Affiliation to mature B cell repertoire and positive selection can be separated in two distinct processes
Soulef Hachemi-Rachedi1,
Anne-Marie Drapier1,
Pierre-André Cazenave1 and
Pierre Sanchez1,2
1 Immunochimie Analytique, Institut Pasteur and
2 Immunobiologie, Université Denis Diderot, 75251 Paris, France
Correspondence to:
P. Sanchez, Laboratoire d'Immunobiologie Case 7048, Université Denis Diderot (PARIS VII), 2 Place Jussieu, 75251 Paris Cedex 05, France
 |
Abstract
|
---|
Using an `oligoclonal' model, we have previously shown that mice transgenic for a µ chain (H3) and deficient for
chain expression display a mature B cell repertoire largely dominated by the H3/
1 pair, while the four H3/
available combinations can be observed in the immature B cell compartment. This led us to propose the existence of a positive selection process. To test this hypothesis, we have introduced the SJL
locus coding for a defective
1 chain (
1s) that creates a dysfunctional Ig receptor complex during B cell differentiation. Our results show that the
1s defect impairs the development of mature B cells when the H3-µ transgene insert is present in the hemizygous state. This suggests that the Gly
Val substitution present in the C
1s chain at position 155 is sufficient to abrogate the selection of the H3/
1 pair. Unexpectedly, when the H3-µ transgene array is present in a homozygous state in
1s mice but not in `wild-type'
1 mice (
1+), a significant number of mature B cells expressing all H3/
combinations can be developed. These results indicate that the overriding H3/
1 dominance observed in
1+ mice is due to a positive selection process and not to a negative selection of other H3/
combinations. They also show that the export of B cells to the periphery can be controlled by the expression of the µ chain.
Keywords: B lymphocytes, cellular differentiation, repertoire development, transgenic/knockout
 |
Introduction
|
---|
During B cell development, multiple Ig V(D)J gene segments are rearranged, and H and L chains are assembled consecutively to be expressed on the surface of B cells. The emergent B cell repertoire therefore displays a large diversity. However, certain H/L chain combinations can be disadvantaged due to incompatible pairing with each other or with different molecules responsible for folding, transport to the cell surface and signaling of the B cell receptor (BCR). For example, the expression of some VH genes is prevented by counter-selection due to the inability of encoded µ chains to form a pre-BCR with the surrogate light chain (13). Moreover, some B cells with nascent autoreactive BCR can be eliminated by negative selection or change their specificity by receptor editing (49). In addition, positive selection has been postulated to favor the entrance of certain newly formed B cells in the long-lived B cell pool (1013). Competition between cells can also act synergistically with the positive selection processes (1416). However, the ligands responsible for such positive selection are unknown and the real existence of these ligands is questioned by self-signaling BCR aggregation models (1720).
Studies on the formation of the B cell repertoire are limited by the huge diversity of generated BCR. To overcome this inconvenience, transgenic mice displaying an `oligoclonal' B cell repertoire have been developed (2123). Using such an experimental model, we have previously described a strong modification of the repertoire between emergent immature and peripheral mature B cell pools (22). More precisely, in the spleen of H3-µ transgenic mice (H3-Tg) crossed with
knockout mice (
/), B cells always express an H3-µ chain paired with a
1 chain, whereas newly formed immature B cells can expressed the transgenic heavy chain with one or another of the four available
subtypes [
1,
2(V2),
2(Vx) and
3] (24). We have postulated that a positive selection process is responsible for the H3/
1 dominance. However, we cannot exclude that the H3/
1 dominance is due to the negative selection of other combinations (i.e. H3/
2 or
3). To test this hypothesis, we have introduced the SJL
locus into the H3-Tg,
knockout mouse genome. This locus encodes a
1 chain (
1s) that causes a dysfunction of the
1-containing Ig receptor during B cell differentiation (2527). Our results show that (i) the nature of the light chain [i.e.
1s versus wild-type
1 (
1+)] determines whether or not the positive selection of H3/
1 B cells occurs in the periphery, (ii) the level of µ transgene expression controls the capacity of B cell replenishment in the periphery, (iii) the peripheral B cell repertoire comprises an abundant H3/
2 +
3 B cell population only in the absence of positive selection of H3/
1 B cells. Our results therefore demonstrate a versatile B cell positive selection independent of the B cell differentiation program. We propose a model in which the formation of the mature B cell repertoire is determined by positive selection, which is dispensable in `oligoclonal' mice when the B cell differentiation is effective and no H/L combination is available to be positively selected.
 |
Methods
|
---|
Animals and screening
Mice (820 weeks old) were housed in the animal facilities at the Institut Pasteur, Paris. Mice homozygous for the C
mutation were produced by mating of chimeras derived from 129/Sv ES cells with C57BL/6 (
1+/+ genotype) (24). Subsequently, the
1s locus was introduced by mating with the SJL strain (
1s/s genotype). The screening of
1+ versus
1s mice was done by Southern blot analysis using the presence or the absence of a KpnI restriction site in the C
1 segment (26,27). H3-Tg C57BL/6 mice were obtained by Honjo's group (28). The association of the H3-Tg chain with the L3 transgenic chain (a
light chain) displays an activity against mouse erythrocytes. However, mice expressing the H3-Tg µ chain only do not develop anemia (28). The H3 transgene was first introduced by crossing H3-Tg C57BL/6 mice with
1+/+
/ mice and second by crossing H3-Tg
1+/+
/ mice with
1s/s
/ mice. The presence of the H3 transgene can be detected by FACS analysis to discriminate between the transgenic µa and endogenous µb chains or by Southern blot analysis using an XbaIHindIII Cµ probe (29).
