Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Institute of Psychiatry, King's College, London
Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, University of Manchester
Social, Genetic and Developmental Psychiatry Research Centre, Institute of Psychiatry, King's College, London, UK
Correspondence: Dr Eric Fombonne, Institute of Psychiatry, De Crespigny Park, Denmark Hill, London SE5 8AF, UK
Declaration of interest The study was funded by a special grant from the Medical Research Council.
See editorial, pp.
189190, this issue.
See part 2, pp.
218223, this issue.
ABSTRACT
Background Strong links exist between juvenile and adult depression but comorbid conduct disorder in childhood may mitigate this continuity.
Aims To test the impact of comorbid conduct disorder on psychiatric adult outcomes.
Method A group of 149 subjects assessed at the Maudsley Hospital in the period 1970-1983 and meeting DSMIV criteria for major depressive disorder with (n=53) or without (n=96) conduct disorder were interviewed 20 years later. Data were collected on the lifetime history of psychiatric disorders.
Results Adult depressive recurrence was high for major depression (62.4%) and any depression (75.2%), and survival analyses showed no difference between the two groups. The group with conduct disorders had higher rates of drug misuse and dependence, alcoholism and antisocial personality disorders.
Conclusions Adolescent depression carries an elevated risk of adult depression irrespective of comorbidity. Comorbid conduct disorder in childhood is associated with raised rates of other psychiatric outcomes.
Juvenile depression is increasing in frequency (Fombonne, 1995) and is associated with serious psychosocial impairment, increased risk of suicide and relapse during adolescence (Kovacs et al, 1984). Long-term follow-up studies have emphasised the increased risk of adult depression (Harrington et al, 1990; Rao et al, 1995; Pine et al, 1998; Weissman et al, 1999a). However, depression with a prepubertal onset is associated with a lower risk of adult depression and different family and psychosocial correlates compared with adolescent-onset depression (Harrington et al, 1997; Weissman et al, 1999a,b). Moreover, comorbid conduct disorder appears to be associated with different treatment response (Hughes et al, 1990), clinical features (Steinhausen & Reitzle, 1996; Simic & Fombonne, 2001) and adult outcomes (Harrington et al, 1991). This longitudinal study investigated further the heterogeneity of juvenile depression and more specifically reassessed the impact of comorbid conduct disorder on adult depressive recurrence.
METHOD
Participants
Patients who attended the child psychiatry department at the Maudsley
Hospital, a south London hospital, between 1970 and 1983 were targeted
(n=5380). The Maudsley item sheet database was used to select
patients for inclusion in the study. From the late 1940s onwards, item sheets
completed by mental health professionals (registrars, child psychiatry
consultants and others) have been collected and (since 1968) computerised,
providing a unique record of socio-demographic and referral data, multi-axial
diagnostic formulations and symptom counts on all patients. The subject
selection procedure is summarised in Figure
1. The database was searched for subjects presenting symptoms of
major depressive disorder (MDD), with or without symptoms of conduct disorder.
Several operational definitions were used. First, based on symptom counts,
operational definitions of both MDD and conduct disorder were used, consistent
with prior studies (see symptom lists below;
Pearce, 1978;
Harrington et al,
1990). These broad syndromic definitions were devised in order to
maximise the sensitivity of the selection process; accordingly, it was
expected that a substantial proportion of subjects would subsequently fail to
meet strict research diagnostic criteria. In order to meet criteria for the
operational definition of depression, subjects had to have a score of 2
(definitely present) for morbid depression, sadness, unhappiness and
tearfulness, associated with two other definite symptoms of depression
chosen from a list of nine associated symptoms. For conduct disorder, subjects
had to have at least two symptoms with a definite level of severity out of a
list of 12 symptoms. Subjects meeting criteria for either depression alone or
depression and conduct disorder were included in the next stage. Second, for
subjects seen from 1973 onwards, subjects with an ICD9 Axis I diagnosis
suggestive of a depressive disorder (300.4; 309.0; 309.1; 309.4;
311.x; 312.3 and 313.1) were also included
(World Health Organization,
1978). Third, subjects with an ICD9 Axis I diagnosis of
conduct disorder (312.0; 312.1; 312.8; 312.9) were also selected if they had a
depressive syndrome score of 6 or more calculated by summing the scores for
all depressive symptoms. The latter definition differed from the syndromic
definition described above by relaxing the requirement of having scores of 2
on depressive symptoms, thereby allowing subjects with low-grade but pervasive
depressive symptomatology to be included. Subjects with mental
retardation (IQ<70) or a pervasive developmental disorder were
excluded.
|
Of the 935 children selected at this stage, 645 had their medical notes retrieved and rated by an experienced child psychiatrist (see below); 245 children met criteria for MDD either without (n=148) or with (n=97) conduct disorder. These individuals were then traced for follow-up interview. Eight had died during the intervening period, and 48 could not be traced despite repeated attempts. Of the remaining 189 subjects, 40 either refused to be interviewed or repeatedly defaulted on appointments made by interviewers. The remaining 149 individuals were successfully interviewed (Fig. 1).
