1 Medical Clinic I and
3 II, Department of Internal Medicine and
2 Alcohology Unit, Community Medicine Department, Geneva University Hospital, Geneva, Switzerland
Received 26 March 1999; in revised form 28 June 1999; accepted 15 July 1999
Drink-driving remains a major problem of public health (Alvarez and Del Rio, 1996). One of the most controversial issues is the choice of legal limit, as the ability to drive can be affected by alcohol levels well below current legal limits (Dunbar et al., 1987
; Howat et al., 1991
; Guppy, 1994
). This study addressed the questions of the self-estimation of ability to drive, and its correlation with blood-alcohol concentration (BAC) measured with a breath-ethanol analyser in a population of non-professional male soldiers.
In November 1997, at 23:00, during the last evening of a 3-week military course, in Geneva barracks, soldiers were asked to fill in a questionnaire including birth date, CAGE test, self-evaluation of ability to drive, and self-estimation of BAC. All gave informed consent and were instructed that the legal Swiss drink-drive limit is 0.8 mg/ml (80 mg/dl). BAC was measured after the completion of the questionnaire with a Lion Alcometer SD 400TM breath-ethanol analyser. Although the gold standard for alcohol determination should be a blood testing, we decided to use a breath-ethanol analyser, as it is accepted as a reliable screening method by police authorities.
Fifty-three out of 73 men (73%) were included (15 men were sleeping and 5 were working and therefore could not participate). All had a driving licence. Median age was 28 years (range: 21 to 41 years). Forty-one were ordinary soldiers, nine under-officers, and three officers. Forty-five subjects (85%) admitted having consumed alcohol at the time of completing the questionnaire. The CAGE test was positive (2 points) in three subjects, all of whom had consumed alcohol at the time of the investigation. Among the alcohol consumers, median (range) self-estimated BAC was 0.8 mg/ml (0.1 to 1.8), and median measured BAC was 0.3 mg/ml (0 to 1.5) (P < 0.001, Wilcoxon signed ranks test). Six men had measured BAC higher than 0.8 mg/ml. Ability to drive estimations relative to BAC are reported in Table 1
, from which three points arise.
|
Second, self-reported BAC was always overestimated, when compared to measured BAC, probably because the questionnaire was performed in the early elimination phase of alcohol (Seidl et al., 1996).
Third, according to other studies (Sharman et al., 1978; Beirness, 1987
), self-estimation of ability to drive correlated with neither estimated, nor measured, BAC. Nine out of 25 (36%) subjects estimating their BAC to be above 0.8 mg/ml declared themselves to be able to drive, which meant that they were liable to break the drink-driving law in Switzerland. Conversely, 13 out of 18 (72%) who declared themselves to be unable to drive would have been allowed to according to the Swiss law.
In conclusion, most of these intoxicated soldiers (72%) would not have been committing an offence according to Swiss law, although they felt unfit to drive. With a legal drink-drive limit of 0.5 mg/ml (50 mg/dl), this proportion would have been reduced by half (39%). Although no test of competence to drive was administered in this study, the data presented do raise concerns about the relationship between perceived levels of intoxication and inability to drive and blood-alcohol level. This suggests that Swiss authorities and other countries in which the legal drink-drive limit is 0.8 mg/ml (80 mg/dl) should rethink their drink-drive policy. One suggestion is the harmonization of a maximum BAC at 0.5 mg/ml (50 mg/dl) throughout the European countries (European Transport Safety Council, 1995).
FOOTNOTES
* Author to whom correspondence and reprint requests should be addressed at: Medical Clinic I, Department of Internal Medicine, Geneva University Hospital, 24 Rue Micheli-du-Crest, CH-1211 Geneva 14, Switzerland.
REFERENCES
Alvarez, F. J. and Del Rio, M. C. (1996) Alcohol and driving. Lancet 347, 985986.
Beirness, D. J. (1987) Self-estimates of blood alcohol concentration in drinking-driving context. Drug and Alcohol Dependence 19, 7990.[ISI][Medline]
Dunbar J. A., Penttila, A. and Pikkarainen, J. (1987) Drinking and driving: choosing the legal limits. British Medical Journal 295, 14581460.[ISI][Medline]
European Transport Safety Council (1995) Reducing Traffic Injuries Resulting from Alcohol Impairment. European Transport Safety Council, Brussels.
Guppy, A. (1994) At what blood concentration should drink-driving be illegal? British Medical Journal 308, 10561057.
Howat, P., Sleet, D. and Smith, I. (1991) Alcohol and driving: is the 0.05% blood alcohol concentration limit justified? Drug and Alcohol Review 10, 151166.
Seidl, S., Scheller, M. and Reinhardt, G. (1996) Self-assessment of blood alcohol content in acute alcoholic intoxication. Blutalkohol 33, 2330.[Medline]
Sharman, J. R., Lindley, T. N. and Abernethy, M. H. (1978) Blood alcohol levels. How accurately can they be guessed? New Zealand Medical Journal 87, 438440.[ISI][Medline]