Address supplied; postal correspondence c/o British Journal of Psychiatry, 17 Belgrave Square, London SW1X 8PG,UK. E-mail: robertfearn{at}yahoo.co.uk
The debate rages between Schlesinger (2004) and Wills (2004) over the evidence for a link between mental illness and creativity, but I believe that their focus is wrong.
Most studies to date have either focused on anecdotal (biographical) evidence or have been methodologically flawed retrospective cohort studies, and all would rate low on the hierarchy of evidence. Whatever the outcome of Schlesinger's and Wills' arguments, the question will remain unanswered until better controlled, masked, prospective and replicable randomised studies are carried out.
What is not in question is that mental illness is at least as prevalent in the creative community as in the general population and there are even examples of how some artists, including Dali and Munch, have used their mental illness to feed into the creative process (Saloman, 1996; Rothenberg, 2001). Given the hefty side-effect profiles of most psychiatric treatments, surely the emphasis should be on how best to treat such exceptional patients - indeed all patients - in a way that minimises their symptoms without rendering them incapable of practising their trade. That is, after all (at the risk of sounding naïve), naive), what we are here for.
REFERENCES
Rothenberg, A. (2001) Bipolar illness, creativity, and treatment. Psychiatric Quarterly, 72, 131 -147.[CrossRef][Medline]
Saloman, M. (1996) Raphaelesque Head Exploding, Salvador Dali. Neurosurgery, 38, 225.
Schlesinger, J. (2004) Heroic, not disordered;
creativity and mental illness revisited (letter). British Journal
of Psychiatry, 184, 363
-364.
Wills, G. (2004) Creativity and mental health
(letter). British Journal of Psychiatry,
184, 184
-185.
HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Psychiatric Bulletin | Advances in Psychiatric Treatment | All RCPsych Journals |