(Received for publication, August 16, 1995)
From the
Although a number of eukaryotic DNA helicases have been identified biochemically and still more have been inferred from the amino acid sequences of the products of cloned genes, none of the cellular helicases or putative helicases has to date been implicated in eukaryotic chromosomal DNA replication. By the same token, numerous eukaryotic replication proteins have been identified, but none of these is a helicase. We have recently identified and characterized a temperature-sensitive yeast mutant, dna2ts, defective in DNA replication, and have cloned the corresponding gene (Kuo, C.-L., Huang, C.-H., and Campbell, J. L.(1983) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 30, 6465-6469; Budd, M. E., and Campbell, J. L.(1995) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 92, 7642-7646). The DNA2 gene is essential and encodes a 172-kDa protein with DNA helicase motifs in its C-terminal half and an N-terminal half with no similarity to any previously described protein (Budd, M. E., and Campbell, J. L.(1995) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 92, 7642-7646). Here we show that the helicase domain is required in vivo and that a 3` to 5` DNA helicase activity specific for forked substrates is intrinsic to the Dna2p. The N terminus is also essential for DNA replication. Thus, the structure of this new helicase is different from all previously characterized replicative helicases, which is consistent with the complex organization of eukaryotic replication forks, where the activities of not one but three essential DNA polymerases must be coordinated.
A DNA helicase is a central component of the architecture of prokaryotic DNA replication forks. Reconstitution of the basal apparatus for replication of the SV40 virus has established the requirement for a DNA helicase in eukaryotic DNA replication as well. However, SV40 DNA replication requires only the helicase associated with the viral large T antigen and no cellular helicase. Therefore, we have looked for a cellular replicative helicase using yeast genetic analysis.
Recently, we characterized a gene, DNA2, which complements a temperature-sensitive yeast strain defective in the elongation stage of DNA replication(1, 2) . The DNA2 gene is essential for viability and encodes a 1522-amino acid protein, the most prominent feature of which is the presence of the six conserved motifs characteristic of DNA helicases. These motifs are localized to the COOH third of the protein (amino acids 1035-1522). In order to demonstrate that the protein had helicase activity, the HA-Dna2 protein was purified 50,000-fold. The immunoaffinity-purified protein was shown to be associated with a DNA-dependent ATPase and a DNA helicase. Interestingly, the helicase is active only on a substrate with a forked structure, as is true of many prokaryotic and viral replicative helicases and appears to translocate in the 3` to 5` direction, the polarity of the leading strand at a replication fork (2) .
While these experiments suggest that Dna2p is a replicative helicase, they are preliminary in two ways. First, although mock purifications yield no ATPase or helicase activity, our biochemical approach could not rule out that the ATPase and helicase activities were copurifying with, rather than intrinsic to, the Dna2p. Second, because more than two-thirds of the protein sequence was not conserved in any known helicase and might therefore encode some novel replicative function, our previous results did not allow us to conclude that the essential role of Dna2p in replication was that of a helicase. An example of a DNA-dependent ATPase and helicase whose essential function may not require the helicase activity of the protein is the Rad3 protein. Rad3 is essential for viability and is required for both nucleotide excision repair and for mRNA transcription. When the conserved lysine of the ATP-binding site, GKT, is changed to arginine, the protein loses its DNA dependent-ATPase and helicase. The resulting rad3 mutant is sensitive to UV irradiation but is viable(3, 4) . Thus, the helicase appears to be required for nucleotide excission repair but seems to be dispensable for the essential function of RAD3 in transcription. In this paper, we show that a helicase activity is intrinsic to the Dna2p and that the helicase is required for its in vivo function.
