and LEU2 are given in Tables I-III. All
reporters were sequenced to verify the correct construction of the
UASs.
-Galactosidase Assays
Strains were transformed with reporters and selected on plates
lacking uracil. Colonies were grown overnight in YPD (35). Cells were
then diluted in SD (35) supplemented with histidine, leucine, lysine,
tryptophan, and adenine at 0.004% (w/v) and glucose (2% final
concentration). Activity of Uga3p was induced by adding GABA to the
medium (0.1% final concentration). -Galactosidase activity was
measured with permeabilized cells (36).
-Galactosidase assays were
performed at least twice in duplicates.
In Vitro Binding of Leu3p and Uga3p
The DNA-binding domain of Leu3p (a.a. 1-147) was expressed in E. coli as a glutathione S-transferase fusion protein and purified as described (17). The glutathione S-transferase moiety was removed by cleavage with thrombin. The DNA-binding domain of Uga3p (a.a. 1-124) fused to a 6xHis tag was expressed as described (17) except that whole bacterial extracts were used for electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA). EMSAs were performed as described (17). Competitor probes were generated by PCR using the primers 5'-AAGATGCGGCCAGCAAAACT-3' and 5'-CAGAGCACATGCATGCCATA-3' and the reporters as templates. The PCR products were then purified on a column (Qiagen). Labeled UAS of LEU2 (0.15 pmol) was added to 4, 25, 100, and 200 × excess of cold competitors, and Leu3 (a.a. 1-147) was added last. After 30 min at room temperature, the mixture was loaded on a 4% acrylamide gel. The percentage of binding (with no competitor taken as 100%) was measured (PhosphorImager, Fuji) and plotted against the log of the concentration of the cold competitor. Relative affinities were determined by comparing the concentration of each competitor required to give 50% binding as compared with the wild type competitor.
![]() |
RESULTS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
The UASs UASLEU3 and UASUGA3 have 6 identical nucleotides (Fig. 1, Ref. 31). We first set out to determine if Leu3p and Uga3p have different target specificities and, if so, to identify which nucleotides are responsible for the discrimination between a Leu3p and a Uga3p target.
|
The UAS of UGA1 and LEU2 Are Activated by Distinct Zinc Cluster
Proteins--
We inserted the UAS of LEU2 or the UAS of
UGA1 (or mutants) upstream of a minimal CYC1 promoter
driving lacZ transcription. The reporters were transformed
in a wild type strain or strains carrying disruption of genes encoding
the transcriptional activators Uga3p or Leu3p, and their activity was
assayed. As shown in Table I, activity
of the UAS of UGA1 was induced 15-fold in a wild type strain
grown in the presence of GABA and gave background levels in a
uga3 strain. Deletion of the LEU3 gene had no
effect on UGA1 activity indicating that Leu3p does not
recognize the UAS of UGA1. As expected, activity of the UAS
of LEU2 was reduced about 80 times in a strain carrying a
deletion of the LEU3 gene, whereas the activity was reduced
3-4 times in a uga3
strain (Table I). If Uga3p was
directly involved in the activation of LEU2, one would
expect increased activity in the presence of GABA. However, the UAS of
LEU2 showed slightly decreased activity in the presence of
GABA in a wild type strain suggesting that the reduced activity is due
to indirect effect. These results show that even if the UASs of
UGA1 and LEU2 are related, they are activated by
distinct zinc cluster proteins, Uga3p and Leu3p, respectively.
|
Uga3p Recognizes an Everted Repeat Spaced by 4 bp--
If Uga3p
recognizes CGG triplets, there are three triplets within the UAS of
UGA1 that are potentially important for its activity (Fig. 1). To
determine the importance of each of these CGG triplets, we mutated each
one to CGA and assayed the activity of the resulting mutants. Mutating
the first or the third CGG triplet of the UAS of UGA1
reduced -galactosidase activity 300- and 15-fold, respectively (Table I, mutants UGA1-A and UGA1-C). Similarly,
mutations in both the first and third CGGs resulted in background
activity (Table I, mutant UGA1-D). In contrast, a mutant
bearing a nucleotide alteration in the second CGG triplet showed high
activity that was dependent on Uga3p and GABA but not on Leu3p. Thus,
CGG triplets numbers 1 and 3, which correspond to an everted repeat,
appear to be essential for transcriptional activation by Uga3p.