Measures
Childhood measures
Maudsley item sheet database. After the initial psychiatric
assessment of every patient attending the Maudsley Hospital child psychiatry
department, a summary sheet containing data on the patient's psychiatric
symptoms (0, not present; 1, minimal or dubious; 2, definitely present),
psychological, medical and socio-demographic characteristics and family
circumstances was systematically completed by medical staff, and these data
have been computerised since 1968. Data are available for 52 psychiatric
symptoms (12 emotional and 6 somatic; 12 speech, language and motor
functioning; 12 conduct symptoms; 7 disturbed relationships; and 3 other). The
reliability, internal consistency and validity of item scale scores has been
reported elsewhere (Goodman &
Simonoff, 1991; Fombonne,
1998; Moore & Fombonne,
1999; Simic & Fombonne,
2001).
Symptoms scale scores were created in order to provide more reliable
indices of baseline childhood psychopathology. We devised a depression scale
score (six items: morbid depression, sadness, unhappiness and tearfulness;
suicidal ideas, attempt or threat; school refusal or phobia; abnormally
elevated mood; disturbance of eating; disturbance of sleeping; pains of mental
origin; =0.52); an anxiety scale score (six items: morbid anxiety,
worrying or panic; situation- or object-specific fears or phobias;
ruminations, obsessions, rituals or compulsions; hypochondriasis;
depersonalisation or derealisation; conversion hysterical symptoms;
=0.51); an antisocial scale score (eleven items: morbid irritability,
screaming, tempers; disobedience; stealing; destructiveness or malicious
damage; fire-setting; truancy or staying out late; running away; sexual
misbehaviour; fighting, bullying, aggression; violent assault; other
antisocial behaviour;
=0.71); an adult relationship scale (three items:
overt disturbance of childmother relationship; overt disturbance of
childfather relationship; overt disturbance of relationship with other
adults;
=0.65); and a sibling/peer relationship score (two items: overt
disturbance of patient-sibling relationship; overt disturbance of
relationships with other children;
=0.49). Original ratings (0, 1 and
2) were retained to derive these composite scores and all items contributed
only to one scale. In light of its considerable clinical significance, the
suicidality item (suicidal ideas, attempt or threat) is used on its own to
describe patient status at referral.
The following variables of the database were also used in this set of analyses: pubertal status (prepubertal, pubescent or postpubertal); parent/sibling lifetime history of suicide or psychiatric contact (positive or not); family circumstances of the child (living with both parents v. other situations); brought before the juvenile court at any time (no v. police caution or juvenile court attendance); and social class. All these variables had been recorded with a stable format throughout the study period.
Ratings of medical notes. All the medical, social, educational and psychological data for subjects meeting at least one selection criterion were carefully reviewed by an experienced child psychiatrist and rated using DSMV diagnostic criteria for MDD and conduct disorder (American Psychiatric Association, 1994). The presence of other comorbid disorders at presentation was separately recorded using ICD10 clinical guidelines (World Health Organization, 1992). Other data were extracted on an ad hoc questionnaire covering socio-demographic details, referral origin, family psychiatric history, obstetric and birth information, history of any developmental delay or abnormality, physical health, hospital admissions, current weight and height, pubertal status, school attendance and achievement, as well as peer relationships. Psychometric data (mostly from the results on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (Wechsler, 1974)) were also extracted when present. Family relationships were evaluated from the original psychiatric assessment and reports by other agencies. In addition, components of the psychiatric intervention were noted, including the use of family, individual or other forms of psychotherapy, any prescription of antidepressants and of other drugs either before or after the initial Maudsley assessment, and other interventions. In-patient admissions at the Maudsley and Bethlem Hospitals were recorded.