Antibodies and flow cytometry analyses
Cells were stained with the indicated mAb labeled with FITC (Sigma, St Louis, MO) or biotin (Boehringer Mannheim, Mannheim, Germany). Streptavidin coupled to phycoerythrin was obtained from Southern Biotechnology Associates (Birmingham, AL). Anti-CD24 was a gift from Dr A. Freitas. Anti-CD23 (B3B4) and anti-CD21 (7G6) were purchased from PharMingen (San Diego, CA). µ,
1 and
2 +
3 cells were defined by labeling with biotinylated goat anti-mouse IgM (Sigma), AF6-78, DS-1 (PharMingen), MS40-13 (30), 189B3 (31) antibodies and with FITC-labeled anti-CD45R/B220 (RA3-6B2) mAb (32). Analyses were done on a FACScan (Becton Dickinson) or on an Epics Elite-ESP flow cytometer (Coultronics, Margency, France).
In vitro B cell differentiation
Confluent S17 stromal cells in 24-well plates were
-irradiated at 2000 rad (33,34). Bone marrow cells (5x105) were then cultured in 1.5 ml in regular medium in the presence of 50150 U rIL-7 in each well. After 4 days, cells were transferred to a new confluent S17 layer and grown in the absence of rIL-7 for 3 days. Cells were then cultured again under the same conditions for 34 days and subsequently analyzed by FACS.
Spleen B cells (3x106) were cultured in 1.5 ml in regular medium in the presence of lipopolysaccharide (LPS) (25 µg/ml) (L-2880; Sigma) over 9 days. Subsequently, supernatants were tested by ELISA using a sandwich test in which goat anti-mouse IgM were coated and endogenous or transgenic secreted IgM are revealed by specific biotinylated anti-allotype DS-1 or AF6-78. Finally, streptavidin coupled to horseradish peroxidase (Southern Biotechnology Associates) was used for the last step.
 |
Results
|
---|
The
1s defect leads to a decrease in B cell development in
/ mice
Among the four
chains encoded by the
locus [i.e.
1,
2(V2),
2(Vx) and
3],
1 is over-expressed in normal and
knockout mice (35). This dominant expression (~5065%) is detectable in central and peripheral lymphoid tissues, except in the peritoneal cavity. We have shown that the preferential usage of
1 chains results from a higher frequency of V1J1 rearrangements (36). In contrast, in
/ mice with the SJL
locus,
1-expressing cells represent only 515% of cells in the periphery(27) (Fig. 1
). The decrease in the
1 subpopulation can be first observed among immature B cells (B220loIgM+), in the bone marrow. The
1s phenotype probably results solely from a Gly
Val substitution in the
1 constant region. Indeed, no other difference in the coding or regulatory sequences is found between SJL
1 (
1s) and the common
1 (
1+) locus and the higher frequency of V1J1 rearrangements is unchanged in
1s mice (27) (unpublished data). It has been proposed that the Gly
Val substitution creates an Ig receptor complex which is dysfunctional during B cell differentiation (27). This could be due to an impairment in BCR signaling, although the precise mechanism responsible for this defect remains elusive. As can be seen on Fig. 1
, the percentages of
1 cells, in
1s/s
knockout mice, decrease as B cells progress from the bone marrow to the spleen, suggesting a selection against
1 cells in the periphery. This result therefore reinforces the idea of an inefficient survival signaling via the
1s BCR. Moreover in in vitro culture conditions which allow the development of immature B cells only (22,37), the percentage of
1 cells (near to 30%) is highest, although it remains 2-fold lower than in the
1+/+ mice (Fig. 1
).
As 5060% of immature B cells are of the
1 subtype in
1+/+ mice, the fact that there are 30%
1 immature cells in
1s/s mice should lead to a decrease in the number of newly formed B cells in the bone marrow in the absence of compensatory phenomena. To examine the efficiency of B cell development, we compared the ratio of IgM+B220lo/ total B220lo cells in ex vivo and in vitro different B cell differentiation conditions. As shown in Fig. 2
, B cell development is impaired in
1s/s mice. Indeed, in ex vivo and in vitro conditions, the ratio passes from 9.8 and 16.8% in
1+/+ mice to 4.4 and 8.5% in the
1s/s mice respectively. However, the percentage of spleen B cells is similar in both mice, indicating a peripheral compensation for the defect in B cell lymphopoiesis by amplification of the
