1 Endocrinology Unit, School of Molecular and Clinical Medicine, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, U.K
2 Department of Medicine, Division of Diabetes, University of Helsinki, Helsinki, Finland
3 Department of Surgical Sciences, Division of Clinical Physiology, Karolinska Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden
![]() |
ABSTRACT |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
The enzyme 11ß-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 1 (11HSD1) is widely expressed, including in the liver and adipose (1). It catalyzes regeneration of the glucocorticoid cortisol from its inactive 11-keto metabolite cortisone, thus amplifying glucocorticoid receptor activation independently of the level of cortisol in the blood. Its potential importance as a tissue-specific regulator of metabolism is illustrated in animals. Transgenic mice overexpressing 11HSD1 in adipocytes (2,3) develop central obesity with hyperinsulinemia, hyperglycemia, hyperlipidemia, and hypertension. Mice overexpressing 11HSD1 in the liver develop insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and hypertension without obesity (4). Conversely, 11HSD1 knockout mice are protected from obesity, hyperglycemia, and dyslipidemia on high-fat feeding (57). Moreover, inbred rodent models of obesity and diabetes show tissue-specific dysregulation of 11HSD1 (2,8,9). Most commonly, 11HSD1 is reduced in the liver but increased in adipose tissue.
Similar tissue-specific dysregulation of 11HSD1 has been inferred in human obesity from indirect measurements. The rate of conversion of an oral dose of cortisone into cortisol in peripheral plasma is impaired (1012), suggesting downregulation of hepatic 11HSD1. In subcutaneous adipose tissue, 11HSD1 activity and mRNA are increased in biopsies from obese subjects in most studies (1117), and in vivo microdialysis confirms increased cortisone-to-cortisol conversion in obesity (18). Furthermore, the nonselective 11HSD1 inhibitor carbenoxolone enhances insulin sensitivity in healthy men and in patients with type 2 diabetes (19,20). Against this background, development of selective 11HSD1 inhibitors has become a highly competitive goal for the pharmaceutical industry, with some evidence of success (21,22).
However, fundamental questions remain about the role of 11HSD1 in humans. Crucially, the magnitude of regeneration of cortisol within individual tissues has not been quantified; therefore, consequences of dysregulation or enzyme inhibition remain uncertain. A suspicion persists that 11HSD1 catalyzes dehydrogenase conversion of cortisol to cortisone under some circumstances (23); therefore, enzyme expression or activity in vitro cannot be extrapolated in vivo. Studies measuring endogenous cortisol and cortisone (24) or dilution of stable isotope cortisol tracer (25) in the hepatic vein suggest that there is substantial splanchnic regeneration of cortisol but do not distinguish activity in the liver from the contribution of visceral adipose tissue, which in vitro studies suggest is substantial (26). Unfortunately, measurement of cortisol in the portal vein has only been achieved during surgery, when high stress levels probably obscure any influence of local regeneration (27). In subcutaneous adipose tissue, venous sampling has indicated local regeneration of cortisol, but the errors of measurement are wide (28), while in vivo microdialysis provides relative rather than absolute quantification (18).
We aimed to establish the relative contribution of liver and extrahepatic splanchnic tissues (principally visceral adipose tissue) to total splanchnic cortisol production in healthy men. This was achieved using hepatic vein catheterization and systemic infusion of 9,11,12,12-[2H4]-cortisol (d4-cortisol) (29) (Fig. 1). d4-Cortisol is converted to 9,12,12-[2H3]-cortisone (d3-cortisone) by 11HSD type 2 in the kidney, and d3-cortisone is converted to d3-cortisol by 11HSD1. Unlike cortisol or d3-cortisol, d4-cortisol is not regenerated by 11HSD1; for this reason, dilution of d4-cortisol tracer with either cortisol or d3-cortisol in a selective venous sample reflects 11HSD1 activity in the tissues draining to that vein. Whole splanchnic cortisol generation was measured in steady state, and hepatic production of cortisol was measured after oral administration of cortisone. Subtraction of hepatic production from splanchnic production allowed calculation of cortisol production from extrahepatic visceral tissues.
|
![]() |
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
Protocol.