Adult follow-up measures
Lifetime rates of specific psychiatric disorders were measured using a
revised semi-structured version of the Schedule for Affective Disorders and
SchizophreniaLifetime version (SADSL;
Harrington et al,
1988). Diagnoses were made according to the revisions of the
Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC; Spitzer
et al, 1978; Mazure
& Gershon, 1979). Major depression was therefore diagnosed
with a 4-week duration and social impairment criteria. Simple phobias with no
significant impairment did not count towards a diagnosis of phobic disorder.
To improve coverage, dysthymic disorder was coded using DSMIV criteria,
and eating disorders were diagnosed using DSMIIIR criteria
(American Psychiatric Association,
1987). Diagnostic hierarchies were removed to allow comorbid
patterns between disorders to be fully observed.
Other data were collected on adult social functioning, family psychiatric history, childhood experiences of care and abuse, life events, social support, neuroticism and psychological characteristics, and use of services. Criminal records and death certificates were also available.
Data collection procedures
Participants were located through the Central Register of the National
Health Service. A letter of information was sent, followed shortly afterwards
by a home visit by one interviewer. Repeated visits were made in the evening
or at weekends in order to establish contact with the subject. Most interviews
were completed in two sessions of 3-4 hours. A small payment was available for
out-of-pocket expenses to facilitate participation.
Data were collected by four female interviewers during the period 1994 to 1999. All had a master's degree or equivalent educational attainment and had prior experience of working with subjects with mental illness. Interviewers were trained to apply the measures through a combination of teaching tapes and videos, role play and pilot interviews. Interviews were audiotaped unless the respondent objected. During fieldwork, joint interviews were performed by a pair of interviewers on several occasions. Interviewers were blind to childhood diagnosis. To maintain blindness during the assessment, all interviews started with the SADSL focusing on life after the respondent's 17th birthday. After each interview, interviewers wrote detailed vignettes on positive screens of the SADSL. These vignettes were scored independently by other interviewers and the first author blind to childhood diagnosis. Rating meetings were held regularly and rating discrepancies were resolved by consensus.
Interrater reliability
A subsample of medical notes chosen at random in three groups
subjects with other psychiatric disorders excluded from the study
(n=15), subjects with MDD (n=25) and subjects with both
conduct disorder and MDD (CDMDD) (n=19) were rated
blindly by an independent rater. The sample available consisted of 59 subjects
(mean age 13.3 years at attendance). The interrater agreement was good for
eight depressive symptoms (median =0.64) although it was low
(
=0.11) for one symptom (retardation/agitation) with a very low
frequency; otherwise,
coefficients ranged from 0.51 to 0.90 for the
seven other symptoms. Agreement was excellent on the overall diagnosis of MDD
(
=0.956). Not surprisingly, agreement for conduct symptoms was better
(median
=0.825), and agreement was also very high on an overall
diagnosis of conduct disorder (
=0.965).
Interrater reliability coefficients for SADSL ratings of depressive
disorders were as follows: major depression, =0.78; minor depression,
=0.52; dysthymic disorders,
=0.53; and any depressive disorder,
=0.90. Agreements for other disorders were: Briquet's disorder,
=0.55; generalised anxiety disorder,
=0.68; phobic disorder,
=0.78; obsessivecompulsive disorder,
=0.48; any anxiety
disorder,
=0.77; bipolar disorders,
=0.38; any eating disorder,
=0.78; and excellent (
>0.80) for all other disorders. Lower
values of
mostly reflected lower base rates for some disorders.
Statistical analyses
Univariate comparisons were performed using the 2, Fisher's
exact and Student's t tests. Reliability was assessed with Cohen's
coefficient for categorical measures. The effect of comorbid conduct
disorder on rates of adult disorders was assessed with logistic regression
models controlling for age and gender. To adjust for unequal observation
times, Cox proportional hazards models were fitted to the data and relative
risks of adult MDD according to childhood comorbidity status were estimated.
Survival functions were calculated with the KaplanMeier estimator, with
age of onset at the first episode of depressive recurrence as the dependent
event. Subjects free of any MDD relapse during their adult years were
right-censored. Differences between survival functions were examined with the
log-rank test. Throughout, a conventional P value of 0.05 was
retained as the level of statistical significance.
RESULTS
Interviewed v. non-interviewed subjects
Of the 245 subjects included in the study, 8 (5 men) had died by the time
they were traced. Further details on suicidal deaths are provided in a
companion paper (Fombonne et al,
2001, this issue). The rates of completed interviews did not
significantly differ between diagnostic groups: 67.5% v. 58.2%;
2=1.35, d.f.=1, NS. Excluding untraced subjects, refusal rate
was 21.2% (40/189) with no difference between the two diagnostic groups (21.3%
v. 20.9%;
2=0.001, d.f.=1, NS). Differences between
interviewed and non-interviewed subjects were investigated on 14 baseline
psychiatric measures and demographic characteristics available from the item
sheet computerised database; these included gender, age at Maudsley
attendance, year of Maudsley attendance, family situation, social class,
pubertal status, psychiatric family history, suicidality at presentation,
contacts with the juvenile court and the scores on the five item sheet scales.