In Vitro Binding of Uga3p to the UASs of UGA1 and Mutants-- We compared the activity in vivo of wild type or mutated UGA1 sequences with binding of the Uga3p DNA-binding domain to these sequences in vitro. With a probe corresponding to the UAS of UGA1, a retarded complex was formed in the presence of an extract prepared from cells containing the expression vector for Uga3p (a.a. 1-124) (Fig. 2) but not the parental vector (data not shown). Nucleotide alteration in the first CGG triplet (UGA1-A), but not the second (UGA1-B), abolished binding of Uga3p, an observation consistent with the relative function of these sequences in reporter plasmids in vivo. Mutation in the third CGG triplet (UGA1-C) resulted in a weak complex of identical mobility to that formed on the wild type sequence and a complex of faster mobility which may correspond to a monomer as observed for another zinc cluster protein (37). Mutations in both the first and the third CGG triplets (UGA1-D) completely abolished binding of Uga3p, an observation consistent with the background activity of the double mutant in vivo. Thus, the activity observed in vivo is correlated with in vitro binding of Uga3p.
|
Nucleotides Located between the Everted CGGs Discriminate between a
Uga3p and a Leu3p Site--
Our results suggested that nucleotides
other than those present in the everted CGG motifs are responsible for
discrimination between activation by Leu3p and Uga3p. To map these
nucleotides, a reporter containing sequences encompassing the everted
repeat of LEU2 flanked by sequences corresponding to the UAS
of UGA1 was made (reporter ULU, Table
II). The activity of that reporter was
similar to the UAS of LEU2, high in a wild type strain even in the absence of GABA and reduced to background levels in a
leu3 strain. These results suggest that key nucleotides
for discrimination of a Leu3 and a Uga3p site are located between the
two everted CGG triplets.
|
|
Nucleotides in the Middle of the UAS of UGA1 Are Important for Uga3p Activity-- We determined the importance of the two central nucleotides of the UAS of UGA1. For the wild type UAS of UGA1, the sequence GGCGG is on the top strand of the everted repeat and the sequence CGCGG is on the lower strand (nucleotide difference in bold). Therefore, we tested if the presence of a G or a C at that position is important for activation by Uga3p. We constructed two reporters containing the perfect everted repeats GGCGG or CGCGG. Strong activity was observed with either reporter (UGA1-L, UGA1-M, Table III), giving rise to 25-fold induction in the presence of GABA. The results show that the "optimal" target sequence for Uga3p consists of an everted repeat with the sequence (G/C)GCGG.
The importance of the two central nucleotides of the UAS of UGA1 and LEU2 was further assayed by substituting the AA sequence present in the middle of UAS of LEU2 by the sequence GG found in the UAS of UGA1 and vice versa. A double nucleotide alteration of the UAS of LEU2 (reporter LEU2-GG, Table III) had a 4-fold effect on activation by Leu3p. Similarly, mutating the two central nucleotides of the UAS of UGA1 to AA (mutant UGA1-AA, Table III) resulted in a 12-fold decrease ofAffinity of Leu3p to the UASs of LEU2, UGA1, and Mutants-- We correlated the in vivo activity of reporters described above with their ability to bind in vitro with the purified DNA-binding domain of Leu3p (a.a. 1-147; hereafter referred to as Leu3p). We measured the relative affinities of the UASs of LEU2 and UGA1 and mutants (Table IV). The affinity of UGA1 for Leu3p was weak (8%) compared with the affinity of the UAS of LEU2. The hybrid UAS consisting of the core sequence of LEU2 flanked by sequences of the UAS of UGA1 had similar affinity for Leu3p. In addition, the mutant of the LEU2 UAS, in which the central nucleotides were changed to those of the UGA1 UAS, had a reduced affinity for Leu3p (50%) relative to that of the wild type LEU2 UAS in agreement with its slightly reduced activity in vivo (4-fold). Thus, the Leu3p affinity for the mutant UASs is correlated with their in vivo activity.
|
![]() |
DISCUSSION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
In this report, we show that Leu3p and Uga3p recognize highly related but distinct DNA sequences as follows: an everted CGG repeat spaced by 4 bp (CCG N4 CGG) and that nucleotides located between the CGG triplets are important for discrimination between a Uga3p and a Leu3p site. For example, any mutation targeting the two everted CGG triplets resulted in decreased activation by Uga3p (Table I), whereas mutating a third CGG triplet in the middle of the UAS had only minor effects in analogy to Leu3p (17). These results correlate with in vitro binding of the DNA-binding domain of Uga3p to the UAS of UGA1 and mutants (Fig. 2). Comparison with the UAS of UGA4 shows that only the two everted CGG triplets are conserved in both UGA1 and UGA4 (Fig. 1). Thus, Uga3p and Leu3p recognize a similar DNA motif, an everted sequence spaced by 4 bp (CCG N4 CGG). However, a target of Uga3p, the UAS of UGA1, was shown not to be activated by Leu3p. Conversely, the UAS of LEU2 is not a target of Uga3p.
We showed that nucleotides located between the two CGG triplets are responsible for discriminating between a Uga3p site and a Leu3p site. Changing either nucleotides that flank the two everted CGG triplets of the UAS of UGA1 to those found in the UAS of LEU2 abolishes activation by Uga3p (Table II, reporters UGA1-G and UGA1-H). Double nucleotide alteration results in very weak activity for both activators. However, a reporter (3XUGA1-I) containing three copies of the double mutant is responsive to Leu3p but not Uga3p. Thus the nucleotides that flank the two everted CGG triplets of the UAS of UGA1 are important but not sufficient for discrimination between Uga3p and Leu3p. In addition, a UAS containing the repeat TCGG or ACGG (reporters UGA1-J and UGA1-K, Table III) is almost inactive. Thus, there is a strict requirement for G or C nucleotides flanking the CGG motifs for activation by Uga3p and Leu3p, respectively.