Subjects took 1 mg dexamethasone by mouth at 2300, fasted thereafter, and attended the clinical research center at 0700. Cannulae were positioned in an antecubital vein for infusions and in a dorsal vein of a hand placed in a hot box for sampling arterialized blood.
Intravenous infusions commenced at 0730 (t = 0 h) and continued for 6.5 h (Fig. 2). Dexamethasone was infused at 4 µg/min to suppress ACTH and endogenous cortisol production. 9,11,12,12-[2H4]-Cortisol (Cambridge Isotopes, Andover, MA) (Fig. 1) was infused at 40% enrichment in unlabeled cortisol at 1.74 mg/h after a priming dose of 3.6 mg.
|
At t = 3.5 h, cortisone acetate (25 mg) was administered by mouth. Sampling continued until t = 5 h when the hepatic vein catheter was removed (Fig. 2).
Laboratory analyses
Steroid analysis by gas chromatography mass spectrometry.
Plasma (1.5 ml) containing epicortisol (500 ng) was extracted with chloroform (15 ml) and methoxime-trimethylsilyl derivatives prepared as described (29). Derivatized steroids were quantified using a Polaris Q ion trap electron-impact mass spectrometer with a Trace gas chromatograph (Thermofinnigan, Winsford, U.K.) with electron energy 70 eV, source temperature 200°C, and interface temperature 280°C. Separation used a DB17MS column (column length 15 m, internal diameter 0.25 mm, film thickness 0.25 µm; J&W Scientific). Oven temperature was 60°C and was increased after 1 min at 30°C per min to 200°C, then increased at 10°C per min to 300°C, and then maintained for 8 min. Injection temperature was 240°C. Quantitation was against two calibration lines for quantities (50250 ng) and enrichment (1050%) of cortisol. Enrichment was corrected for background interference from naturally occurring isotopes.
ICG analysis.
ICG concentrations were measured using high-performance liquid chromatography as described (30).
Data interpretation
Steady-state calculations.
Concentrations of cortisol, [2H4]-cortisol (d4-cortisol), and [2H3]-cortisol (d3-cortisol) were calculated. Enrichment of cortisol with d4-cortisol was calculated as peak area of d4-cortisol/[peak areas of (d4-cortisol + cortisol)]. Enrichment with d3-cortisol was calculated as peak area of d3-cortisol/[peak areas of (d3-cortisol + d4-cortisol)]. The tracer-to-tracee ratios (TTRs) (TTRs of d4-cortisol to cortisol and d4-cortisol to d3-cortisol) were calculated from the peak areas. Steady-state (ss) concentrations, enrichments, and blood flows were calculated as the means for each subject between t = 3 and t = 3.5 h.
Clearances (l/min) of cortisol and d4-cortisol were calculated as the rate of infusion of cortisol or d4-cortisol divided by the steady-state concentrations of cortisol or d4-cortisol, respectively.
The rate of appearance (Ra) of endogenous cortisol (Eq. 1) and d3-cortisol (Eq. 2) were calculated in arterialized samples.
![]() | 1 |
![]() | 2 |
Tissue production of cortisol (Eq. 3) and d3-cortisol (Eq. 4) across the splanchnic bed were calculated as follows.
![]() | 3 |
![]() | 4 |
Regional cortisol production was also calculated by the alternative approach used by Basu et al. (25), as in Eq. 5.
![]() | 5 |
Nonsteady-state calculations.
Two approaches were applied to calculate rates of appearance of cortisol, using the mean data for all eight subjects: Steele equation calculations at individual time points and curve fitting of change in enrichment of d4-cortisol with time.
The Steele equation was applied using Eq. 6, where t = time, V = volume of distribution, C(t) = total cortisol concentration at time = t, and E(t) = TTR d4-cortisol/cortisolvenous at time = t. The volume of distribution was assumed to be 12 l, as has been widely used for glucose (31). However, V for cortisol could not be measured in the current studies, so the rates estimated from the Steele equation were used only to estimate the time course of appearance of cortisol, not to quantify absolute cortisol production rates.