Preliminary analyses did not show differences between non-interviewed and
untraced subjects. Accordingly, they were pooled together in a single
non-interviewed group.
Within the MDD group, the only difference found indicated a higher
proportion of men in the non-interviewed subjects compared with the
interviewees (60.0% v. 38.5%; 2=6.1, d.f.=1,
P=0.014); all other comparisons were non-significant. Within the
CDMDD group, the only difference found was for the peer/sibling
disturbances scale score, which was slightly higher in the interviewed group
than in the non-interviewed subjects (2.38 v. 1.76; t=2.2,
d.f.=89, P=0.03). The proportion of men was slightly higher in the
non-interviewed group (52.6% v. 41.5%) but not significantly so.
Thus, on the whole, there were few differences between baseline
characteristics and follow-up interview status in both groups. In particular,
levels of depressive symptoms were comparable in both groups and, for the
CDMDD group, levels of conduct symptomatology were also at similar
levels according to interview status. Within the CDMDD group, the rates
of combined criminal offences in adulthood were also at roughly similar levels
for interviewed and non-interviewed subjects (39.6% v. 52.6%;
two-tailed Fisher's exact test, P=0.286); however, the tendency
towards higher rates of criminality in non-interviewed subjects was also
noticed when more serious offences only were considered (1.9% v.
13.2%; two-tailed Fisher's exact test, P=0.078).
Follow-up sample: childhood data
The sample predominantly comprised patients in their mid-adolescent years,
with only 16.1% of subjects under the age of 12 years. Similarly, the
proportion of prepubertal children was low (19.7%) compared with that of
postpubertal patients (57.7%). There was a marked preponderance of girls in
the sample, with no difference between the two groups. However, as reported in
other studies, the proportion of males was strongly associated with pubertal
status (prepubertal, 75.9%; pubescent, 51.5%; postpubertal, 22.4%;
2=28.5, d.f.=2, P<0.001). There was no difference
between the groups in terms of social class, year of attendance at the
Maudsley or area of residence (Table
1).
|
Item sheet measures showed comparable levels of depressive symptomatology in both groups (Table 2). Anxiety symptom scores were, as expected, significantly higher in the MDD group, while the CDMDD group displayed significantly higher levels of other disturbances, particularly suicidality. Over half the sample were suicidal at the time of hospital attendance. Broadly similar results with respect to levels of depressive and conduct symptomatology were obtained with blind ratings of the notes. Although there was a significant difference in the average number of depressive symptoms, the magnitude of this difference remained small. Conduct disturbances discriminated between the groups efficiently. In line with anxiety scale scores, categorical diagnoses of comorbid anxiety were found at significantly higher rates in the MDD group. In contrast, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder and substance misuse or dependence were almost exclusively found in the CDMDD group.
|
Although IQ data were not available for about two-fifths of the sample, the proportion of subjects with IQ data did not differ importantly across groups (49% v. 34.0%; Fisher's exact test, P=0.087). Consistent with the literature, subjects with CDMDD had, on average, lower IQs. The strong differences in symptom and diagnostic profiles were not paralleled by differences in treatment data. Diverse therapeutic ingredients and modalities were used during the treatment of the index episode, often in combination, and with generally uniform frequencies across diagnostic groups. Over a quarter of the sample had been admitted for in-patient psychiatric treatment at the Maudsley and Bethlem Hospitals. As admissions before or after attendance at the Maudsley Hospital are not counted, this figure represents an underestimate of the frequency of in-patient treatment in this sample. For the 40 subjects admitted to hospital, the average length of in-patient stay was 275 days (interquartile range 82-430 days), with no difference between the two diagnostic groups (t=0.65, d.f.=38, NS). The only exception was the use of antidepressant medications. Any occurrence of antidepressant prescription either before admission or after initial presentation was counted as positive. Most prescriptions were for tricyclic antidepressants; dosages were either unavailable or not reported consistently over time, precluding further quantitative analysis. Over two-fifths of the sample (41.8%) had received antidepressant drug treatment at one time. A significant difference emerged between the two diagnostic groups, with more antidepressant prescriptions in the MDD group. In so far as such a difference did not apply to other psychotropic drugs, these findings suggest both that antidepressant prescriptions were specifically employed to match the symptomatic presentation and that depressive phenomenology might have been more easily recognised in the non-comorbid group. Electroconvulsive therapy was used in 2% of the sample (2 MDD, 1 CDMDD).