2 +
3 B cell compartment (see discussion).
The
1s defect predominates over processes responsible for the H3/
1 selection
Using H3-µ transgenic mice obtained by Honjo's group (28), we have previously shown that H3-µ transgenic mice deficient for
chains (H3-Tg
/ mice) express a quasi-monoclonal repertoire since ~8090% of mature B cells express H3-µ in association with the
1 chain (22). In the immature B cell pool, however, all H3/
combinations are normally expressed. This led us to suggest that the H3/
1 combination is positively selected over other H3/
combinations by unknown ligand(s) during the immature to mature B cell transition. Introduction of the
s locus in H3-Tg
/ mice allowed us to test the influence of
1s defect on this selective process. We therefore analyzed spleen B cells and estimated the proportion of
1 cells among the µ+ B cells. As expected,
/
1s/s and H3-Tg
/
1+/+ mice display very low (<15%) and very high (>75%) percentages of the
1 cells respectively (Fig. 3
), compared to ~55% of
/
1+/+ mice (see Fig. 1
). In contrast, H3-Tg
/
1s/s mice show a drastic decrease not only in
1 but also in total B cells (Fig. 3
). These results indicate that (i) the
1s defect prevents the H3/
1 combination selection, (ii) there is no compensation with H3/
2 or H3/
3 combinations and (iii) the
1s defect leads to a quasi-absence of B cells in H3-Tg
/
1s/s mice. We conclude that the
1s defect is dominant over the selection of the H3/
1 combination, most probably because the
1s Ig receptor displays a deficient signaling function.
The H3/
1 combination dominance is most probably due to positive rather than negative selection
As H3-Tg
/
1s/s mice have few spleen B cells, it is necessary to verify whether B lymphopoiesis is efficient and whether newly formed B cells can express all
chains. Spleen and bone marrow cells were therefore analyzed with anti-
1 and anti-
2 +
3 antibodies in conjunction with anti-B220 antibodies (Fig. 4
, left in top). As already noted, these mice have very few spleen B cells (<5%). These cells express the different
subtypes and many of them express endogenous µ chains as observed using anti-µ allotype antibodies (see Fig. 6
). In contrast, immature B cells are present in the bone marrow and all express the µ transgenic gene (not shown). Moreover, all
subtypes are expressed in the immature B cell compartment and no mature B cells in the bone marrow are detected. This suggests a decreased recruitment of B cells in the periphery rather than a blockade in early B cell maturation steps.
Unexpectedly, during the breeding of H3-Tg
/
1s/s mice, we observed two phenotypes with respect to the number of spleen B cells. The first phenotype corresponds to that described above, i.e. very few spleen B cells, and the second one displays a significant number of spleen B cells (Fig. 4
, top right). These two phenotypes are directly correlated with the number of H3-µ transgenic array copies as quantified by Southern blot analysis (Fig. 5
). The results show that mice can receive one or two copies of inserts as suggested by calculated transgene/endogene ratios. Thus, the
1s/s mice with transgenic inserts to a hemizygous state (H3-Tg+/) display very few B cells, whereas the mice with transgenic inserts to a homozygous state (H3-Tg+/+) have a significant percentage of splenic B cells (Fig. 4
, top). Nearly all B cells of H3-Tg+/+
/
1s/s mice express the transgenic heavy chain contrary to H3-Tg+/
/
1s/s mice (Fig. 6
). Interestingly, the H3-Tg+/+ state (MFI = 5.45) favors a significantly higher expression of the transgenic chain on the cell surface than in H3-Tg+/ mice (MFI = 4.21) (Fig. 6
). Unexpectedly, a large number of H3-Tg+/+
/
1s/s spleen B cells expresses the
1 chain (~40%). Finally, the percentage of
1 in the spleen reflects the percentage of immature B cells (IgM+B220lo) in the bone marrow, indicating that there is no positive selection of the H3/
1 combination in the periphery. It is worthy to note that ~60% of B cells express H3-µ in association with
2 or
3 chains, demonstrating that their quasi-absence in H3-Tg mice with the
1+ locus does not arise from a negative selection (see Fig. 4
, bottom). These results show that the number of copies of the µ transgenic array plays an important role in B cell development in the
1s mice but does not restore the positive selection process of the H3/
1 combination. To control the mature status of peripheral B cells, we compared the expression of maturation markers in transgenic and non-transgenic
1s mice. As shown in Fig. 7
(A), non-transgenic and H3-Tg+/+
1s mice display similar patterns of CD24, CD23 and CD21 expression, whereas H3-Tg+/
1s mice show a more immature profile for CD23 and CD21. These results are in accordance with LPS proliferation assay (Fig. 7B
), which shows that transgenic IgM are secreted after LPS stimulation in H3-Tg+/+
1s mice. Moreover, both
1 and
2 + 3 cells can be stimulated in these mice (data not shown).

View larger version (36K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Fig. 5. Quantification of H3-µ transgene inserts. Tail DNA was digested by BamHI and membranes were hybridized with a Cµ probe. The ratios between c and d bands were calculated after scanning of membranes with a PhosphorImager (Molecular Dynamics, Bondoufle, France), and the hemi- versus homozygous state of H3-Tg inserts deduced from them are indicated.
|
|
As double copies of the H3 transgene array lead to an increase in H3/
2 and H3/
3 positive cells in
1s mice, it was important to study the same H3 genotype in
1+ mice. As illustrated in Fig. 4
(bottom), no significant difference can be detected between mice with one or two H3 transgene copies since ~60% of H3/
1 immature cells in the bone marrow and 8590% of H3/
1 mature B cells in the spleen were found in both mice. Taken together these results demonstrate that (i) the conditions of H3 transgene expression play a role in the export of newly formed B cells to the periphery, (ii) the H3/
2 and/or H3/
3 combinations in H3-Tg
1+ mice are not eliminated by negative selection due to autoreactive specificities, and (iii) the
1s defect inhibits the positive selection process of the H3/
1 combination.