![]() | 6 |
![]() |
|
![]() |
![]() | 7 |
Estimating extrahepatic (visceral) versus hepatic contribution to splanchnic cortisol generation.
To estimate the extent to which hepatic metabolism of cortisone to cortisol accounts for cortisol generation in the whole of the splanchnic circulation, and thereby to deduce the likely contribution of visceral adipose tissue, the following applies, where Ra is the net rate of appearance.
![]() |
![]() | 8 |
Ra cortisolsplanchnic ss is known (Eq. 3) and Ra cortisolhepatic in nonsteady state at time = t is known (Eq. 7). Cortisoneliver t was estimated as follows. Since very little cortisone was detected in hepatic vein, bioavailability of cortisone was calculated as a percentage of the administered dose from the area under the total curve of cortisol appearance (fitted as above). The time-course of absorption was assumed to be distributed as a symmetrical bell-shaped curve with a peak at the time of maximum rate of production of cortisol, calculated in Eq. 6. Thus, the amount of cortisone reaching the liver between time 0 and the time of the peak rate of appearance of cortisol was estimated as half the administered dose x bioavailability %/100. The mean concentration of cortisone reaching the liver between administration and the peak rate of appearance of cortisol was then calculated as the amount of cortisone reaching the liver x hepatic blood flow, assuming equal mixing between blood from portal vein and hepatic artery.
The two unknown variables in Eq. 8 (cortisone concentration reaching the liver in steady state and rate of visceral appearance of cortisol) were then modeled to identify combinations that fit the observed data. At each estimated cortisone concentration reaching the liver in steady state, the rate of extraction of cortisone by visceral tissues was calculated using Eq. 9.
![]() | 9 |
Equation 8 was solved by finding an estimated cortisone concentration reaching the liver in steady state at which the visceral cortisone extraction rate was equal to the visceral cortisol production rate.
Statistical comparisons.
Data were compared using paired Students t tests and are presented as means ± SE.
![]() |
RESULTS |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
|
Applying Eq. 5, as suggested by Basu et al. (25), gave similar results. Cortisol production was 34 ± 17 nmol/min (P = 0.65 vs. result from Eq. 3 above), and d3-cortisol "production" was 0.9 ± 3.2 nmol/min (not different from zero or from result from Eq. 4 above). Equations 3 and 4 are preferred, however, because they are based on peak area ratios and do not require extrapolation from calibration lines to calculate steroid concentrations and are, therefore, less prone to error. Splanchnic cortisol uptake was 23 ± 12 nmol/min.
Hepatic "first-pass" metabolism of cortisone in nonsteady state.
Following administration of cortisone (69 µmol) by mouth, cortisol concentrations rose in hepatic vein earlier than in arterialized blood (time to peak 76 ± 16 vs. 118 ± 11 min; P = 0.01). d4-Cortisol enrichment fell in both hepatic vein and arterialized blood (Fig. 3), but this occurred within 5 min of dose administration in hepatic vein and after 35 min in arterialized blood, and tended to be more pronounced in hepatic vein (24.5 ± 3.0 vs. 22.0 ± 2.2%; P = 0.07).
The peak rate of appearance of cortisol (Eq. 6) occurred 35 min after the dose (Table 2). This calculation assumes mixing of the cortisol generated only within the "immediate" pool with an estimated size of 12 l (31). Therefore, the accuracy of time points beyond 45 min is questionable, given that distribution will be occurring into the adipose and extracellular fluid compartments. Over the first 35 min, 29 µmol of cortisol was generated, equivalent to 42% of the administered cortisone dose. Assuming a symmetrical bell-shaped curve for cortisol generation (as supported by the calculated rates in Table 2) and complete conversion of "available" cortisone to cortisol, this indicates a bioavailability of 84% and complete absorption of the dose over 70 min. Curve fitting of change in d4-cortisol enrichment revealed a total area under the curve of 5,150 ± 730%.min (hepatic vein) or 5,093 ± 1,234%.min (arterialized blood), which equates with a very similar bioavailability of cortisone of 85%. The remainder of the cortisone dose was either not absorbed or metabolized by other enzymes in liver, since only a trivial rise in cortisone was detected in the hepatic vein (data not shown).
|
Estimating extrahepatic (visceral adipose tissue) cortisol generation.