The occurrence of a helicase domain does not in itself mean
that it is part of the essential function of a gene. For instance, the
helicase activity of the Rad3 protein is dispensable for its role in
mRNA transcription(3, 4) . To investigate whether the
helicase domain of Dna2p contributed to its essential physiological
function, the invariant lysine 1080 in the major
GXGK(T/S) nucleotide-binding loop was changed to
glutamic acid. The lysine is essential for binding the
,
-phosphate of ATP or GTP(6) . The ability of
wild-type and ATPase mutant genes to complement the dna2-1
strain and a dna2
deletion
strain was then assessed. As shown in Fig. 1, dna2-1
cells transformed with the Dna2K (wild-type) plasmid are
complemented for growth at 37 °C, but cells transformed with the
Dna2E (mutant) plasmid are not. Wild-type cells transformed with Dna2E
grow normally (data not shown). In order to establish that the mutant
Dna2E protein could not support growth when it was the only form of
Dna2p in the cell, the DNA2/dna2
strain, used
previously to demonstrate that DNA2 was essential(2) , was
transformed with both wild-type pJDgal:DNA2K and mutant pJDgal:DNA2E
plasmids. The transformants were sporulated and tetrads analyzed.
Transformants carrying pJDgal:DNA2K gave four viable spores in all
tetrads, while pJDgal:DNA2E failed to complement dna2
spores, giving rise to 2 viable and 2 inviable spores in each
tetrad. Interestingly, the dna2
strain transformed with
pJDgal:DNA2K grew on glucose as well as on the inducing carbon source
galactose. In contrast, the pJDgal:DNA2K plasmid complemented
dna2-1
strains only after induction on galactose (Fig. 1). This suggests that when expression of the wild-type
Dna2 protein is low, the dna2-1
protein may
exhibit a dominant negative effect, perhaps by forming inactive
heteroallelic oligomers containing a mixture of wild-type and mutant
protein. Since the dna2-1
mutation is recessive
in a heterozygous diploid and since pJDgal:DNA2K complements the dna2-1
strain when grown with galactose, raising
the level of wild-type Dna2 protein eliminates the possible dominant
negative effect of dna2-1
protein.
Figure 1:
Lack of complementation of dna2-1 by the Dna2E mutant protein. 3X154 9A dna2-1 ura3 was transformed with the plasmids expressing the wild-type (DNA2K) and ATPase mutant (DNA2E) genes, pJDgal:DNA2K
or pJDgal:DNA2E. Ura transformants were selected at 23
°C. Both plasmids yielded viable transformants at 23 °C.
Colonies carrying the indicated plasmids were then restreaked and
incubated at 37 °C in the presence of
galactose.
The Dna2E
mutant was then used to verify that the Dna2 protein had helicase
activity. Both the wild-type (HA-Dna2K) and the mutant proteins
(HA-Dna2E) were expressed in yeast as hemagglutinin epitope fusion
proteins under the control of the inducible GAL10 promoter.
Dna2p was partially purified, immunoprecipitated with the hemagglutinin
monoclonal antibody 12CA5 from the 0.2 M hydroxyapatite
eluant, and assayed for DNA-dependent ATPase activity (Fig. 2).
The HA-Dna2K protein converted ATP to ADP and P, and the
activity was dependent on the addition of DNA, as expected for a DNA
helicase. The mutant HA-Dna2E protein, however, exhibited no ATPase
activity. Similar amounts of the respective HA-tagged Dna2 proteins
were shown to be present in both immunoprecipitates, verifying that the
mutant protein was expressed at levels equivalent to wild-type protein (Fig. 2). Thus, the Dna2p is a DNA-dependent ATPase.
Figure 2:
Mutation of the conserved ATP-binding site
eliminates the DNA-dependent ATPase activity of Dna2p. Protein (0.2 mg
of the 0.2 M hydroxyapatite wash prepared as described under
``Materials and Methods'') was mixed with 20 µg of 12CA5
monoclonal antibody for 1 h at 0 °C. Twenty microliters of 10%
protein A beads was added followed by a 1-h incubation at 0 °C.