Adult rates of psychiatric disorders
The vast majority of the sample (84.6%) were in their fourth decade of
life, and over half (51%) were 35 years old or more. The mean age at follow-up
was 34.6 years (range 25.4-43.5 years, s.d.=4.1). The mean follow-up interval
was 20.7 years (range 13.0-27.7 years, s.d.=3.8). There was no difference
between the two groups with respect to these two variables.
Adult rates of psychiatric disorders apply from age 17 years onwards (Table 3). As episodes of disorders occurring in childhood or adolescence did not contribute to these figures, these rates are underestimates of true lifetime rates. Nevertheless, 86.6% of the sample reported at least one episode of psychopathology over the 21-year follow-up interval. The rate of adult MDD (62.5%) was high in the whole sample, and three-quarters of the respondents had experienced some form of depressive disorder through follow-up. Anxiety disorders (39.6%) were the second most frequent diagnoses with a typically high overlap between subtypes of anxiety disorders. Alcohol disorders were endorsed by nearly a third of the sample (32.2%). The rates of all other psychiatric disorders were lower (<20%). In particular, adult rates of bipolar disorders were only moderately raised compared with general population estimates.
|
Systematic comparisons between the two groups were undertaken with logistic regression analyses, adjusting for gender and age at follow-up. The odds ratios provide an estimate of the increase in adult rates of psychiatric disorders attributable to comorbid conduct disorder in childhood. Contrary to one of our main hypotheses, the MDD and CDMDD groups showed strictly comparable levels of MDD recurrence in adulthood. This held true when the definition of depression was widened to include minor depression and dysthymic disorder. Three-quarters of the subjects in each group had experienced at least one episode or form of affective illness. If anything, there was a trend for the comorbid group to have higher rates of minor forms of affective illness which just reached the level of statistical significance for minor depression. Survival models confirmed the lack of difference in risk of depressive recurrence when comparing the CDMDD group with the MDD group (relative risk 0.95, 95% CI 0.62-1.46). Figure 2 shows the proportion of subjects in each group remaining free from MDD recurrence from age 17 years up to 43 years. The timing of MDD relapse during the follow-up period was similar in the two groups, with no statistical difference between the two survival curves (log-rank test 0.05, d.f.=1, NS). The median survival times were 30 years (95% CI 26-34) for the MDD group and 30 years (95% CI 22-38) for the CDMDD group. At the end of the follow-up period, the survival probabilities of remaining free of MDD relapse were similar in the MDD group (0.245) and the CDMDD group (0.309). Including minor depression in the analysis produced similar results (relative risk 1.06, 95% CI 0.69-1.62). Equally, no difference was found for survival distributions (log-rank test 0.87, d.f.=1, NS). When gender was included as covariate in the proportional hazard models, relative risks were virtually unchanged.
|
With the exception of bipolar and affective disorders, all other psychiatric disorders occurred more frequently in the CDMDD group than in the MDD group, as shown by odds ratios uniformly higher than unity. This heavy load of adult psychopathology was significantly raised for Briquet's disorder, alcohol disorders, drug misuse and dependence, and antisocial personality.
Women had significantly higher rates of MDD (OR=3.1, 95% CI 1.5-6.3), any depression (OR=3.9, 95% CI 1.8-8.7), panic disorder (OR=3.1, 95% CI 1.1-9.1), phobic disorder (OR=2.8, 95% CI 1.2-6.8), any anxiety disorder (OR=2.5, 95% CI 1.2-5.2) and eating disorders (OR=10.5, 95% CI 1.3-83.8). No significant childhood diagnosis x gender interactions were found, although a trend (P=0.04) was noted for women with CDMDD to have much higher rates of alcoholic disorders than those with MDD (51.6% v. 20.3%; P=0.004); whereas men in both groups had equal, intermediate-level rates (31.8% v. 35.1%; NS). The same trend applied to rates of drug misuse and dependency, although owing to small cell sizes, power to detect a significant interaction was seriously reduced. Nevertheless, drug misuse and dependency was significantly higher in the CDMDD group than in the MDD group, both for men (18.2% v. 0%; Fisher's exact test, P=0.016) and women (35.5% v. 1.7%; Fisher's exact test, P<0.001), the levels for women being much higher than those for men.