The µ transgenic chain increases B cell lymphopoiesis but does not restore completely the peripheral B cell pool in
1s mice
As shown in Fig. 4
(top), B cell development seems normal in H3-Tg+/+
1s mice, whereas it is compromised in H3-Tg+/
1s ones. On the other hand, we also showed that the
1s defect leads to a decrease of B cell lymphopoiesis in non-transgenic
1s mice (Fig. 2
). We therefore assessed the influence of µ transgenic chain expression both on the generation of newly formed B cells in the bone marrow and on the capacity of these cells to migrate to the periphery. The data are summarized in Table 1
in which we compare µ transgenic
1s or
1+ mice with non-transgenic
1s mice. As shown, both Tg+/ and Tg+/+
1s mice have a significantly lower percentage of spleen B cells than non-transgenic
1s mice (7.7 and 20 versus 36% respectively). The behavior of Tg+/ and Tg+/+
1+ mice is similar to the non-transgenic
1s mice (33 and 43 versus 36%) although Tg+/
1+ mice recurrently display a lower B cell percentage than Tg+/+
1+ mice. The results are identical if we analyze the total number of B cells per spleen (data not shown). Therefore, this result shows that the homozygous state of the transgene array favors the filling of the peripheral B cell compartment in H3-Tg
1s mice. However, this filling remains lower than in the non-transgenic
1s animals.
To analyze the influence of the µ transgenes on B lymphopoiesis, we estimated the ratio of immature B cells (IgM+B220lo) to total B220lo cells. As shown in Table 1
, both Tg/ and Tg+/
1s mice display a similar B cell lymphopoiesis. Their ratios are significantly lower than in Tg+/+
1s mice, indicating that the homozygous state of the transgene enhances the production of newly formed B cells, which is similar to that found in H3-Tg
1+ mice (Table 1
) and non-transgenic
1+ mice (not shown). Altogether, these data clearly show that µ transgene expression is able to modulate B cell development in the
1s mice in two ways. The first should determine the rate of immature B cells produced in the bone marrow. The second should determine the ability of new B cells to colonize the periphery. However, even if B cell lymphopoiesis is restored, it is not sufficient to have a complete mature B cell repertoire in H3-Tg+/+
1s mice.
 |
Discussion
|
---|
The molecular and cellular mechanisms controlling the transition from newly formed B cells in the bone marrow to the mature B cell pool in the periphery are still largely unknown (38,39). Using H3-µ transgenic
/ mice with the
1s defect, we bring some insights into the generation of immature B cells and the requirements for the establishment of a mature B cell repertoire. Two developmental steps can be distinguished in our model. The first is characterized by an absence of clonal selection and depends on mechanistic constraints. The second is based on selective processes that ensure the persistence of B cells in the periphery. We will discuss these two aspects sequentially.
The H3-Tg µ chain favors B cell lymphopoiesis, restores the
1/
2 +
3 ratio and controls the export of newly formed B cells in
1s mice
Non-µ transgenic
1s
/ mice display a lower rate of immature B cell production than
1+
/ mice (Fig. 2
and Table 1
). This observation can be interpreted as a consequence of the decrease in the
1 B cell number that can be produced in bone marrow (27) (Fig. 1
). Indeed, we have previously reported that the dominant
1 cell expression in
1+
/ mice (~60%) results from a higher probability to rearrange
1 over other
subloci (36). Thus, numerous cells could have productively rearranged
1s but because of the defective
1s chain, these cells die in situ before they express their surface Ig, and they consequently prevent, by competition, a compensatory development of bone marrow
2 +
3 cells. Moreover, these cells cannot be rescued by secondary rearrangements in the
locus since V
1sJ
1s rearrangements in spleen
2 +
3 cells are all in a non-productive configuration, as already shown for the
1+ mice (data not shown). The defect of
1s chain is likely due to a Gly
Val substitution at position 155 since no other difference has been described between the
1+ and
1s loci (27,40). This substitution could act on the function of the Ig receptor, although we cannot exclude a ineffective association of the
1s chain with chaperones before its pairing with the µ chain (41), even if the defect can be modulated by the H3-Tg chain. However, in
1s mice, the µ transgenic chain effect on bone marrow B cell development is complex (see Fig. 4
): (i) in the bone marrow, the presence of the H3 chain seems to restore the
1/
2 +
3 ratio to ~47%, regardless of the H3-Tg genotype, (ii) when the H3-Tg inserts are in double copies, B cell lymphopoiesis in
1s mice increases, regardless of the
subtype expressed, and (iii) the H3-Tg genotype in
1+ mice has no effect on either the
1/
2 +
3 ratio or B cell lymphopoiesis.