Table 3 shows models for the steady-state conditions that would satisfy the observed steady-state splanchnic rate of cortisol generation of 45 nmol/min with an observed steady-state arterialized cortisone concentration of 92 nmol/l, given a rate of conversion of oral cortisone to cortisol by the liver of 156 nmol/min at a cortisone concentration of 337 nmol/l. The predicted steady-state concentration of cortisone being delivered to the liver at which rates of visceral adipose production of cortisol and extraction of cortisone are identical is 67 nmol/l. Under these conditions, the predicted hepatic rate of cortisol generation was 15.2 nmol/min, and the calculated visceral cortisol production and visceral cortisone extraction were both 29.8 nmol/min. Other solutions to the model are unfeasible because they demand a mismatch between production of cortisol and extraction of cortisone by visceral adipose tissue.
|
![]() |
DISCUSSION |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|
The absolute rate of splanchnic cortisol production depends on cortisone concentrations, which are typically lower in healthy men (at 5070 nmol/l [24]) than those achieved during prolonged cortisol infusion here. The relative rate of splanchnic and systemic cortisol production depends upon adrenal secretion, which varies widely according to ACTH levels. Here, ACTH was suppressed with dexamethasone; therefore, the similarity between splanchnic and whole-body cortisol production suggests that extrasplanchnic tissues do not make a major contribution to nonACTH-dependent cortisol production. Dexamethasone is converted by 11HSD2 to 11-dehydrodexamethasone, which might compete with cortisone for metabolism by 11HSD1 (32); however, given the low concentrations of this metabolite in plasma (which are predicted to be 10 nmol/l at this infusion rate), we think this is unlikely to have influenced the results.
The only enzyme known to produce cortisol that is expressed in splanchnic tissues (i.e., in liver and visceral adipose tissue) is 11HSD1. In principle, 11HSD1 can be measured selectively by differential production of d3-cortisol rather than d4-cortisol (Fig. 1). However, by contrast with our previous experience in systemic measurements (18,29), we found measurements of d3-cortisol and, in particular, d3-cortisone to be less reliable than d4-cortisol, cortisol, or cortisone in detecting relatively small arteriovenous differences. As a result, the estimation of substrate d3-cortisone concentration is subject to error, and rates of d3-cortisol generation cannot be compared directly with those of cortisol. d3-Cortisol generation in the whole body tended to be higher than in the splanchnic circulation, consistent with extraadrenal nonsplanchnic 11HSD1 activity. Production of cortisol in other extraadrenal organs has rarely been assessed using tracers in humans. Basu et al. (25) found no cortisol production into the femoral vein, although this is not surprising given that most of leg circulation is in skeletal muscle where 11HSD1 expression is trivial. It will be important to extend the current approach to measurements in subcutaneous adipose tissue.
We have not established whether 11ß-dehydrogenase conversion of cortisol to cortisone, catalyzed by either 11HSD isozyme, occurs in the splanchnic circulation. The low levels of d3-cortisone and cortisone in hepatic vein precluded the calculation of tracer dilution for cortisone.