DISCUSSION
Methodological strengths and weaknesses
Compared with other follow-up studies of juvenile depression, this study
had both the largest sample size and the longest follow-up interval.
Therefore, most participants would have lived partly through the period at
risk for most psychiatric disorders under investigation. Second, attendance at
the Maudsley Hospital was typically during the mid-adolescence years, and few
subjects were younger than 12 years or prepubertal. Accordingly, this study
reflects mostly on the outcome of adolescent rather than child depression.
Third, although the catch-up follow-up design precluded direct standardised
assessment of patients at presentation, participants were selected according
to strict DSMIV diagnostic criteria following a detailed inspection of
their medical charts. Good interrater reliability was demonstrated in this
selection procedure, and several correlates of the disorder at presentation,
such as age and pubertal status, gender repartition, patterns of comorbid
disorders, treatment history and especially the high rate of antidepressant
treatment during the index episode, argue strongly for the validity of the
diagnostic ascertainment. Fourth, although the sample was selected in a
tertiary referral centre, the majority of the sample were local residents at
the time of first attendance at the Maudsley Hospital. Furthermore, several
patients listed as resident of the Home Counties were living in
nearby cities in Kent, and could therefore be considered as local residents
too, suggesting that the sample was reasonably representative of child
psychiatric patients in the 1970s. Fifth, by virtue of study design, the study
did not include a non-depression group (either psychiatric or normal controls)
or a group with conduct disorder only for comparison, as the focus of the
study was on assessing the impact of comorbidity on levels and mechanisms of
adult depressive recurrence. Finally, compared with the sample of patients
with depression included in a previous follow-up study at the same site
(Harrington et al,
1990), our sample was larger (149 v. 52), older (13.9
years v. 12.9 years) and with lower proportions of prepubertal
children (19.7% v. 40%) and males (39.6% v. 58%). Moreover,
the matching procedure used in the earlier study led to the inclusion of
children with comorbid conduct problems in the depression group, whereas this
was not possible in this study.
Depressive recurrence
The recurrence rates of major depression (62.6%) and of any depressive
disorder (75.2%) following an episode of childhood major depression are among
the highest reported so far. In other studies based on clinical samples,
investigators have reported a rate of 49.3% for MDD recurrence in a
longitudinal study of adolescents with depression
(Weissman et al,
1999a), a rate of 69% for MDD and 77% for any affective
disorder in a 7-year follow-up of 28 adolescents
(Rao et al, 1995), a
rate of 62% for MDD recurrence in the earlier Maudsley follow-up study
(Harrington et al,
1990) and a rate of 64% in another longitudinal study of
adolescents with depression (Garber et
al, 1988). Thus, a consistent picture emerges which
emphasises the elevated risk of adult depressive recurrence following
first-onset major depression in adolescence. The fact that continuity between
adolescent and adult depression is also found in community-based samples
(Fleming et al, 1993; Pine et al, 1998)
suggests that the findings are not a function of some form of selection bias.
Rates of other psychiatric disorders were also very high, pointing to
persistent levels of comorbidity in adult depression. Contrary to one of our
main hypotheses, however, the presence of a comorbid conduct disorder in
childhood was not associated with lower rates of major depression in adult
life compared with the non-comorbid group. In fact, the group with comorbid
conduct disorder showed an overall higher rate of any affective disorder, with
minor depression being more often reported. Survival functions were very
similar across the two groups, suggesting that the pattern of relapse over
time was closely parallel in both groups and that no difference would have
emerged even with a larger sample size. Half the sample in each group had
experienced a relapse of major depression by age 30 years, although the risk
of recurrence did extend beyond that age. The discrepancies between this study
and the previous Maudsley follow-up investigation regarding the impact of
comorbid conduct disorder on adult depressive recurrence were examined
further. In the previous study, rates of adult depression were lower in the
comorbid group although, owing to a small sample size, this difference fell
short of statistical significance
(Harrington et al,
1991). Less than half the comorbid sample met RDC criteria for MDD
in childhood, whereas this was the case for a higher proportion of subjects
(70% v. 46%) in the non-comorbid group. Moreover, within the
non-comorbid group, recurrence of MDD in adult life was clearly higher for
subjects who met RDC criteria for MDD in childhood (40% v. 13.3%);
and the only subject from the comorbid group with adult recurrence had also
met RDC criteria for MDD in adulthood (further details available from the
author upon request). Unfortunately, small sample sizes limited further
exploration of the data. Nevertheless, these trends in the data suggest that a
broader and less specific depressive construct was used to include subjects in
the previous study, whereas this study relied on narrower diagnostic criteria,
possibly leading to differences in patterns of adult depression
recurrence.