We propose the following hypotheses to explain these multiple effects of the H3-µ transgene. The expression of the µ transgenic chain is different from that of µ endogenous chain and favors the folding, the transport to the cell surface and/or the signaling of Ig
1s receptors. This enables immature B cells to have a
1/
2 +
3 ratio near 50%. However, when the transgene inserts are present in one copy only, the condition of transgenic µ expression is not sufficient to obtain a normal B cell lymphopoiesis. This would probably be due to the subsequent death of
1s cells because of a deficiency in Ig
1s signaling, even if these cells pursued their development until they express the Ig
1s on their surface. A defect in B cell lymphopoiesis would therefore be one of the causes of the quasi-absence of peripheral B cells in H3-Tg+/
1s mice. In contrast, when the transgene inserts are present in double copies, the condition of transgenic µ expression overrides the
1s chain defect in B cell lymphopoiesis. This leads to two phenomena: (i) normal B cell lymphopoiesis for both
1 and
2 +
3 cells, and (ii) an increased ability of these cells to be exported to the periphery. The fact that the suppression of the
1s defect indirectly causes the production of
2 +
3 cells can be explained by the hypothesis that, now, the newly formed
1s cells, instead of dying in situ, leave the bone marrow allowing `free space' in which
2 +
3 cell development is possible.
More unexpected is the peripheral colonization by the newly formed cells when the transgenes are in double copies. To our knowledge, such a fine regulation is only reported by two very recent publications (42,43). Indeed, a slight but significant differential surface expression of transgenic µa chain can be observed between H3-Tg+/+ and H3-Tg+/
1s mice (see Fig. 6
). Moreover, we also found a more pronounced differential expression of intracellular µ chain and surface Ig density between H3-Tg+/+ and H3-Tg+/
1+ mice (not shown). Watanabe et al. reported a similar result in H3-Tg
+/+ mice (42). A possible hypothesis to explain the colonization would be better survival signaling via Ig receptors in H3-Tg+/+
1s mice. An alternative but not opposite hypothesis could be that, as
1s mice display a diminished B cell lymphopoiesis, the average time of recombination processes increases, favoring a deletion of an H3 transgene array on the basis of recently reported data (44). In this case, cells with two copies of H3 transgenes should have an advantage to express an H3-Tg Ig receptor.
It is remarkable to note that colonization occurs for both
1s and
2 +
3 cells. Such a situation is not found in the H3-Tg
1+ mice in which
1 cells largely dominate
2 +
3 cells. As we propose below, the difference between
1s and
1+ mice must arise from a lack of positive selection in the
1s mice. However,
1 and
2 +
3 cells in the H3-Tg+/+
1s mice seem immunocompetent as tested by the presence of maturation markers or by in vitro LPS stimulation (Fig. 7
), suggesting that positive selection is dispensable for bone marrow immature B cells to be exported to the periphery. Our results are in agreement with two very recent reports (42,43). Both papers favor the idea that BCR surface density positively regulates B-1 cell compartment. Our results extend their observations to B-2 cell compartment since our H3-Tg
1s mice display a splenic B-2 phenotype as tested by the absence of CD5 marker (data not shown).
The
1s defect reveals that the dominance of the H3/
1 combination results from a positive selection process in H3-Tg
1+ mice
Taken together, our analyses of the peripheral B cell repertoire can be divided into four phenotypes depending on two criteria: B cell number and the
1/
2 +
3 ratio. For each phenotype, we attempted to separate the parameters conditioning the establishment of a mature B cell repertoire, i.e. formation of immature B cells and recruitment to the periphery, on one hand, and a clonal positive selection, on the other hand, as illustrated in our model (Fig. 8
).
The first phenotype can be seen in both H3-Tg+/ and H3-Tg+/+
1+ `oligoclonal' mice (Fig. 8D
). It is characterized by an almost normal number of spleen B cells and
1 dominance although the number of spleen B cells of Tg+/
1+ is often smaller than that of the Tg+/+
1+ mice. These results confirm our previous data which have been interpreted as positive selection of the H3/
1 combination (22). Indeed, these two mouse strains have normal B cell lymphopoiesis and ~60% of
1 cells are present in the immature B cell pool as found in non-transgenic
1+ mice (Fig. 1
). These results demonstrate that selection takes place at the transition between newly formed immature and mature B cells and the conditions of µ transgene expression (H3-Tg+/+ versus H3-Tg+/) have no effect on this selection. Moreover, since H3/
2 and/or H3/
3 cells can be found in the periphery of H3-Tg+/+
1s mice, the quasi-absence of these cells in H3-Tg
1+ mice does not result from negative selection by clonal deletion. This fact therefore shows that the H3/
1 dominance is due to a clonal positive selection process.
The second phenotype is represented by H3-Tg+/
1s/s mice which have very few B cells in the periphery and a dominance of
2 +
3 cells (Fig. 8B
). Numerous peripheral B cells express an endogenous µ chain suggesting that no H3/
combination is positively recruited (Fig. 6
). These results fit very well with our hypothesis of a positive selection of the H3/
1 combination. Indeed, bone marrow immature cells are not recruited to the periphery, the
1 B cells because of the
1s defect and the
2 +
3 cells due to the lack of positive selection of H3/
2 or H3/
3 combinations as observed in H3-Tg+
1+ mice.