Beads were washed eight times with TBS/0.1% Tween, 2 times with 2
assay buffer, resuspended in 20 µl of 2
assay
buffer, and used for Western blot analysis after boiling beads in SDS
or directly for ATPase assays. Left, the Western blot shows
the wild-type (labeled K) and the mutant (labeled E)
proteins in extracts and in the immunoprecipitates used for ATPase
assays, as indicated. Right, ATPase assays of wild-type and
mutant protein were carried out as described under ``Materials and
Methods'' in the presence and absence of DNA, as indicated. First 6 lanes, wild-type protein; last 6 lanes,
mutant protein. About 55 and 100% of the ATP was converted to ADP after
18 and 54 min, respectively, in the presence of DNA by the wild-type
protein. No ATPase is observed when extracts of cells carrying the
pGAL18 vector alone are carried through the same purification
procedure. The spot at the origin (lower spot) corresponds to ATP, and
the spot that moves corresponds to ADP.
Both wild-type and mutant protein were purified further and assayed for DNA helicase activity (Fig. 3). We had previously shown that a 3` to 5` DNA helicase specific for the forked substrate shown in Fig. 3copurified from yeast with HA-Dna2p through all steps. Despite many attempts, however, we were not able to completely remove contaminating proteins, preventing us from determining whether the helicase was intrinsic to or merely associated with the HA-Dna2p(2) . As shown in Fig. 3, DNA helicase activity is observed with purified wild-type HA-Dna2K protein (Fig. 3, lane 2) but not with the mutant HA-Dna2E protein (Fig. 3, lane 3). Thus, DNA helicase activity is intrinsic to the Dna2 protein. (Interestingly, a structure-specific nuclease activity, which preferentially degrades a substrate with the configuration shown in Fig. 3(2) , is also present in these highly purified preparations (see below). The nuclease is not affected by the lysine to glutamate mutation, as expected, since ATP is not required for nuclease activity (2) .)
Figure 3: Mutation of the conserved ATP-binding site eliminates the DNA helicase activity of Dna2p. The wild-type and mutant proteins eluted from hydroxyapatite were purified further by immunoaffinity chromatography (see ``Materials and Methods'' and (2) ). Purified protein (10 ng) was assayed for DNA helicase activity. Lane B, boiled substrate; lane K, wild-type protein; lane E, ATP site mutant. The 38 mer is the product of the helicase unwinding reaction. The most rapidly moving bands in lanes 2 and 3 are 14-16 mers and are due to a structure-specific nuclease activity that copurifies with the helicase. As shown previously, the nuclease does not require ATP hydrolysis and is, therefore, not affected by the mutation. Thus it is either encoded by another gene or resides in a separate domain of DNA2 (see text). The forked molecule shown on the right is the only substrate configuration on which the helicase found in Dna2 preparations is active(2) . Neither helicase nor nuclease is observed when extracts of cells carrying the pGAL18 vector alone are carried through the same purification procedure.
The
complementation of the ts mutant and the deletion mutant taken
together demonstrate that the DNA-dependent ATPase and helicase
activity of Dna2p is required for its essential role in DNA
replication. It was therefore of interest to ask whether the dna2-1 mutation affected the helicase domain. The
site of the dna2-1
mutation was mapped using a
marker rescue technique we previously used to locate
temperature-sensitive mutations of the POL1 gene, encoding DNA
polymerase
(Fig. 4)(7) . DNA sequencing (see Fig. 4) revealed a single amino acid change of proline 504 to
serine (CCT to TCT), placing the dna2-1
mutation
in the N-terminal portion of the protein, far from the essential
helicase domain (amino acids 1070-1522). Thus, the Dna2p appears
to be composed of at least two domains, both required in vivo.
Nevertheless, intraallelic complementation of the GAL10-expressed ATPase mutant protein in the dna2-1
strain did not occur (Fig. 1),
suggesting that the functional domains of the Dna2 protein cannot act
in trans in vivo.