Other nucleotides in the middle of the UAS of UGA1 are important for activity since a double mutation (GG to AA) showed low transcriptional activity (reporter UGA1-AA). Thus, our results suggest that the site recognized by Uga3p is an everted repeat with the repeat sequence of (G/C)GCGG. The two nucleotides in the middle of the UAS of LEU2 also play a role in modulating activity by Leu3p. For example, substitution of the two As found in the middle of the UAS of LEU2 to G results in decreased activation (4-fold) by Leu3p and in vitro binding. This is in agreement with the fact that most nucleotides found in the middle of the six known targets of Leu3p are A/T-rich and that none of them have only Gs or Cs at these positions (Fig. 1). We have previously shown (17) that single mutations (to A or T) outside the everted CGG triplets reduced in vivo activation and in vitro binding of Leu3p (17).
Three other members of the family of zinc cluster proteins bind to inverted CGG triplets with a spacing of 11 bp (Gal4p, Lac9p) or 6 bp (Ppr1p). Mutations in the CGG triplets have drastic effects on in vitro binding by these proteins, whereas they can tolerate multiple changes of the nucleotides located between the CGG triplets (5, 38, 39). This is consistent with crystallographic data of the DNA-binding domain of Gal4 and Ppr1p which showed that most of the contacts with DNA are made through interaction with the CGG triplets (8, 11). It is likely that Leu3p makes additional contacts with nucleotides between the CGG triplets allowing discrimination between the UAS of LEU2 and the UAS of UGA1, although this was not detected by methylation interference analysis (18, 20). Additional protein-DNA contacts would account for the strict DNA sequence requirement for Uga3p.
In addition to Uga3p, Dal81p is also required for induction of the GABA-responsive genes. The exact role of Dal81p in activation of UGA1 is not clear. Unexpectedly, deletion of the entire zinc finger of Dal81p had no effect on activation of UGA1 (28) similar to another zinc cluster protein (40). In addition, deletion of the DAL81 gene did not affect transcription of the UGA3 gene (31). Probably Dal81p does not contact DNA to form a heterodimeric complex as observed for the zinc cluster proteins Oaf1p and Oaf2p (41). One possibility is that Dal81p rather helps Uga3p to dimerize, resulting in increased affinity for target sites or provides an activation domain required for increased gene expression.
Our results may serve as a model for discrimination between UASs by other classes of zinc cluster proteins which recognize a specific CGG motif with a given spacing. For example, three zinc cluster proteins (Put3p, Tea1p, and Cha4p) have been shown to recognize the same DNA motif, inverted CGG triplets spaced by 10 bp (7, 42, 43). However, Tea1p does not activate Put3p sites (42). Some additional nucleotides may be responsible for the discrimination as we have observed in the present study for Leu3p and Uga3p.
In conclusion, alternate DNA motifs (direct, inverted, and everted repeats) and variation in the spacing between the CGG triplets have previously been shown to generate a diversity of binding sites for the family of zinc cluster proteins. In addition, other zinc cluster proteins do not recognize a pair of CGG triplets (44, 45) extending the repertoire of target sites for the family of zinc cluster proteins. Our results show that additional specificity can be provided by nucleotides flanking the CGG triplets generating distinct binding patterns of zinc cluster proteins to DNA motifs of a given spacing. This provides another mechanism by which the number of specific targets recognized by members of the family of zinc cluster proteins is increased.
![]() |
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS |
---|
We are grateful to Dr. G. Hendy, Dr. J. White, and K. Chu for critical reading of the manuscript; to K. Hellauer for technical assistance; and to members of the Laboratory of Molecular Endocrinology for very helpful discussions.
![]() |
FOOTNOTES |
---|
* This work was supported in part by grants from the National Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada and the Canadian Genome Analysis and Technology Program.The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page charges. The article must therefore be hereby marked "advertisement" in accordance with 18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Supported by a studentship of the Research Institute of the Royal
Victoria Hospital.
§ Scholar of the Medical Research Council of Canada. To whom correspondence should be addressed: Dept. of Medicine, Royal Victoria Hospital, McGill University, 687 Pine Ave. West, Montréal, Québec, Canada H3A 1A1. Tel.: 514-842-1231 (ext. 5046); Fax: 514-982-0893; E-mail: turcotte{at}lan1.molonc.mcgill.ca.
1
The abbreviations used are: bp, base pair(s);
EMSA, electrophoretic mobility shift assay; GABA, -aminobutyrate;
glutathione S-transferase; a.a., amino acid(s); UAS,
upstream activating sequence(s).
![]() |
REFERENCES |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|