The third and unexpected phenotype arises from H3-Tg+/+
1s/s mice which display numerous mature spleen B cells and a
1/
2 +
3 ratio near to 1 (Fig. 8C
). As we have already mentioned, the presence of the H3 inserts to the homozygous state, enhances B cell lymphopoiesis, probably by compensation of the
1s defect. This better lymphopoiesis could favor, by itself, the recruitment of immature B cells to the periphery. However, non-transgenic
1s mice with a defective B lymphopoiesis display a normal mature B cell repertoire suggesting that other elements control the recruitment. The simplest hypothesis is to imagine that the modification of H3 expression has two effects, an increase in immature B cell number and an increase in Ig signaling, both of which permit the export of the cells to the periphery. However, it does not reach the normal size as shown in Table 1
. Moreover, B cell recruitment does not favor the H3/
1 combination, since H3/
2 + H3/
3 expressing cells represent nearly half the B cells. These results therefore suggest that the H3-Tg+/+ genotype can suppress the
1s defect, with respect to production of
1s cells and their peripheral export, but remains ineffective for the suppression of the
1s defect, with respect to clonal positive selection. It is tempting to propose that there are two processes for peripheral recruitment. The first depends on efficient signaling via the Ig receptor and can be observed without positive selection. In this case, this process should allow the export of not only
1s cells but also
2 +
3 cells. This process could result from survival BCR signaling in a ligand-independent way, but it would not be sufficient to have a complete mature B cell repertoire due to lack of positive selection. The second process leads to clonal positive selection, which is probably ligand dependent. In this case, the mature repertoire tends to reach its normal size as seen in H3-Tg
1+ mice even if the lymphopoiesis is diminished as proposed below for the
1s mice.
The fourth phenotype corresponds to non-transgenic
1s mice which have a normal number of spleen B cells and a large
2 +
3 dominance (Fig. 8A
). These mice display a deficient B cell lymphopoiesis due to their
1s defect (Table 1
) but a normal mature repertoire size. This phenotype reflects a powerful compensation process due to selection of
2 +
3 clones. We propose, here, that this compensation is possible because numerous newly formed
2 +
3 cells can be positively selected in a ligand-dependent way and that this positive selection allows a normal size B cell repertoire in the periphery.
Numerous models of transgenic mice have been used to explore the establishment of the B cell repertoire. The concept of negative selection has largely been supported by the finding of B cell development arrest in `monoclonal' transgenic mice in the presence of self antigen (12). The concept of positive selection has been supported, indirectly, in a certain number of different transgenic models (16,22,45,46). However, the balance between negative and positive selections remains difficult to evaluate, notably because of possible competition between cells (14,15,47). Our oligoclonal transgenic model brings new light on this balance. First, the block in B cell development in certain transgenic mice could be interpreted only by an absence of Ig signaling and not by the existence of negative selection (48,49). Thus, the comparison between H3-Tg+/+
1s and H3-Tg+/
1s is exemplary. The only difference between these two mice is the number of H3 inserts but the impact of this difference on the establishment of the B cell repertoire is drastic. This result strongly suggests that the conditions of µ chain expression determine the level of (auto?) Ig survival signaling. Secondly, the existence of a B cell subpopulation is totally dependent on the nature of the other B cells. Indeed, the H3/
2 and/or H3/
3 cells are, a priori, identical in both H3-Tg+/+
1s and H3-Tg+/+
1+ mice. However, these cells can develop in the former mice and almost disappear in the latter mice. Their presence is possible only in the absence of positive selection of H3/
1s cells. These results strongly suggest that, in physiological conditions (non-transgenic), only positively selected B cells can belong to the mature B cell repertoire.
Our understanding of the
1s phenotype remains obscure. Our results indirectly demonstrate that only the Gly
Val substitution is responsible for the
1s defect since the latter can be overcome under adequate experimental conditions (i.e. in H3-Tg+/+
1s mice). According to our hypotheses, the
1s defect has several facets. It can be corrected for B cell lymphopoiesis and for export to the periphery. However, it remains effective to inhibit the positive selection process. From a structural viewpoint, the Gly
Val substitution, which is exposed to solvent, fits with the idea that positive selection requires an interaction with an external ligand. However, the presence of few normal mature
1s cells in
1s mice remains an enigma since these cells do not differ from
1+ cells in their capacity to be stimulated or their VH-associated repertoire (our unpublished data).
 |
Acknowledgments
|
---|
We thank Drs Michelle Goodhart, Ana Cumano, Dominique Rueff-Juy and Colette Kanellopoulos-Langevin for helpful discussions. We gratefully acknowledge Ms Anne-Marie Crain and Marie-Claude Gendron for expert assistance in FACS analyses. S. H.-R. was supported by a fellowship from the `Fondation pour la Recherche Médicale'. URA CNRS 1961 and the Université Pierre et Marie Curie support The Immunochimie Analytique unit. This work is also supported by the Fondation pour la Recherche Médicale and the Association pour la Recherche sur le Cancer
 |
Abbreviations
|
---|
BCR B cell receptor |
LPS lipopolysaccharide |
 |
Notes
|
---|
Transmitting editor: J. F. Kearney
Received 12 August 1999,
accepted 24 November 1999.