Figure 4:
Mapping of the dna2-1 mutation by
marker rescue and DNA sequencing. Six different fragments spanning the DNA2 gene were cloned into pRS424 to give the respective
plasmids: pRS1, 1.1-kb SacI-SnaB1 fragment of the dna2-1 gene; pRS2, 1.4-kb SacII fragment; pRS3,
1.34-kb NstI fragment; pRS4, 1.14-kb BstB1-PvuII fragment; pRS5, 1.1-kb BglII
fragment; pRS6, 0.4-kb BglII-EcoRI fragment. These
plasmids were used to transform dna2-1 Transformants were selected by growth on uracil-deficient plates
and replica plated, and the replicas were placed at 37 °C. The
appearance of papillation after 2 days indicated recombination and
hence marker rescue. The SnaBI-SacII region of the dna2-1
gene was amplified by PCR and cloned. Six
different clones were prepared from six different PCR reactions to
avoid being misled by mutations that might occur during PCR
amplification. DNA sequencing revealed that each had not one, but two,
base changes. One mutation changed proline 504 into serine (CCT to TCT)
and is likely the dna2-1 mutation, since the second base
change is silent, leaving amino acid 426 as serine (AGC to AGT). The
figure shows a diagram of the segments used to both functionally
(marker rescue) and physically map the mutation. + indicates
papillation after 2 days and constitutes marker rescue; -
indicates lack of papillation. The mutation causing the ts phenotype falls between the SnaBI site and the SacII site.
Both sequence conservation and deletion
analysis also support an important role for the N-terminal domain.
Dna2p is similar over its entire length to the human ha3631 gene
product, an open reading frame derived from DNA sequence (accession no.
D42046), having 34% overall amino acid sequence identity and 55%
similarity to Dna2p(2) . The proline changed by the dna2-1 mutation is conserved between the Dna2
protein and the ha3631 open reading frame and falls in an N-terminal
20-amino acid stretch that is 55% identical and 98% similar to the
human ha3631 gene product. Such strong conservation suggests that the
proline and surrounding motif are functionally important. Preparation
of a series of deletions into the Dna2 protein was described
previously(2) . Deletion of only 25 amino acids at the C
terminus results in a protein unable to complement the dna2-1
mutation. Deletion of 105 amino acids from
the N terminus leads to a protein that can complement both the dna2-1
mutation and a dna2
strain
and that is active as a helicase(2) . However, deletion of an
additional 25 amino acids inactivates the protein.
What is the role
of the N terminus? The sequence does not contain motifs characteristic
of any class of protein with known function. It may be essential for
helicase activity. Alternatively, it may not contribute directly to the
catalytic activity of the helicase but may rather serve as a site of
protein/protein interactions. If Dna2 protein is oligomeric, as many
helicases are, then association of monomers might be destabilized in
the dna2-1 protein. The partial dominant negative
effect described above may suggest an oligomeric structure, in analogy
with phage T7 gene 4 mutants(8) .
It is also possible that
the N-terminal domain is required for interaction with other
replication proteins. Preliminary evidence suggests that Dna2 protein
interacts with the product of another yeast replication gene, the YKL510/RAD27 gene, a homolog of human FEN1
endonuclease, which is involved in processing of Okazaki pieces in the
SV40 in vitro replication system (9, 10, 11) . The YKL510/Rad27 nuclease
copurifies with Dna2 helicase through all purification steps (Fig. 3). ()Furthermore, a plasmid that overexpresses
the YKL510 (RAD27) gene suppresses the dna2-1
mutation but not dna2
.
Such high copy
suppression is considered genetic evidence for interaction of the
corresponding gene products in vivo. A deletion of the RAD27 gene results in a strain with temperature-sensitive
growth(10, 12) .
Thus, the
temperature-sensitive phenotype of the dna2-1
strain may result from an inability of the mutant protein to
interact with RAD27 or an additional nuclease involved in
Okazaki fragment processing. Even if the latter hypothesis is correct,
it is likely that additional factors contribute to the
temperature-sensitive phenotype of the dna2-1
mutation, since dna2-1
strains exhibit less
DNA synthesis at 37 °C than rad27
strains(2, 10) .
At this stage of characterization of Dna2p, it is hard to predict its precise mechanistic role in DNA replication. The 3` to 5` directionality might suggest that unwinding at a chromosomal fork may be coordinated with polymerization of the leading strand. Given the complexity of the eukaryotic replication fork, the requirement for a 3` to 5` helicase does not exclude a role for additional helicases in yeast chromosomal DNA replication, including at least one that, like the prokaryotic primosomal helicases, has a 5` to 3` polarity.