Other psychiatric outcomes
The comorbid group had increased rates of other disorders, including
antisocial personality and substance misuse/dependence disorders. The 45% rate
of adult antisocial personality disorder at follow-up in the comorbid group is
in line with rates of antisocial personality disorder found in adult follow-up
studies of youths with conduct disorder but without depression
(Zoccolillo et al,
1992). Thus, comorbid major depression does not appear to
attenuate continuities between juvenile and adult antisocial behaviours. The
rate of alcoholic disorders in the non-comorbid group suggests a developmental
pathway from juvenile depression to adult alcohol dependence which points to
negative and heterotypic long-term psychiatric outcomes. Consistent with
earlier studies reporting an association between hysteria and antisocial
disorders, both at a family level
(Cloninger et al,
1975) and at individual levels
(Robins, 1966;
Cloninger & Guze, 1970), we
also found an increased rate of Briquet's disorder in our sample which applied
to both genders in the comorbid group. All 15 subjects with Briquet's disorder
also met criteria for an affective disorder. In keeping with comorbid patterns
observed in adolescence, the rates of alcohol and drug misuse and dependence
were high in the comorbid group. The transition to bipolar disorder was, in
contrast, relatively rare, with no difference between the two groups. Our
findings concur with those from some
(Harrington et al,
1990; McCauley et al,
1993; Strober et al,
1993; Weissman et al,
1999a) but not all (Strober
& Carlson, 1982; Geller
et al, 1994; Kovacs
et al, 1994; Rao
et al, 1995) previous studies. These discrepancies in
rates of switching to bipolarity clearly require further investigation. Other
adult outcomes are discussed in a companion.
paper (Fombonne et al, 2001, this issue). While overall levels of recurrence of depression in adult life were similar in both groups, it is plausible that the mechanisms underlying recurrence of depression in adult life in subjects with MDD or CDMDD are not the same.
Clinical Implications and Limitations
CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS
LIMITATIONS
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors express their thanks to Olive McKeown, Theresa Pearce, Karen Schepman, Debbie Heavey, Val Hicks and Felicity Whitton for their contribution to the study.
REFERENCES
American Psychiatric Association (1987) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (3rd edn, revised) DSM III R). Washington, DC: APA.
American Psychiatric Association (1994) Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (4th edn) (DSM IV). Washington, DC: APA.
Cloninger, C. R. & Guze, S. B. (1970) Female criminals: their personal, familial, and social backgrounds: the relation of these to the diagnoses of sociopathy and hysteria. Archives of General Psychiatry, 23,554 -558.[CrossRef][Medline]
Cloninger, C. R., Reich, T. & Guze, S. B. (1975) The multifactorial model of disease transmission: III. Familial relationship between sociopathy and hysteria (Briquet's syndrome). British Journal of Psychiatry, 127, 23-32.[Medline]
Fleming, J., Boyle, M. & Offord, D. (1993) The outcome of adolescent depression in the Ontario Child Health Study follow-up. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 32,28 -33.[Medline]
Fombonne, E. (1995) Depressive disorders: time trends and possible explanatory mechanisms. In Psychosocial Disorders in Young People: Time Trends and Their Causes (eds M. Rutter & D. J. Smith), pp. 544-615. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons.
Fombonne, E. (1998) Suicidal behaviours in vulnerable adolescents. Time trends and their correlates. British Journal of Psychiatry, 173,154 -159.[Abstract]
Fombonne, E., Wostear, G., Cooper, V., et al
(2001) The Maudsley long-term follow-up of child and
adolescent depression. 2. Suicidality, criminality and social dysfunction in
adulthood. British Journal of Psychiatry,
179,218
-223.
Garber, J., Kriss, M., Koch, M., et al (1988) Recurrent depression in adolescents: a follow-up study. Journal of American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 27,49 -54.[Medline]
Geller, B., Fox, L. & Clark, K. (1994) Rate and predictors of prepubertal bipolarity during follow-up of 6 to 12 year old depressed children. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 35,461 -468.
Goodman, R. & Simonoff, E. (1991) Reliability of clinical ratings by trainee child psychiatrists. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 32,551 -555.