Portal vein cannulations cannot be performed ethically in healthy humans, so we relied on indirect calculation of extrahepatic splanchnic cortisol generation. Extrapolation of the hepatic cortisol production rate following oral cortisone to deduce the relative contribution of liver and extrahepatic splanchnic tissues in steady state required some assumptions. Crucially, it is assumed that the rate of appearance of cortisol changes in linear proportion to cortisone concentration in the range of 0 to 700 nmol/l (the maximum concentration estimated after oral cortisone administration). This has not been tested directly but is consistent with the Km of human 11HSD1 for cortisone concentrations of
1 µmol/l (33), which suggests that it is unlikely to reach Vmax in physiological conditions and with studies of 11HSD1 in isolated perfused liver in animals that demonstrate linear increases in product generation at substrate concentrations in excess of 1 µmol/l (34,35). A second assumption is that the bioavailability of cortisone can be inferred from the proportion that appears as cortisol. However, this is likely to underestimate rather than overestimate bioavailability. The model in Table 3 is remarkably robust to increases in cortisone bioavailability; for example, if bioavailability is assumed to be 100% rather than 84%, then the estimated cortisone concentration reaching the liver at steady state is 65 rather than 67 nmol/l, scarcely affecting the estimates of relative extrahepatic visceral and hepatic cortisol production. A third assumption is that oral administration of cortisone results in generation of cortisol exclusively in the liver. However, any additional conversion (e.g., in blood vessels or mesenteric adipose tissue) would result in overestimation of the hepatic rate of cortisol generation and hence underestimation of the rate in visceral adipose tissue; therefore, the major conclusion that extrahepatic tissues contribute to splanchnic cortisol generation would not be undermined. Finally, the model assumes that there is equimolar exchange between cortisone extraction and cortisol production in extrahepatic splanchnic tissues; therefore, rates of disappearance of cortisone and production of cortisol are identical. From what is known of adipose steroid metabolism, it is a reasonable assumption that there is no additional cortisone extraction other than by 11HSD1, since the other enzyme that metabolizes cortisone in liver, 5ß-reductase, has not been reported in adipose tissue.
Measurement of peripheral venous plasma cortisol after an oral dose of cortisone has been used extensively to measure hepatic 11HSD1 (1012,36,37). Our findings validate this, since there was a close relationship between results in hepatic vein and in peripheral plasma, albeit the peripheral changes occurred later. This emphasizes that hepatic first-pass metabolism is highly efficient at converting cortisone to cortisol, allowing little "leak" of cortisone into the systemic circulation (38) and hence little opportunity for 11HSD1 in other tissues to contribute. In contrast, in evaluating whole-body 11HSD1, our data illustrate that there are substantial contributions from both liver and visceral adipose tissue; thus, the tissue-specific dysregulation proposed in obesity, with decreased 11HSD1 in liver and increased 11HSD1 in adipose (11), may not alter either total splanchnic or whole-body regeneration of cortisol (18).
We have estimated the likely impact of 11HSD1 on cortisol concentrations in the portal vein. The incremental increase in cortisol concentrations between arterial blood and portal vein was estimated at 37 nmol/l. In conditions where cortisol levels are elevated and variable, it may not be possible to detect such a small increment (27). However, the impact on intracellular cortisol concentrations in cells expressing 11HSD1 is much greater and has not been estimated here. In mice, transgenic overexpression of 11HSD1 in adipose results in a 2.7-fold increase in enzyme activity and a twofold increase in visceral fat mass, which is associated with an 500 nmol/l increase in portal vein corticosterone concentrations (2). This suggests a similar order of magnitude of the influence of visceral 11HSD1 on portal vein glucocorticoid levels in mice (
90 nmol/l) as in men (
37 nmol/l).
In summary, these results confirm the substantial magnitude of cortisol regeneration from cortisone within the splanchnic circulation and suggest that an important component is from nonhepatic tissue, probably visceral adipose tissue. This is a key finding in interpreting the likely impact of altered 11HSD1 expression and activity in obesity and other diseases and in predicting the likely benefits of 11HSD1 inhibition.
![]() |
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
---|
We are grateful to Alison Ayres, Eva-Lena Forsberg, Monika Jurkiewicz, Alice Skogholm, and Agneta Reinholdsson for excellent technical assistance.
![]() |
FOOTNOTES |
---|
Address correspondence and reprint requests to Professor Brian R. Walker, Endocrinology Unit, School of Molecular and Clinical Medicine, University of Edinburgh, Western General Hospital, Edinburgh, EH4 2XU, U.K. E-mail: b.walker{at}ed.ac.uk
Received for publication December 16, 2004 and accepted in revised form January 27, 2005
11HSD1, 11ß-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase type 1; ICG, indocyanin green; TTR, tracer-to-tracee ratio
![]() |
REFERENCES |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
---|