 |
References
|
---|
-
ten Boekel, E., Melchers, F. and Rolink, A. G. 1997. Changes in the V(H) gene repertoire of developing precursor B lymphocytes in mouse bone marrow mediated by the pre-B cell receptor. Immunity 7:357.[ISI][Medline]
-
ten Boekel, E., Melchers, F. and Rolink, A. G. 1998. Precursor B cells showing H chain allelic inclusion display allelic exclusion at the level of pre-B cell receptor surface expression. Immunity 8:199.[ISI][Medline]
-
Wasserman, R., Li, Y. S., Shinton, S. A., Carmack, C. E., Manser, T., Wiest, D. L., Hayakawa, K. and Hardy, R. R. 1998. A novel mechanism for B cell repertoire maturation based on response by B cell precursors to pre-B receptor assembly. J. Exp. Med. 187:259.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Goodnow, C. C., Crosbie, J., Adelstein, S., Lavoie, T. B., Smith-Gill, S. J., Brink, R. A., Pritchard-Briscoe, H., Wotherspoon, J. S., Loblay, R. H., Raphael, K., Trent, R. J. and Basten, A. 1988. Altered immunoglobulin expression and functional silencing of self-reactive B lymphocytes in transgenic mice. Nature 334:676.[ISI][Medline]
-
Goodnow, C. C., Crosbie, J., Jorgensen, H., Brink, R. A. and Basten, A. 1989. Induction of self-tolerance in mature peripheral B lymphocytes. Nature 342:385.[ISI][Medline]
-
Nemazee, D. and Buerki, K. 1989. Clonal deletion of autoreactive B lymphocytes in bone marrow chimeras. Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA. 86:8039.[Abstract]
-
Nemazee, D. A. and Bürki, K. 1989. Clonal deletion of B lymphocytes in a transgenic mouse bearing anti-MHC class I antibody genes. Nature 337:562.[ISI][Medline]
-
Tiegs, S. L., Russell, D. M. and Nemazee, D. 1993. Receptor editing in self-reactive bone marrow B cells. J. Exp. Med. 177:1009.[Abstract]
-
Gay, D., Saunders, T., Camper, S. and Weigert, M. 1993. Receptor editing: an approach by autoreactive B cells to escape tolerance. J. Exp. Med. 177:999.[Abstract]
-
Gu, H., Tarlinton, D., Müller, W., Rajewsky, K. and Förster, J. 1991. Most peripheral B cells in mice are ligand selected. J. Exp. Med. 173:1357.[Abstract]
-
von Boehmer, H. 1994. Positive selection of lymphocytes. Cell 76:219.[ISI][Medline]
-
Goodnow, C. C., Cyster, J. G., Hartley, S. B., Bell, S. E., Cooke, M. P., Healy, J. I., Akkaraju, S., Rathmell, J. C., Pogue, S. L. and Shokat, K. P. 1995. Self-tolerance checkpoints in B lymphocyte development. Adv. Immunol. 59:279.[ISI][Medline]
-
Torres, R. M., Flaswinkel, H., Reth, M. and Rajewsky, K. 1996. Aberrant B cell development and immune response in mice with a compromised BCR complex. Science 272:1804.[Abstract]
-
Cyster, J. G., Hartley, S. B. and Goodnow, C. C. 1994. Competition for follicular niches excludes self-reactive cells from the recirculating B-cell repertoire. Nature 371:389.[ISI][Medline]
-
Freitas, A. A., Rosado, M. M., Viale, A.-C. and Gradien, A. 1995. The role of cellular competition in B cell survival and selection of B cell repertoires. Eur. J. Immunol. 25:1729.[ISI][Medline]
-
Chen, X., Martin, F., Forbush, K. A., Perlmutter, R. M. and Kearney, J. F. 1997. Evidence for selection of a population of multi-reactive B cells into the splenic marginal zone. Int. Immunol. 9:27.[Abstract]
-
Neuberger, M. S. 1997. Antigen receptor signaling gives lymphocytes a long life. Cell 90:971.[ISI][Medline]
-
Lam, K. P., Khun, R. and Rajewsky, K. 1997. In vivo ablation of surface immunoglobulin on mature B cells by inducible gene targeting results in rapid cell death. Cell 90:1073.[ISI][Medline]
-
Irving, B. A., Alt, F. W. and Killeen, N. 1998. Thymocyte development in the absence of pre-T cell receptor extracellular immunoglobulin domains. Science 280:905.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Pillai, S. 1999. The chosen few? Positive selection and the generation of naive B lymphocytes. Immunity 10:493.[ISI][Medline]
-
Cascalho, M., Ma, A., Lee, S., Masat, L. and Wabl, M. 1996. A quasi-monoclonal mouse. Science 272:1649.[Abstract]
-
Hachemi-Rachedi, S., Cumano, A., Drapier, A. M., Cazenave, P. A. and Sanchez, P. 1997. Does positive selection determine the B cell repertoire? Eur. J. Immunol. 27:1069.[ISI][Medline]
-
Sonoda, E., Pewznerjung, Y., Schwers, S., Taki, S., Jung, S., Eilat, D. and Rajewsky, K. 1997. B cell development under condition of allelic inclusion. Immunity 6:225.[ISI][Medline]
-
Sanchez, P., Drapier, A. M., Cohen-Tannoudji, M., Colucci, E., Babinet, C. and Cazenave, P. A. 1994. Compartmentalization of
subtype expression in the B cell repertoire of mice with a disrupted or normal C
gene segment. Int. Immunol. 6:711.[Abstract]
-
Geckeler, W., Faversham, J. and Cohn, M. 1978. On a regulatory gene controlling the expression of the murine
1 light chain. J. Exp. Med. 148:1122.[Abstract]
-
Epstein, R., Lehmann, K. and Cohn, M. 1983. Induction of lambda 1-immunoglobulin is determined by a regulatory gene (r lambda 1) linked (or identical) to the structural (c lambda 1) gene. J. Exp. Med. 157:1681.[Abstract]
-
Kim, J. K., Kurtz, B., Huszar, D. and Storb, U. 1994. Crossing the SJL
locus into
-knockout mice reveals a dysfunction of the
1-containing immunoglobulin receptor in B cell differentiation. EMBO J. 13:827.[Abstract]
-
Okamoto, M., Murakami, M., Shimizu, A., Ozaki, S., Tsubata, T., Kumagai, S. and Honjo, T. 1992. A transgenic model of autoimmune hemolytic anemia. J. Exp. Med. 175:71.[Abstract]
-
Chih-Ping, L., Tucken, P. W., Mushinski, J. and Blattner, F. R. 1980. Mapping of heavy chain genes for mouse immunoglobulin M and D. Science 209:1348.[ISI][Medline]
-
Amor, M., Guénet, J. L., Bonhomme, F. and Cazenave, P.-A. 1983. Genetic polymorphism of
1 and
3 immunoglobulin light chains in the Mus subgenus. Eur. J. Immunol. 13:312.[ISI][Medline]
-
Sanchez, P., Nadel, B. and Cazenave, P.-A. 1991. V
J
rearrangements are restricted within a VJC recombination unit in the mouse. Eur. J. Immunol. 21:907.[ISI][Medline]
-
Coffman, R. L. 1982. Surface antigen expression and immunoglobulin gene rearrangement during mouse pre-B cell development. Immunol. Rev. 69:5.[ISI][Medline]
-
Collins, L. S. and Dorshkind, K. 1987. A stromal cell line from myeloid long-term bone marrow cultures can support myelopoiesis and B lymphopoiesis. J. Immunol. 138:1082.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Rolink, A., Kudo, A., Karasuyama, H., Kikuchi, Y. and Melchers, F. 1991. Long-term proliferating early pre B cell lines and clones with the potential to develop to surface Ig-positive, mitogen reactive B cells in vitro and in vivo. EMBO J. 10:327.[Abstract]
-
Sanchez, P., Rueff-Juy, D., Boudinot, P., Hachemi-Rachedi, S. and Cazenave, P. A. 1996. The lambda B cell repertoire of kappa-deficient mice. Int. Rev. Immunol. 13:357.[Medline]
-
Boudinot, P., Rueff-Juy, D., Drapier, A.-M., Cazenave, P.-A. and Sanchez, P. 1995. Various VJ rearrangement efficiencies shape the mouse
B cell repertoire. Eur. J. Immunol. 25:2499.[ISI][Medline]
-
Rolink, A., Ghia, P., Grawunder, U., Haasner, D., Karasuyama, H., Kalberer, C., Winkler, T. and Melchers, F. 1995. In-vitro analyses of mechanisms of B-cell development. Semin. Immunol. 7:155.[Medline]
-
LeBien, T. W. 1998. B-cell lymphopoiesis in mouse and man. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 10:188.[ISI][Medline]
-
MacLennan, I. C. 1998. B-cell receptor regulation of peripheral B cells. Curr. Opin. Immunol. 10:220.[ISI][Medline]
-
Arp, B., McMullen, M. D. and Storb, U. 1982. Sequences of immunoglobulin lambda 1 genes in a lambda 1 defective mouse strain. Nature 298:184.[ISI][Medline]
-
Leitzgen, K., Knittler, M. R. and Haas, I. G. 1997. Assembly of immunoglobulin light chains as a prerequisite for secretion. A model for oligomerisation-dependent subunit folding. J. Biol. Chem. 272:3117.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Watanabe, N., Nisitani, S., Ikuta, K., Susuki, M., Chiba, T. and Honjo, T. 1999. Expression levels of B cell surface immunoglobulin regulate efficiency of allelic exclusion and size of autoreactive B-1 cell compartment. J. Exp. Med. 190:461.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Lam, K.-P. and Rajewsky, K. 1999. B cell antigen receptor specificity and surface density together determine B-1 versus B-2 cell development. J. Exp. Med. 190:471.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Heinzelmann, A., Kumar, S., Noggle, S., Goedegebuur, I., Sauer, K. M., Rath, S. and Durdik, J. M. 1998. Deletion of a recombined Ig heavy chain transgene in B-lineage cells of transgenic mice. J. Immunol. 161:666.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Cyster, J. G., Healy, J. I., Kishihara, K., Mak, T. W., Thomas, M. L. and Goodnow, C. C. 1996. Regulation of B-lymphocyte negative and positive selection by tyrosine phosphatase CD45. Nature 381:325.[ISI][Medline]
-
Martin, F., Won, W.-J. and Kearney, J.-F. 1998. Generation of the germline peripheral B cell repertoire: VH81X-lambda B cells are unable to complete all developmental programs. J. Immunol. 160:3748.[Abstract/Free Full Text]
-
Nemazee, D. 1996. Antigen receptor `capacity' and the sensitivity of self-tolerance. Immunol. Today 17:25.[ISI][Medline]
-
Luning Prak, E., Trounstine, M., Huszar, D. and Weigert, M. 1994. Light chain editing in
-deficient animals: a potential mechanism of B cell tolerance. J. Exp. Med. 180:1805.[Abstract]
-
Anderson, J., Melchers, F. and Rolink, A. 1995. Stimulation by T cell independent antigens can relieve the arrest of differentiation of immature auto-reactive B cells in the bone marrow. Scand. J. Immunol. 42:21.[ISI][Medline]