Harrington, R., Hill, J., Rutter, M., et al (1988) The assessment of lifetime psychopathology: a comparison of two interviewing styles. Psychological Medicine, 18,487 -493.[Medline]
Harrington, R., Fudge, H., Rutter, M., et al (1990) Adult outcomes of childhood and adolescent depressionI. Psychiatric status. Archives of General Psychiatry, 47,465 -473.[Abstract]
Harrington, R., Fudge, H., Rutter, M., et al (1991) Adult outcomes of childhood and adolescent depression: II. Links with antisocial disorders. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 30, 434-439[Medline]
Harrington, R., Rutter, M., Weissman, M., et al (1997) Psychiatric disorders in the relatives of depressed probands. I. Comparison of prepubertal, adolescent and early adult onset cases. Journal of Affective Disorders, 42, 9-22.[CrossRef][Medline]
Hughes, C., Sheldon, H., Preskorn, S., et al (1990) The effect of concomitant disorder in childhood depression on predicting treatment response. Psychopharmacology Bulletin, 26,235 -238.[Medline]
Kovacs, M., Feinberg, T., Crouse-Novak, M., et al (1984) Depressive disorders in childhood: (ii) a longitudinal study of the risk for a subsequent major depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 41,643 -649.[Abstract]
Kovacs, M., Akiskal, H., Gatsonis, C., et al (1994) Childhoodonset dysthymic disorder: clinical features and prospective naturalistic outcome. Archives of General Psychiatry, 51,365 -374.[Abstract]
Mazure, C. & Gershon, E. (1979) Blindness and reliability in lifetime psychiatric diagnosis. Archives of General Psychiatry, 36,521 -525.[Abstract]
McCauley, E., Myers, K., Mitchell, J., et al (1993) Depression in young people: initial presentation and clinical course. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 32,714 -722.[Medline]
Moore, J. & Fombonne, E. (1999) Psychopathology in adopted and non-adopted children: a clinical sample. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry, 69,403 -409.[Medline]
Pearce, J. (1978) The recognition of depressive disorder in children. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine, 71,494 -500.[Abstract]
Pine, D., Cohen, P., Gurley, D., et al
(1998) The risk for early adulthood anxiety and depressive
disorders in adolescents with anxiety and depressive disorders.
Archives of General Psychiatry,
55, 56-64.
Rao, U., Ryan, N., Birmaher, B., et al (1995) Unipolar depression in adolescents: clinical outcome in adulthood. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 34,466 -578.
Robins, L. (1966) Deviant Child Grown Up: A Sociological and Psychiatric Study of Sociopathic Personality. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
Simic, M. & Fombonne, E. (2001) Depressive conduct disorder: symptom patterns and correlates in referred children and adolescents. Journal of Affective Disorders, 62,175 -185.[CrossRef][Medline]
Spitzer, R., Endicott, J. & Robins, E. (1978) Research diagnostic criteria: rationale and reliability. Archives of General Psychiatry, 35,773 -782.[Abstract]
Steinhausen, H.-C. & Reitzle, M. (1996) The validity of mixed disorders of conduct and emotions in children and adolescents: a research note. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 37,339 -343.
Strober, M. & Carlson, G. (1982) Bipolar illness in adolescents with major depression. Clinical, genetic, and psychopharmacologic predictors in a three- to four-year prospective follow-up investigation. Archives of General Psychiatry, 39,549 -555.[Abstract]
Strober, M., Lampert, C., Schmidt, S., et al (1993) The course of major depressive disorder in adolescents: I. Recovery and risk of manic switching in a follow-up of psychotic and non-psychotic subtypes. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 32, 34-42.[Medline]
Wechsler, D. (1974) Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children Revised. Windsor: NFER.
Weissman, M., Wolk, S., Goldstein, R., et al
(1999a) Depressed adolescents grown up.
Journal of the American Medical Association,
281,1707
-1713.
Weissman, M., Wolk, S., Wickramaratne, P., et al
(1999b) Children with prepubertal-onset major
depressive disorder and anxiety grown up. Archives of General
Psychiatry, 56,794
-801.
World Health Organization (1978) International Classification of Diseases and Related Disorders (ICD9). Geneva: WHO.
World Health Organization (1992) The ICD 10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders: Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines. Geneva: WHO.
Zoccolillo, M., Pickles, A., Quinton, D., et al (1992) The outcome of childhood conduct disorder: implications for defining adult personality disorder and conduct disorder. Psychological Medicine, 22,971 -986.[Medline]
Received for publication March 13, 2000. Revision received October 19, 2000. Accepted for publication October 24, 2000.
Related articles in BJP: